安克斯密特的历史表现理论
RethinkingHistory
Vol.13,No.3,September2009,357–369
ExploringholisminFrankAnkersmit’shistoricalrepresentation
ak*EugenZelen
DepartmentofPhilosophy,CatholicUniversityinRuzˇomberok,Slovakia
Forover20yearsFrankAnkersmithasbeenoneoftheleading gures
ofnarrativistphilosophyofhistory.Despitethefactthathisworkhas
receivedconsiderableattentionfromotherphilosophersofhistory,few
authorshaveattemptedtoprovideafavorableinterpretationofthe
interestingthingshesaysabouthistory.InthisarticleIarguethatsuch
aninterpretationofhisaccountofhistoricalrepresentationmayreveala
veryimportantpointhemakesconcerningthenatureofhistoricalwork.
Followingadiscussionoftheory-ladennessandunderdetermination
fromthegeneralphilosophyofscienceIshowthattheseconceptsshould
betakenintoaccountbettertounderstandAnkersmit’sholisticviewof
historicalrepresentation.Althoughitispossibleto ndseveraltypesof
holisminhiswritings,thisarticletriestoemphasizethesigni cance
ofoneofthem.Itcouldbesummarizedintheso-callednewholism
thesisclaimingthathistoricalrepresentationisawholeproducedbythe
interplayoffactualandconceptualelements.Thus,theimportantlesson
tobelearntfromAnkersmit’sworkanddeservingfurtherstudyisthat
thereisnotonlyanempiricalbutalsoaconceptualcomponentplayinga
crucialroleinwritinghistory.
Keywords:Ankersmit;historicalrepresentation;
ladenness;underdetermination;epistemologyholism;theory-
Duringthe1980sand90snarrativismwasoneofthemostpopularviewsinthephilosophyofhistory.Theproponentsofnarrativismareconvincedthatthephaseofwritinghistoricalnarrativesshouldbethecenterofphilosophicalinterest.Accordingtothemphilosophersshouldreconsidertherealnatureofhistoricaltextsandpaycloserattentiontothelanguagehistoriansusetoaccountforthepast.Since,asnarrativistsmaintain,historiansarefundamentallystory-tellersitiscrucialtostudyintensivelythesimilaritiesbetweenhistoricalworksand ctionalnovels,andsomeofthemclaimthatitmightprovefruitfultoderivesomeinspirationnotonlyfromthephilosophyoflanguagebutalsofromliterarytheory.
*Email:zelenak@ku.sk
ISSN1364-2529print/ISSN1470-1154online
Ó2009Taylor&Francis
DOI:10.1080/13642520903091100
doc.guandang.net
Exploring Customers’ Motivation and Satisfaction with International Casual-Dining Restaurants in Korea Yun J. Jang Jinlin Zhao ABSTRACT. This explorative study...
(2012) 655–660 Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect Journal of Informetrics journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/joi Exploring scientists’...
Exploring-gnuradio(中文)_信息与通信_工程科技_专业资料。软件无线电 GNURADIOExploring-gnuradio 简介: 软件无线电是一门让软件代码尽可能靠近接收天线的技术。...
exploring 中文版_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。Exploring Chemistry with Electronic Structure Method Second Edithion James B. Foresman Aeleen Fris...
Copy Right by RUAN Jing Statistical Product and Service Solutions 数据预处理阮敬 博士 ruanjing@msn.com 首都经济贸易大学统计学院 Statistics Dept., Capital ...
Exploring the U.S.A. 46页 免费 Exploring the world 5页 免费 exploring the cell 24页 1下载券 喜欢此文档的还喜欢 JUNIPER 路由器常用维护... 90页 ...
Exploring Corporate Strategy 8th Edition -Chapter02_The Environment_管理学_高等教育_教育专区。最新企业战略管理The Focus of Part 1: The Strategic Position ...
4页 1下载券 Unit4 Exploring plants 27页 2下载券Unit 4 Exploring pla...
Exploring Reading 课程进度及教学安排_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区 暂无评价0人阅读0次下载举报文档 Exploring Reading 课程进度及教学安排_英语学习_外语学习_...
Exploring English-speaking Countries_文化/宗教_人文社科_专业资料。英语国家社会与文化Exploring English-speaking Countries About the Course ? Why should we ...
热门文档