VOL. 98 nO. 3BRunnERMEIER AnD nAgEL: WEALTH AnD TIME-VARyIng RISk AVERSIOn715liquid risky asset share. Indeed, we find that inertia seems to be the dominant factor determining changes in asset allocation. The PSID data on purchases and sales of risky assets allows us to reconstruct, approximately, how the portfolio allocation would look if households had not bought or sold risky assets between successive interview dates (assuming that all in- and outflows affect only cash balances). We find that actual portfolio allocations are quite close. The data on pur-chases and sales are surely noisy and probably affected by forgotten trades, but the strength of the inertia effect seems to be too big to be just the result of measurement error.
Given that there seems to be strong inertia, we then check whether a positive effect of liquid wealth changes on portfolio shares might appear if we allow for slow adjustment. We regress future changes in the risky asset share on past changes in wealth and find a small positive effect. But in terms of economic magnitudes, it is again a very small effect, and it is statistically weak.Taken together, our findings suggest that relative risk aversion does not vary with wealth changes in the way postulated by habit-formation models. The large variations in relative risk aversion induced by wealth changes that these theories predict are evidently absent from micro-data. At least with respect to the relationship between asset allocation and wealth, our evidence suggests that CRRA is a good description of microeconomic behavior. But the CRRA model cannot explain the large inertia in household portfolio shares either.
Our evidence on household asset allocation ties in well with some recent work that finds it hard to reconcile habit preferences and microdata along other dimensions of household eco-nomic choices. Karen E. Dynan (2000) finds no evidence that household-level consumption growth exhibits the patterns predicted by internal habit-formation models. Francisco Gomes and Alexander Michaelides (2003) study a life-cycle model of consumption and portfolio choice and find that the introduction of habit formation makes it more difficult to match empirical regulari-ties in microdata. A recent paper by Claudia R. Sahm (2006) examines relative risk aversion measures elicited from responses to hypothetical gamble questions in the Health and Retirement Study and finds no effect of wealth changes on changes in relative risk aversion. The findings in these studies contrast with those of Joseph P. Lupton (2003), who finds a negative relationship between past consumption levels and current risky asset holdings, including businesses and real estate, which he argues is consistent with habit formation, and Enrichetta Ravina (2005), who finds support for habit formation in credit card purchases data. The results in our (first-differ-ences) regressions are also consistent with earlier evidence that the cross-sectional relationship between the level of the risky asset share (John Heaton and Deborah Lucas 2000; Luigi Guiso, Michael Haliassos, and Tullio Jappelli 2003) or elicited relative risk aversion measures (Robert
B. Barksy et al. 1997) and the level of wealth is essentially flat among households that participate in the stock market.
The paper is organized as follows. Section I presents a simple portfolio choice model with habit preferences, our methodology, and the data. Section II reports our main results. In Sec-tion III we discuss the implications of our results. The Appendix is available on the AER Web site (http: doc.guandang.net).
I. Theory and Methodology
A. Model of Asset Allocation with Habits
We develop a simple model of portfolio choice that illustrates how relative risk aversion can be time-varying when agents’ preferences exhibit difference habits, subsistence levels, or simi-lar features. Let time be discrete and consider a single agent with infinite horizon. The agent’s wealth at time t is denoted Wt and is measured before time t consumption, Ct . There are two securities the agent can invest in: a risky asset with return Rt, and a risk-free asset with constant
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
热门文档