Vol.22,No.5,September–October2013,pp.1077–1088ISSN1059-1478|EISSN1937-5956|13|2205|1077DOI10.1111/poms.12006
©2013ProductionandOperationsManagementSociety
TheChangingFaceofDistributionChannels:PartialForwardIntegrationandStrategicInvestments
AnilArya,BrianMittendorf
FisherCollegeofBusiness,OhioStateUniversity,Columbus,Ohio43210,USA,
arya_4@ sher.osu.edu,mittendorf_3@ sher.osu.edu
ecentyearshaveseenadrastictransformationintheorganizationofwholesaleandretailmarkets.Whereoncecleardistinctionsbetweenwholesalesuppliersandretailcompetitorsexisted,nowaneraofblurringboundarieshasemerged.Thistransformationhasbeenmarkedbytheintroductionofonlinechannelsforsupplierstoprovideproductsdirectlytoconsumerswhile,atthesametime,traditionalretailerstoopersist.Thus,retailersarebothwholesalecustomersandretailcompetitorsofmanymanufacturers.Theconsequencesoftherapidemergenceofinstancesofsuchpartialfor-wardintegrationbysuppliersarenotyetfullyknown.Tothisend,westudyhowpartialforwardintegrationcanaffectcompeting rms’strategicinvestments.We ndthatintegrationshiftstheenvironmentfrombeingoneinwhich rmsinvesttoundercutretailrivalstooneinwhich rmsinvestmoreinboostingdemand,eventhatoftheircompetitors.Acaseinpointisthetendencyforamanufacturertoinvestbroadlyinbrandpromotion(bene tingbothitselfanditsretailcompetitor),ratherthanheavypromotionofitsownsaleschannel.Theshiftinthenatureofstrategicinvestmentsarisingfrompartialforwardintegrationimpliesthatsuchintegrationcanbene t rmsandconsumersalike,eventhe rmwhich ndsitselfreliantonacompetitorforsupplies.
Keywords:dualdistribution;forwardintegration;investments;supplychains
History:Received:March2012;Accepted:August2012byKalyanSinghal,after1revision.
R
1.Introduction
Traditionalviewsofdistributionentailcleardistinc-tionsbetweenverticalrelationshipsamongsupplychannelpartnersandhorizontalrelationshipsamongretailcompetitors.Recentyears,however,haveseenadramaticshiftinthewayproductsreachconsumerswhichhas,inturn,revolutionizedthefaceofdistribu-tionchannels.Inparticular,partialforwardintegrationbysuppliersintoretailmarketshasledtoablurringintraditionalboundaries.Insuchenvironments,asup-pliercanbebotha(vertical)inputprovidertoatradi-tionalretailerwhilealsocompetinginthe(horizontal)marketwiththesameretailertoreachendconsumers.Inotherwords,partialforwardintegrationischar-acterizedbycircumstanceswhereasuppliertoa rmalsoservesasthe rm’scompetitor.Examplesincludesoft-drinkproducers,cerealmanufacturers,andgaso-linere nerswhosupplybothtodownstreamaf liatesandtoretailcompetitors.Company-ownedfranchisesthatcompeteforterritorywithindependentfran-chisesaswellasfactoryoutletsandcatalogsalesalso tthebill.Yet,theubiquitouspresenceofpartialfor-wardintegrationdidnottakeholduntiltheonsetofthee-commerceera,duringwhichthejointpresenceoftraditionalretailersandonlinesalesarmsofmanu-facturershasbecomerampant(e.g.,Tedeschi2005).
Inthisarticle,weconsidertherami cationsofpar-tialforwardintegrationforthecriticalissueof rms’strategicinvestments.Researchineconomics,market-ing,operations,andrelated eldshasconsistentlystressedthecrucialroleofinvestmentsinalteringproductdemand.Thisliteraturenotesthata rmcanengageininitiativestopromoteitsowndemand(self-investment)aswellasundertakeinitiativesthatcanalterarival’sdemand(cross-investment).Althoughself-investmentsare,ofcourse,common-place,cross-investmentstooareprevalent.Cross-investmentscantakepositiveforms,suchasthepro-motionofproductcategoriesinlieuofspeci cbrandsorretailoutlets,aswellasnegativeforms,suchascomparativeadvertising,establishingexclusivedis-tributionarrangements,andlobbyingforregulationsthatadverselyaffectrivals.
Atypicalcaseofpositivecross-investmentisSharp’saggressivepromotionofLiquidCrystalDis-play(LCD)technologyfor atpaneltelevisions:NotonlydidthisinvestmentspurdemandforSharp’sownproductsbutitalsoboostedconsumerinterestinsimilarofferingsofitsmainrivals,SonyandSamsung.Prominentexamplesofnegativecross-investmentincludeTylenol’sadsalertingconsumersthatibuprofencancausestomachproblems(SorescuandGelb2000)andApple’snowiconicMacvs.PC
1077
DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS ⑶BETTER ACCESS TO MARKET ...partial integration backward or forward, the firm ...changing ⑵Emphasis is shifting from growth to ...
Changing conditions rendering purpose of alliance ...Can aim at either full or partial integration ...To compensate for undependable distribution channels ...
Integration Customization 来自 www.3722.cn 中国最大的资料库下载 5 Partial ...中国最大的资料库下载 Regional Distribution Center & Sales Channels OEM DIST....
Can aim at either full or partial integration ...To bypass regular distribution channels in favor ...Risk exposure to changing technology and/or ...
Adding channels of distribution or ? Changing ...s outputs - forward integration Prof.Sushil\IITD\...? ? Partial mismatches between acquired firm and ...
integration of methane’s partial-oxidation in supercritical water and exergy ...the reference temperature, set equal to 298.15 K, and H and S are the...
Integration ___ 55 Oliver Bandte v Illustrative...the Joint Probability Distribution ___ 167 JPDM for...Changing y1 and y2 Figure 3.11: CDF ...
Biological treatment of landfill leachate with the integration of partial nitrification, anaerobic a Biological treatment of landfill leachate with the integrati...
Design and Integration of Partial Brain Models Using...directing forward robot motion without bumps on the...changing their functionality from wall avoidance to...
热门文档