石墨烯
JASONALICEAANDMATTHEWP.A.FISHERPHYSICALREVIEWB74,075422 2006 VI.CONCLUDINGREMARKS
treatmentofdisorderandinteractionswillclearlybedesir-able,butwillnotbepursuedhere.
Evenatthecrudelevelofourtreatment,itisinterestingtocompareourpredictionsfromHartreetheorywiththehigh- eldexperimentsmentionedabovethatresolvedadditionalquantumHallstatesat =0,±1,and±4.First,HartreetheoryisconsistentwiththeappearanceofthesequantumHallstatesandalsocanpotentiallyprovideasimpleexplanationfortheconspicuousabsenceofthoseat =±3and±5—namely,alackof avorsymmetrybreakingduetotheformofthehigher-Landau-levelwavefunctions.Second,theactivationenergypredictedat =±4isgivenbytheZeemanenergyplusacontributionfromtheon-siteUthatislinearintheperpendicularmagnetic eld,thelatterbeingunchangedbytheadditionofanin-planemagnetic eldcomponent seeEq. 83 .Themeasuredenergygapforthespin-splitLandaulevelswassimilarlyfoundtobegivenbytheZeemanenergy,supplementedbyaphenomenologicalLandau-levelbroaden-ingvaryinglinearlywiththeperpendicularmagnetic eld.5IfoneinterpretsthisLandau-levelbroadeningasacontributiontotheenergysplittingarisingfromtheon-siteU,oneobtainsU 2eV,whichisoftherightorderofmagnitude.Finally,ifg BB+2u0 0 4u1 0,thenoneobtainsactivationenergiesinHartreetheorywhichareidenticalat =±1and±4,whilealargerenergyispredictedat =0 seeEqs. 83 , 86 ,and 87 .Itisintriguingtonotethatexperimentallythequan-tizedHallplateauat =0setsinatB 11T,whilethe =±1and±4plateausareresolvedatsimilar eldsaroundB 17T,whichmaybeconsistentwiththerelativemagni-tudesoftheaboveHartreeenergies.
Weemphasizethattheprecedingdiscussionisbynomeansintendedtobeconclusive,butonlytosuggestonepossiblemechanismfortheappearanceoftheadditionalquantumHallplateausathighmagnetic elds.Again,assess-ingtheoriginofthequantumHallstatesat =0and =±1requiresfurtherexperiments,whichwehopethisworkmaystimulate.Measuringtheactivationenergiesatthese llingfactorsasafunctionofanin-planemagnetic eldmaypro-videsomeguidanceastowhetherthequantumHallstatesatthese llingfactorsareduetoquantumHallferromagnetism,explicitsymmetrybreaking,orperhapssomeothermecha-nism.Forinstance,ifg BB+2u0 0 4u1 0,ourHartreees-timatespredictthatthe =0gapwillincreasewithanin-planemagnetic eldcomponent,whilethegapsat =±1willremainunchanged.Ontheotherhand,forg BB+2u0 0 4u1 0thegapsatboth =0and =±1varywithanincreasingin-plane eld,theformerdecreasingwhilethelatterincreases.
Astechnologicalprogressenablesthefabricationofhigher-qualitygraphenesamples,quantumHallferromag-netismwilllikelyprovideaninterestingavenueofexplora-tionalongtheroadtothefractionalquantumHalleffect.OneoftheremarkableaspectsofquantumHallferromagnetismingrapheneistheconnectionbetweenquantumHallphysicsoperatingonlonglengthscalesoforderthemagneticlengthandlattice-scalephysics.Theclearestmanifestationofthisinterplayoccursat llingfactors =±1andpossiblyalso =0,wherelattice-scalechargedensitywaveorder,albeitweak,coexistswiththeintegerquantumHalleffect.Estab-lishingthepresenceofsuchlattice-scalestructureexperi-mentallywouldbequiteinteresting,althoughdoingsowilllikelyprovechallengingasthesignaturesofsuchorderareexpectedtobesmall.AnotherremarkableaspectofquantumHallferromagnetismingraphenethatwouldbeworthpursu-ingisthepotentialforobservingaKosterlitz-Thoulesstran-sition,whichwearguedshouldoccurat llingfactors =±3and±5.FurtherexperimentalandtheoreticalstudiesofSkyrmionphysicsingraphenewouldalsobeinteresting.Inthemoreimmediatefuture,furtherexperimentstode-terminetheoriginoftheadditionalintegerquantumHallstatesappearingathighmagnetic eldswouldbeextremelyuseful.WehaveprovidedhereHartreeestimatesfortheac-tivationenergiesinthesestateswhich,atleastinprinciple,shouldbestraightforwardtocomparewithbyexploringthedependenceofthetransportgaponanin-planemagnetic eld.Finally,studiesthatincorporatedisorderintoouranaly-sisoftheparamagneticregimeinamoresystematicwaywouldofcoursebewelcome.
Noteaddedinproof.Aftersubmissionofthismanuscript,athirdscenariofortheappearanceofadditionalquantumHallstatesingrapheneathighmagnetic elds apartfromquantumHallferromagnetismandexplicitsymmetrybreak-ing wasproposedinRef.36basedontheformationofanexcitonicgaptogetherwithZeemansplitting.Futureexperi-mentswillhopefullyprovideinsightintowhichofthesemechanismsunderliestheinterestinghigh- eldbehaviorob-servedingraphene.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
WewouldliketothankAndreiBernevig,TaylorHughes,AllanMacDonald,andespeciallyLeonBalentsforstimulat-ingdiscussions,aswellasPhilipKimforsharingexperimen-taldatapriortopublication.ThisworkwassupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationthroughGrantsNos.PHY-9907949 M.P.A.F. andDMR-0529399 J.A.andM.P.A.F. .
1K.
S.Novoselov,A.K.Geim,S.V.Morozov,D.Jiang,Y.Zhang,S.V.Dubonos,I.V.Grigorieva,andA.A.Firsov,Science306,666 2004 .2
K.S.Novoselov,A.K.Geim,S.V.Morozov,D.Jiang,M.I.Katsnelson,I.V.Grigorieva,S.V.Dubonos,andA.A.Firsov,Nature London 438,197 2005 .
3Y.
Zhang,Y.-W.Tan,H.L.Stormer,andP.Kim,Nature London 438,201 2005 .
4K.S.Novoselov,E.McCann,S.V.Morozov,V.I.Fal’ko,M.I.Katsnelson,U.Zeitler,D.Jiang,F.Schedin,andA.K.Geim,Nat.Phys.2,177 2006 .
5Y.Zhang,Z.Jiang,J.P.Small,M.S.Purewal,Y.-W.Tan,M.
C. Meyer等人对他们观察到的这一现象提出了理论模型:石墨烯并不是绝对 的平面,而是存在一定的小山丘似的起伏。[7]随后,Meyer等人又研究了单层石 墨烯和双层石墨...
热门文档