JournalofConsumerBehaviour,J.ConsumerBehav.11:11–20(2012)
Publishedonline15April2011inWileyOnlineLibrary(wileyonlinelibrary.com)DOI:10.1002/cb.356
Understandingconsumers’brand‐inducedfoodtasteperception:A
comparisonof‘brandfamiliarity’–and‘consumervalue–brandsymbolism(in)congruity’–accounts
RAMIPAASOVAARA1*,HARRIT.LUOMALA2,TERHIPOHJANHEIMO3andMARISANDELL31
UniversityofVaasa,DepartmentofMarketing,POBox700,65101Vaasa,Finland2
UniversityofVaasa/EPANET,FoodwestLtd,Vaasantie1C,60100Seinäjoki,Finland3
UniversityofTurku,FunctionalFoodsForum,DepartmentofBiochemistryandFoodChemistry,20014Turku,FinlandABSTRACT
Pastresearchhasshownthatfamiliarbrandscanboostconsumers’foodtasteexperiences.Ontheotherhand,morerecentevidencesuggeststhatthe(in)congruitybetweenconsumervaluesandbrandsymbolismcanaffectthefoodtasteperception.Thisstudyisthe rstonetointegratethesetwoaccountsintoonesingleconceptualframeworkandtoempiricallyevaluatetheirrelativerolesinexplainingconsumers’brand‐inducedtasteperception.Twoexperimentsinvolvingtastetrials(blindvsbrand‐cuedsensoryevaluation)wereconducted.The rstexperimentanalysedthebrandfamiliarityeffect,whereasthesecondexperimentaddressedalsothetasteperceptionofyogurtswithdifferingbrandsymbolismamongstfoodconsumerswithdistinctvalueorientationsto ndsupportforthe(in)congruityeffects.Thisresearchimpliesthatcongruityisnotresponsibleforenhancingconsumers’tasteperceptionbeyondthelevelthatisproducedbythebrandfamiliarity.Incontrast,theincongruityeffectappearscapableofneutralisingthebrandfamiliarityeffect.Therefore,thesetwoexplanationsmayoperateindependently.Moregenerally,thisstudyspeaksfortheimportanceofincorporatingconsumervalue–brandsymbolismincongruitymechanismintofoodconsumptionstudies;evenowners’ofstrongfoodbrandscannottrusttheabilityoftheirbrandstoboostaconsumer’stasteexperienceifthereisnocorrespondencebetweenhisorhercentralvaluesandbrandsymbolism.Thus,anobjectivelybettertasteisnotnecessarilydecisive;satisfactorysensoryqualitycansuf ceifitiscoupledwithimaginativeanddaringbrandmarketingthatdeliversuniqueemotionalandfunctionalbene tsforwell‐de nedfoodconsumertargetsegments.Copyright©2011JohnWiley&Sons,Ltd.
INTRODUCTION
Itisknownfrompastresearchthatstrongbrandscanelevateconsumers’tasteperceptionsoffoodproducts.Forexample,intheirclassicalstudy,AllisonandUhl(1964)foundthatconsumers’identi cationofafamiliarbeerbrandincreasedsigni cantlytasteperceptioncomparedwiththeblindevaluationcondition.InthestudyofRobinsonetal.(2007),youngchildrentastedidenticalfoodsanddrinkseitherinpackagingfromMcDonald’sorfromunbrandedpackaging.ChildrenpreferredthetasteoffoodsanddrinkstheybelievedwerefromMcDonald’s.Anothermajorfoodbrandplayer,Coca‐Cola,madethefamousmarketingblunderinthe1980sbychangingthetasteformulationofits agshipproduct.The‘NewCoke’waspreferredinblindtests,butitstillcausedmuchnegativeemotionsandwasthusrejectedbymanyconsumersonthemarketplace.ItappearsthatCoca‐Colaunderestimatedthelevelofemotionalattachmentconsumersmayhavewithfamiliaroriginalfoodbrands(seee.g.CovaandPace,2006).IntheCoca‐Colacase,thisledtoasituationwheretheobjectivelybettertaste(NewCoke)wassubjectivelyexperiencedasworsebyconsumersthantheobjectivelypoorertaste(originalCoke)presumablybecausethewell‐establishedandstableconsumer–brandrelationshiphadbeentransgressedbytheCoca‐Colacompanyitself.Infact,McClureetal.(2004)haveevenshownthattheexposuretotheCoca‐ColabrandstimulatesthebrainactivityofUSconsumers.
*Correspondenceto:RamiPaasovaara,UniversityofVaasa,DepartmentofMarketing,POBox700,65101Vaasa,Finland.Conventionally,itisthoughtthatconsumerstendtobuyfamiliarbrandsoutofhabitorbecauseofloyalty,andtheyarelikelywillingtopaymoreforabrandedproductthanforanon‐brandedgenericproduct,iftheyseefavourableconsequencesofbranduse(Solomon,2007).Intermsofpackagedfoodproducts,therecognitionofafamiliarbrandnameorlogohelpsconsumerstoevaluatequalityattributesandmakesconsumptiondecisionseasier.
Ontheotherhand,therehasrecentlybeenasurgeofinterestdirectedattheinterplaybetweenconsumervaluesandtasteperception(KihlbergandRisvik,2007).AnespeciallyrelevantstudyfromthisresearchgenreforthepresentinvestigationistheonebyAllenetal.(2008).Theyarguedthatcultureattachessymbolicmeanings(e.g.humanvalues,norms,socialcategories)tofoodsandbeveragesandthatthe tbetweenthesesymbolicmeaningsandcon-sumers’ownpersonalvaluesdetermineshowpositivelyornegativelythetasteoraromaisevaluated.Inextensivepilottests,avegetariansausagerollresemblingarealmeatsausagerollbyitstastewasidenti ed.Incomparisonwithvegetarianfood,meatsymbolisessocialpowertoagreaterextent.Intheir rststudy,Allenetal.(2008)showedthatthoseconsumerswhoembracelowsocialpowervaluesevaluatethetasteoftherollbetter(andhavemorefavourableproductattitudeandpurchaseintention)whentheywereinformedthatitwasavegetarianrollthanwhentheywereinformedthatitwasabeefroll.Inreality,itwasrandomlydeterminedwhethertheyreceivedavegetarianorbeefrollfortasting.Asimilarkindofstudywasconductedforbrandedcolasoftdrinkstoo.Accordingtothepilot
热门文档