We speculate on a possible interpretation of events selected by the SELEX collaboration and stress an insufficient evidence for the observation of doubly charmed baryon.
Commenton“FirstobservationofdoublycharmedbaryonΞ+cc”
V.V.Kiselev andA.K.Likhoded,
StateResearchCenter”InstituteforHighEnergyPhysics”
Protvino,Moscowregion,142280Russia
Fax:+7-0967-744739
WespeculateonapossibleinterpretationofeventsselectedbytheSELEXcollaborationandstressaninsu cientevidencefortheobservationofdoublycharmedbaryon.
2
002 guA 62 1v1328020/hp-pe:hviXraPACSnumbers:14.20.Lq,13.30.-a,13.85.Ni
Intherecentpaper[1]theSELEXcollaborationre-portedonthe rstobservationofdoublycharmedbaryon.Inthiscommentwearguethefollowing:
1.Giventhereportedeventswouldbecausedbythedoublycharmedbaryons,theobservedparti-clewouldhaveextremelyexoticcharacteristicsasconcernsforthelifetimeaswellastheproductionrateandsignature.2.TheeventsobservedbytheSELEXcollaborationasdescribedin[1]couldbeordinarytreatedasas-sociatedpairproductionofcharmedparticleswithnoinvolvementofdoublycharmedbaryons.IntheanalysisofSELEXdata,theΛ+1630eventswiththefullreconstructioncsamplecontains
ofΛ+c→pK π+
decaymode.Itisimportantthattheproductsofdecaywereidenti edbyuseoftheRing-ImagingCherenkovde-tector(RICH),andthesecondaryvertexshiftedfromtheinteractionpointofincomingparticlewiththetargetwasresolvedduetothesiliconvertexdetector.Cabbibo-alloweddecayofΞ+cc→Λ+cK Further,the
π+
wassearchedfor,and,thus,oneexpectedthestrongcorrelationof
chargedkaon-signindecaysofΛ+candΞ+
cc.Thecollab-oration+chosentoinvestigatethepositionofadditionalK πvertexbetweentheprimaryoneandthatofΛ+c.Thisconditioncouldremovealotofeventsunderinter-est,butthefurtheranalysisin[1]shownthatitisnotsorestrictiveforthecandidateevents.
LetusassumethattheSELEXcollaborationcanprovetheobservationofdoublycharmedbaryonΞ+in[1].ThenthemeasurementofΞ+
ccasclaimed
withTable1in[1]showsthecclifetimeinaccor-dancepreferablevalueof0.012pswiththeupperlimitof0.033psatthe90%con- dencelevel.Thisresultisinadeepcontradictionwiththetheoreticalpredictions[2,3]basedontheOperatorProductExpansiongeneralizedtothesystemscomposedoftwoheavyquarksandasinglelightquark.Thetotalwidthofthedoublycharmedbaryonuptosubleadingtermsisgivenbythesumoftwobasicterms.The rstisthedoubletotalwidthoffreecharmedquark,i.e.thespectatorcontributioncorrectedbythecouplede ects,
2
.
ThespectatorwidthΓspectslightlymalizationscalecomingc
dependsonthenor-fromthehigher-ordercorrectionsinQCD,sothatitis,withagoodaccuracy,independentofhadronstatespectcontainingthecharmedquark.Therefore,thevalueofΓcannotbeessentiallychangedwithre-specttothatc
ofinDmesons.Theaveragedsquareofcharmedquarkvelocityinthebaryoncanbeestimatedinthemodel-dependentway.Itsvalueisabout0.15,whichgivesatypicalsizeofsubleadingcorrections.Thesec-ondnumerically-essentialterminthetotalwidthofΞ+isdeterminedbytheweakrescatteringofcharmedandccdquarksΓWS[Ξ+cc].Itsvalueparametricallydependsonthewavefunctionofbaryon,whichwasindetailstudiedinRef.[2].Thus,thetotalwidthisequalto
Γtot[Ξ+cc]≈2Γc[Ξ+cc]+ΓWS[Ξ+
cc],
wherethenumericalcontributionofweakscatteringcon-tributionisabout60%.Thenthelifetimeispredictedby
theestimate
τ[Ξ+cc]=0.16±0.05ps,
whichismuchgreaterthanthemeasuredvalueforthe
candidatesreportedbytheSELEXcollaboration.Note,thattheextremelyshortlifetimewouldpointtotheun-expectedbreakingofOPEinthedoublyheavybaryons,sinceoneshouldessentiallychangethemassofcharmedquarkaswellasdrasticallyenlargethebaryonwavefunc-tionincontradictionwiththedescriptionofhadronscon-tainingasinglecharmedquark1.WehavetoemphasizethattheanalysisoflifetimeinRef.[2]wasperformedinaconsistentwaywiththedataonthelifetimesofwiththesinglecharmedquark,i.e.ΛcandΞ+c,0
baryons
.Thus,
First Observation of the... 暂无评价 5页 免费 Comment on First observa.....An interesting process of the mentioned kind is the doubly charmed baryon ...
1 FERMILAB-Conf-02/236-E First Observation of a Family of Double-Charm ...has reported this as the ?rst observation of a doubly-charmed baryon [7]...
The observation of doubly charmed baryon Ξ+ by the SELEX Collaboration at cc FERMILAB[6] provides an opportunity to investigate the hidden problems. ...
We report the first observation of two charmed strange baryons that decay ...We have also searched for the doubly charmed baryon state at 3520 MeV/c2...
First Observation of t... 暂无评价 15页 免费 Observation of the Dec......c c two-body doubly charmed baryon B decay B + →Ξ0 ∧+ [9] ...
mass measurements in Lambda_c, Xi_c, Omega_c, and Xi_cc are discus...rst observation of a member of the doubly charmed baryon family, the Ξ+...
Inclusive Charmed-Baryon... 暂无评价 14页 免费 First Observation of Inc... 暂无评价 11页 免费 Production of doubly cha... 暂无评价 14页 免费 Spectrosc...
First Observation of the... 暂无评价 5页 免费 Comment on First observa.....Search for Doubly Charmed Baryons Xi_cc^+ and Xi_cc^++ in BABAR We sea...
(Received 29 August 2007) We study the inclusive production of doubly heavy baryon Ξcc at polarized photon collider. Our results show that proper choice...
Baryon Production in the... 暂无评价 23页 免费 Doubly Charmed Baryon Pr....the full kinematical reconstruction of the Lambda_b, observation of Xi_b in...
热门文档