American Economic Review 2008, 98:3, 713–736
doc.guandang.net
Do Wealth Fluctuations Generate Time-Varying Risk
Aversion? Micro-Evidence on Individuals’ Asset Allocation
By Markus K. Brunnermeier and Stefan Nagel*
We use data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics to investigate how
households’ portfolio allocations change in response to wealth fluctuations.
Persistent habits, consumption commitments, and subsistence levels can gen-
erate time-varying risk aversion with the consequence that when the level of
liquid wealth changes, the proportion a household invests in risky assets should
also change in the same direction. In contrast, our analysis shows that the
share of liquid assets that households invest in risky assets is not affected by
wealth changes. Instead, one of the major drivers of household portfolio allo-
cation seems to be inertia: households rebalance only very slowly following
inflows and outflows or capital gains and losses. (JEL D14, D31)
A growing number of studies in macroeconomics and finance propose models in which agents’ relative risk aversion is time-varying. The most popular approach is to use habit-formation pref-erences, in particular difference habits, which imply that felicity is a function of consumption minus a habit. In asset pricing, difference-habit models have some success in reproducing the mean and countercyclicality of asset return risk premia found in the data (George Constantinides 1990; Gurdip Bakshi and Zhiwu Chen 1996; John Y. Campbell and John H. Cochrane 1999). In macroeconomics, habits help to jointly match stylized facts about asset returns and the business cycle (see, e.g., Urban Jermann 1998; Michele Boldrin, Lawrence J. Christiano, and Jonas D. M. Fisher 2001). An alternative approach focuses on consumption commitments, which can have effects similar to those of difference habits, in particular, similar time-variation in relative risk aversion (Raj Chetty and Adam Szeidl 2005).
While habit preferences1 seem to help in matching aggregate data, little is known yet about whether the predictions of habit-formation models also fit with microdata. Rajnish Mehra and Edward C. Prescott (2003), for example, point out that it is not clear whether investors actually have the huge time-varying countercyclical variations in risk aversion postulated by models like Campbell and Cochrane (1999). One of the key implications of difference habits is that individu-als’ relative risk aversion should vary with wealth, in contrast to models with constant relative risk aversion (CRRA). An increase in wealth, for example, should lead to a temporary decrease * Brunnermeier: Department of Economics, Bendheim Center for Finance, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544 (e-mail: markus@princeton.edu); Nagel: Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305 (e-mail: nagel_stefan@gsb.stanford.edu). We thank John Campbell, Darrell Duffie, Francisco Gomes, Joy Ishii, Frank de Jong, Christian Julliard, Martin Lettau, Chris Malloy, Filippos Papakonstantinou, Jonathan Parker, Jacob Sagi, Ken Singleton, Ilya Strebulaev, Annette Vissing-Jorgensen, Yihong Xia, Motohiro Yogo, and seminar participants at the CEPR Meetings in Gerzensee, the Five-Star Conference at NYU, HECER Helsinki, Humboldt University Berlin, IAEEG Trier, London School of Economics, the Stanford-Berkeley joint finance seminar, and UC Irvine for useful comments. Brunnermeier acknowledges financial support from the National Science Foundation (SES 021-4445) and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.1 In the following we often speak, for ease of reference, somewhat loosely of “habit preferences” or “habit forma-tion,” but we mean difference habits (or subsistence levels, or consumption commitments that lead to similar effects), which lead to time-varying risk aversion. But we exclude ratio habits of the type used by Andrew B. Abel (1990), because they imply constant relative risk aversion.
713
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
热门文档