According to the internationally well-known expert in perception of taste, Linda Bartoshuk, scientists have been underestimating the difficulties in interpersonal comparisons. When using scales for rating intensities of experiences, there is a ‘long-stand
ARE WE SUBJECTED TO A
‘LONG-STANDING MEASUREMENT OVERSIGHT’?
Gunnar BorgDepartment of Psychology, Stockholm University, Sweden
Abstract
According to the internationally well-known expert in perception of taste, Linda Bartoshuk,scientists have been underestimating the difficulties in interpersonal comparisons. Whenusing scales for rating intensities of experiences, there is a ‘long-standing measurementoversight’. People with great differences in their sensory perceptions may still give verysimilar ratings because of their different experiences and frames of references. In this articleBartoshuk’s idea is presented, and the author's way of handling the problem is reported. Themain aspects of this method consist of using a special verbally level-anchored ratio scale (theCR10 scale or CR100), and a reference modality selected to be as intersubjectively valid aspossible, including a special anchor as a ‘fixed point’. The latter can e.g. be a ’Maximalperceived exertion and heaviness’ because of its good interpersonal preciseness.
In August last year during the APA Convention, Linda Bartoshuk, professor at Yale andexpert in taste perception, presented a paper about ‘tasters’, ‘non-tasters’ and ’super-tasters’.It is an established fact that a rather large group of the population (about 1/4) has a veryimpaired perception of bitterness, identified by the solution of ‘PROP’. They are so called‘non-tasters’. Bartoshuk has found that there also exists a small group of ‘super-tasters’.However, when Bartoshuk uses ordinary simple rating scales these great differences are notwell detected. The genetically determined differences, causing special life-long experiences ofbitter substances, have caused the ‘non-tasters’ and ‘super-tasters’ to adapt to their ownspecial frames of references, without knowing well enough their deviations from otherpeople. This causes a great problem in interpersonal comparisons of ‘absolute’ and ‘natural’levels of intensity.
In an article from the APA congress a Monitor (October 2000) staff editor, Siri Carpenter,wrote about this as ‘a long-standing measurement oversight’. ‘The problem that Bartoshukidentified arises from the fact that people cannot share one another’s sensory experiences.Individuals learn to apply intensity adjectives such as ‘weak’, ‘moderate’ and ‘strong’ tovarious domains, but the intensity indicated by those adjectives depends on the range of theirexperiences. To be accurate in drawing comparisons across individuals or groups, adjective-labeled scales must have universal meaning. But they don’t. I don’t know why this didn’toccur to me years ago, and I don’t know why it didn’t occur to somebody else years ago.’ AtAPA’s 2000 Annual Convention in Washington, D.C., Aug. 4-8 Bartoshuk said, ‘This is adreadful mistake… I keep thinking that somebody somewhere has noticed it, and I just don’tknow about that paper or that literature. But what I do know is that if anyone has done it, ithasn’t penetrated anywhere, because this mistake is being made all over the place.’
A. time B. period C. standing D. stand ( )...oversight on your part that the L/C had not ...subjected to your acceptance reaching us no later...
a test of Bell's inequality by the measurement ...and the surrounding matrix are subjected to a ...also a long-standing problem in polymer adhesives...
140 meters is subjected to pressures of 80 ...to the lack of direct measurement of the radial...t learn to swim while he is standing by the ...
be subjected d. to subject 11. We wish to ...oversight on your part that the L/C had not ...57. As to our credit standing, you may refer ...
Ms. Mbogo also faced misunderstanding among the ...female politicians have been subjected to, however...long as she keeps giving us what we want, she...
by most countries for all units of measurement. ...Between them, there are many long- standing ...flees if one is constantly subjected to demeaning...
are transferred to a 1-L separatory funnel and ...a yellow oil that crystallized on standing (mp ...subjected to high vacuum for long periods of ...
long-standing commitment to creating and effectively...subjected to stereotyping, social isolalion, and ...are members of a demographic minority experience ...
thankyou we are the same Long long ago ,when ...as well as been subjected change moods ,without ...standing outside the window,at that time ,most ...
to be subjected to Descartes’ skeptical method. ...We long for something meaningful, whole, and ...4)-Lecter's "culture" is a standing rebuke to...
热门文档