MindYourBlocks:
OntheStealthinessofMaliciousBGPHijacks
Pierre-AntoineVervier
SymantecResearchLabs/EurecomPierre-Antoine_Vervier@symantec.com
OlivierThonnard
SymantecResearchLabsOlivier_Thonnard@symantec.com
MarcDacier
QatarComputingResearchInstitute
mdacier@qf.org.qa
Abstract—SomerecentresearchpresentedevidenceofblocksofIPaddressesbeingstolenbyBGPhijackerstolaunchspamcampaigns[35].Thiswasthe rsttimeBGPhijackswereseeninthewild.Sincethen,onlyaveryfewanecdotalcaseshavebeenreportedasifhackerswerenotinterestedinrunningtheseattacks.However,itisacommonbeliefamongnetworkoperatorsandISPsthattheseattackscouldbetakingplacebut,sofar,noonehasproducedevidencetobackupthatclaim.Inthispaper,weanalyse18monthsofdatacollectedbyaninfrastructurespeci callybuilttoanswerthatquestion:areintentionalstealthyBGPhijacksroutinelytakingplaceintheInternet?Theidenti cationofwhatwebelievetobemorethan2,000malicioushijacksleadstoapositiveanswer.Thelackofgroundtruthis,ofcourse,aproblembutwemanagedtogetcon rmationofsomeofour ndingsthankstoanISPunwittinglyinvolvedinhijackcaseswehavespotted.Thispaperaimsatbeinganeyeopenerforthecommunitybysheddingsomelightonthisundocumentedthreat.Wealsohopethatitwillspurnewresearchtounderstandwhythesehijacksaretakingplaceandhowtheycanbemitigated.DependingonhowBGPattacksarecarriedout,theycanbeverydisruptiveforthewholeInternetandshouldbelookedatveryclosely.Asoftoday,asmuchas20%ofthewholeIPv4addressspaceiscurrentlyallocatedbutnotpubliclyannounced,whichmakesitpotentiallyvulnerabletosuchmaliciousBGPhijacks.
I.INTRODUCTION
ThecurrentInternetroutinginfrastructureisknowntobevulnerabletoBGPhijackingwhichconsistsintakingcontrolofblocksofIPaddresseswithoutanyconsentofthelegitimateowners.ThisisduetothefactthatBGP[36],thedefactointer-domainroutingprotocol,reliesontheconceptoftrustamonginterconnectedautonomoussystems(ASes).Accidental,notnecessarilymalicious,BGPhijackincidentsareknowntooccurintheInternet.Theyaregenerallyattributedtomiscon gurations.Afewcaseshavereceivedpublicdisclosureonnetworkoperationalmailinglists,suchasNANOG,orblogposts[12],[15],[16],[21].TechniquestodetecttheseBGPhijackshavebeenproposedtohelpnetworkoperatorsmonitortheirownpre xestoreactquicklytosuchpossibleoutages.Theseapproachessufferfromaveryhighfalse-positiverate
Permissiontofreelyreproduceallorpartofthispaperfornoncommercialpurposesisgrantedprovidedthatcopiesbearthisnoticeandthefullcitationonthe rstpage.ReproductionforcommercialpurposesisstrictlyprohibitedwithoutthepriorwrittenconsentoftheInternetSociety,the rst-namedauthor(forreproductionofanentirepaperonly),andtheauthor’semployerifthepaperwaspreparedwithinthescopeofemployment.NDSS’15,8-11February2015,SanDiego,CA,USACopyright2015InternetSociety,ISBN1-891562-38-Xdoc.guandang.net
[23],[29],[40],[50]whichisstillacceptabletotheseuserssincetheyareonlyinterestedinalertsrelatedtothenetworkstheyown.OtherproposalsaimatpreventingBGPhijacks[24],[25],[30]buttheirlarge-scaleadoptionanddeploymentarehinderedbytheimplementationcost.
In2006,Ramachandranetal.[35]introducedanewphenomenoncalled“BGPspectrumagility”,whichconsistsofspammersadvertisingforashortperiodoftime(i.e.,lessthanoneday)BGProutestolarge(i.e.,/8)previouslyunannouncedblocksofIPaddressesand,subsequently,usingtheavailableIPaddressesforspamming.Later,someotherauthorsalsoidenti edtheemissionofspamemailscomingfromhijackedpre xes[20],[23].Furthermore,complementingtheworkdonein[39],wehavedescribedin[47]aspecialcaseofhijackinwhichacoupleofIPaddressblockswerestolenandusedtosendspam.Mostrecently,wehavealsoshownin[46],thankstoanotherreal-worldcase,thatcorrelatingroutinganomalieswithmalicioustraf c,suchasspam,isnotsuf cienttodecisivelyprovetheexistenceofamaliciousBGPhijack.BesidesthesesparsecasesanddespitetheapparentdesireofsomeownerstodetectwhethertheirownIPaddressblockcouldeverbestolen,tothebestofourknowledgewehavenodocumentedevidencethatBGPattacksareathreatworthbeinginvestigated,sincenoonehasshownthathackershavethepossibilitytoroutinelyusethatmodusoperanditocommitnefariousactivities.Iftheywerecapableofit,thiswouldconstituteaveryseriousthreattotheInternetsincethiswouldenablethemnotonlytosendspamemailswhiledefeatingtheclassicalIPblacklistsbut,moreimportantly,torunlargescaleDDoSatalmostnocostorrunman-in-the-middleattacksagainstalmostanytargetoftheirchoosing.
Therefore,wefeelthatthereisaneedtorigorouslyassesstheexistenceandprevalenceofthispotentialthreat.Thispapercontributestothisobjectivebyprovidinganin-depthstudyofaspeci cclassofagilespammersthatareabletohijackroutinely,persistentlyand-quitelikely-automaticallyalargenumberofblocksofIPaddressestosendspamfromthestolenIPspace.Whattrulyseparatesourworkfromothersisthatwedonotonlyuncoveralargenumberofnewsuspiciouscasesbutwealsogathercontextualinformationtobuildacompellingcasefortherealityofthesemalicioushijacksandtoexposethemodusoperandiofthemaliciousactors.Ourresultsshowthattheidenti edhijackswererathersuccessfulatcircumventingtraditionalBGPhijackandspamprotectiontechniques.Themaincontributionofthispaperistobeaneye-openertothefactthatfrequent,persistentandstealthyBGP
热门文档