PHYSICALREVIEWA91,012103(2015)
One-statevectorformalismfortheevolutionofaquantumstatethrough
nestedMach-Zehnderinterferometers
2, ˇKarolBartkiewicz,1,2,*Anton´ nCernoch,DaliborJav urek,2KarelLemr,2, JanSoubusta,3andJiˇr´ Svozil´ k2
FacultyofPhysics,AdamMickiewiczUniversity,PL-61-614Pozna´n,Poland
RCPTM,JointLaboratoryofOpticsofPalack´yUniversityandInstituteofPhysicsofAcademyofSciencesoftheCzechRepublic,17.
listopadu12,CZ-77146Olomouc,CzechRepublic
3
InstituteofPhysicsofAcademyofSciencesoftheCzechRepublic,JointLaboratoryofOpticsofPUandIPASCR,17.listopadu50A,
CZ-77207Olomouc,CzechRepublic
(Received30October2014;published12January2015)
2
1
Linear-opticalinterferometersplayakeyroleindesigningcircuitsforquantuminformationprocessingandquantumcommunications.EventhoughnestedMach-Zehnderinterferometersappeareasytodescribe,thereareoccasionswhentheyprovideunintuitiveresults.ThispaperexplainstheresultsofahighlydiscussedexperimentperformedbyDananetal.[Phys.Rev.Lett.111,240402(2013).]usingastandardapproach.Weprovideasimpleandintuitiveone-statevectorformalismcapableofinterpretingtheirexperiment.Additionally,wecross-checkedourmodelwithaclassical-physics-basedapproachandfoundthatbothmodelsareincompleteagreement.Wearguethatthequantityusedinthementionedexperimentisnotasuitablewhich-pathwitness,producingseeminglycontraintuitiveresults.Tocircumventthisissue,weestablishamorereliablewhich-pathwitnessandshowthatityieldswell-expectedoutcomesoftheexperiment.DOI:10.1103/PhysRevA.91.012103
I.INTRODUCTION
PACSnumber(s):03.65.Ta,42.50.Dv,42.50.Ex
Inquantummechanics(QM)particlesareassignedawavefunctionusedtodescribetheirproperties[1].Thisapproachsometimesleadstoconclusionsaboutexperimentalresultsthatseemtocontradictintuitiveestimationsbasedonclassicalphysics[2,3].QM,however,managestoprovideaccuratepredictionsinagreementwithallexperimentsperformedsofarandisthereforewidelyaccepted[1,4].
Recently,anexperimentthatcontainedcounterintuitivefeatureswasproposedandrealizedbyDananetal.[5].TheauthorsusednestedMach-Zehnderinterferometers(MZIs),showninFig.1,andmirrors(A,B,C,E,F)vibratingwithdifferentfrequencies,inordertoleaveamarkonpassingphotons.Atoneselectedoutputportoftheinterferometer,thephotonsweredetectedbyaquad-celldetectorDcapableoftracingthespatialvibrationsofthephotonbeam.Aftermeasurement,thecollectedsignalwasfurtherprocessedandsubjectedtotheFouriertransform.Fromtheobtainedfrequenciesofvibrations,theauthorsjudgedwhetherthedetectedphotonshaveinteractedwiththemirrorthatwasoscillatingatthisparticularfrequency.
TheresultsdescribedinthearticlebyDananetal.[5]wereinterpretedbymeansoftwo-statevectorformalism(TSVF)andweakvalues.Boththeresultsandtheirunusualinterpreta-tionwerequestioned[6–11].Thecriticalcommentspertainedtothevisibilityofinterferenceinsidetheinterferometer,thecorrectapplicationofTSVF,theprocessingoftheobtaineddata,anditsvalidity.Saldanhaprovidedaninterpretationoftheexperimentusingclassicaloptics[11].However,theoreticalcalculationsandaninterpretationoftheexperimentalresultsusingonlythestandardone-statevectorquantum-mechanical
approacharestilllacking.Assumingtheabove-mentionedapproachmakesitpossibletointerprettheresultsfromRef.[5]andverifytheircongruitywithQM.Consequently,wewouldmanagetoshedmorelightontheongoingdiscussionregardingthelegitimacyoftheexperimentaldataandtheirinterpretation.Inouropinion,thiswouldbeusefulfordescribingexperimentssimilartoRef.[5],clarifyingthedebateabouttheexperiment.Inthispaper,wepresentarelevantstandardone-statevectorformalismanddescribetheevolutionofthestatevectorasitpassestheMZIinthedirectionofthedetector.Wedescribethepostselectionprocessandderivetheprobabilitiesofdetectingatparticularfrequencies(thatcorrespondtothevibrationsoftheindividualmirrors).TheobtainedresultsarecomparedwiththeexperimentaldatapresentedbyDananetal.[5].Finally,weuseclassicalopticstodescribethetransversepro lesofthelightbeamsusedintheexperimentandweapplytheresulttovalidatetheone-statevectoroutcomesattheclassicallimit.Itisourintentiontodemonstratethattheexperimentcanbereadilyinterpretedusingtheformalismofannihilationoperatorsandone-statevectorformalismandthatthereare,infact,nounexpectedresults.
II.QUANTUMAPPROACH
*
bark@amu.edu.pl
antonin.cernoch@upol.cz
k.lemr@upol.cz
AcorrectdescriptionoftheexperimentbyDananetal.needstoconsiderallthephotonmodespresentinthesetup.Apartfromthespatialmodes,additionalmodesareintroducedbyvibrationsofthemirrors(referredtoasthe“frequencymodes”).Themodesmustbetakenintoaccount,sincetheydifferentiate,atleastinprinciple,betweentherespectivepathsofthephoton.Ouranalysisusestheformalismofannihilationoperatorsandtheirtransformationsonbeamsplitters(BSs).
,andc ,b ,whileSpatialmodesarelabeledbytheoperatorsa
thefrequencymodesaremarkedbybinarynumbers.The vefrequencymodesareintroducedbythemirrorsA,B,C,E,orF.Theyaremarkedbyconsecutivebinaryindicesafterthesymbolnamingthespatialmode.Theindexvalue
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.88.011801 PACS number(s): 42.65.Dr, 42.65.Re, 82.37.Vb, 78.47.nj Nonlinear optical spectroscopy [1] is commonly used ...
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.84.043411 PACS number(s): 42.65.Ky, 42.65.Re, 42.65.Jx, 31.70.Hq I. INTRODUCTION High-order harmonic generation (HHG)...
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.84.033850 PACS number(s): 42.65.Tg, 42.65.Jx, 42.65.Wi 1 I. INTRODUCTION Propagation of optical waves in waveguide arrays...
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.84.033850 PACS number(s): 42.65.Tg, 42.65.Jx, 42.65.Wi 1 I. INTRODUCTION Propagation of optical waves in waveguide arrays...
热门文档