使用层次分析法决策
Some Challenges in Using the AHP in Engineering Applications
3
(1990). The first step in the AHP is the estimation of the pertinent data. That is, the estimation of the aij and Wj values ofthe decision matrix. This is described in the next sub-section.
Table 1: Scale of Relative Importances (according to Saaty (1980))Intensity ofImportance 1 3
Definition
Equal importanceWeak importance of oneover anotherEssential or strongimportanceDemonstratedimportanceAbsolute importance
Explanation
Two activities contributeequally to the objectiveExperience and judgment slightly favor oneactivity over anotherExperience and judgmentstrongly favor oneactivity over anotherAn activity is stronglyfavored and its dominancedemonstrated in practiceThe evidence favoring oneactivity over another isof the highest possibleorder of affirmationWhen compromise is needed
5
7
9
2,4,6,8
Intermediate valuesbetween the twoadjacent judgmentsIf activity i has oneof the above nonzero numbers assigned to itwhen compared withactivity j, then j hasthe reciprocal valuewhen compared with i.
Reciprocals of above nonzero
3.1. The Use of Pairwise Comparisons
One of the most crucial steps in many decision-making methods is the accurate estimation of the pertinent data. This isa problem not bound in the AHP method only, but it is crucial in many other methods which need to elicit qualitativeinformation from the decision-maker. Very often qualitative data cannot be known in terms of absolute values. For instance,"what is the worth of a specific computer software in terms of a user adaptivity criterion?" Although information aboutquestions like the previous one are vital in making the correct decision, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to quantifythem correctly. Therefore, many decision-making methods attempt to determine the alternatives in terms of each criterion involved in a given decision-making problem.
An approach based on pairwise comparisons which was proposed by Saaty (1980) has long attracted the interest of manyresearchers. Pairwise comparisons are used to determine the relative importance of each alternative in terms of eachcriterion. In this approach the decision-maker has to express his opinion about the value of one single pairwise comparisonat a time. Usually, the decision-maker has to choose his answer among 10-17 discrete choices. Each choice is a linguisticphrase. Some examples of such linguistic phrases are: "A is more important than B", or "A is of the same importance asB", or "A is a little more important than B", and so on (see also table 1).
The main problem with the pairwise comparisons is during their evaluation. All the methods which use the pairwise comparisons approach eventually express the qualitative
decision making using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and its ...the alternatives in turn differ in our preference for them on each ...
It has particular application in group decision making,and is used around ...Education and scholarly research Though using the analytic hierarchy process ...
hierarchy processEvaluation of services using a fuzzy analytic hierarchy process...(decision-making and actions)—from preparing to enter the negotiation, ...
Selection of IT Sourcing Alternatives in Public Sector Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process_专业资料。CmptrehooyadApiao 2 )8-9 oue cnl n pltn3(0 4548...
Using the Analytic Hiera... 9页 免费 APPLYING... Decision making - the An... 35页 免费...analytic hierarchy process-based model of Ratio of...
. Implementing the balanced scorecard using the analytic hierarchy process and...(1996). Decision making with dependence and feedback: The analytic network ...
? ? ( 1) s one of the most popular methods for multicriteria decisionmaking, the analytic hierarchy process ( AHP ) has been successfully used in a ...
method, Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method helps in decision-making. ...The steps of using the AHP to solve the problem are as follows. First,...
Decision-making with the AHP-Why is the ...The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) allows for ...using the limiting powers of a priority rather ...
using the Analytic Hierarchy Process ( AHP) method. In all,the thesis ...for decisionmaking in assessment and pick of the green supplier. Key words...
热门文档