Figure 2: Interest points detected by PreciseHarris on the same scene as in gure 1 under di erent imaging conditions. The rotation between the image on the left and the image of gure 1 is 155 . The repeatability rate is 92%. The scale change between the image on the right and the one in gure 1 is 1.4. The repeatability rate is 71%. Repeatability and informational content are the criteria used
for our comparison of di erent detectors. Quantitatively good results with respect to theses criteria explain why interest points have proved to be so successful in image matching. In addition, the small image support used for their detection makes them robust to occlusions. There exist other criteria to evaluate interest points. An example for another criterion is the precision of localization. An interest point has to be precisely located at the projection of a speci c 3D point in the scene. This criterion is important is the context of calibration, where the measured world points have to be detected precisely in the image. Repeatability and localization are contradictory criteria 4], as smoothing improves the repeatability and degrades the localization. The localization accuracy has been evaluated for detectors which t a template to the signal (cf. section 2.1.3). Deriche and Blaszka 7] show that their detector has a good precision in localization when synthetic noise is added. Brand and Mohr 3] measure the localization quality of their detector on real images. They use several di erent test criteria: alignment of the extracted points, precision of 3D reconstruction and a variation of the cross ratios. To our knowledge no other quantitative comparisons of interest point operators exist. In general, papers which present a new algorithm for interest point detectors just present results for a few test images. Yet visual evaluation of the results is not quantitative and is very likely to be subjective: results are compared with what the person thinks should be an interest point, and not with what is important in the context of interest points applications. This paper starts by giving an introduction on interest points as well as some implementation details for the detectors used in the comparison (cf. section 2). The repeatability criterion is de ned in section 3. We explain how it is determined experimentally and then compare the di erent detectors in the presence of di erent transformations. Section 4 explains the information content criterion. We rst show how to measure the information content of a distribution and then describe the characterization of local greyvalue patterns. The results for di erent detectors 3


Evaluating and comparing the university performance ...interest in commercial exploitation of a new ..., T [the total number of time points (9 in ...
Comparing and Evaluating epoll, select and poll Event Mechanisms Louay Gammo,...(epoll2) – add/remove interest at time of accept and close – less ...
Comparing and evaluating interest points[ A ]. International Conference on Computer V ision [ C ]. [ 6 ] 杨常清 ,王孝通 ,徐晓刚 ,等 . 基于特征...
mis6324EvaluatingClassifiers_法律资料_人文社科_专业资料...the class of interest, in the descending order ...the less accurate the model 19 Comparing Measures...
Comparing and unifying search-based and similarity-...cant recent interest (Blum & Mitchell, 1998; ...evaluating clusterings so that it includes ...
August 2005 Evaluating Arm Movement Imitation Alexandra...by comparing it to human evaluation of imitation....interest of both behavioral sciences and robotics....
evaluating, obtaining, using, and disposing of ...comparing a product’s perceived performance to ...interest in buying product/service, but may not ...
interest D from the perspective of a person who...comparing and evaluating information systems, data ...adaptation: "plug-in" points, guidelines for ...
and Evaluating Interfaces to Support Exploratory ...However, there is growing interest within the ...Is there a mechanism for comparing interfaces ...
This is done by comparing probabilities of each ...absorbed) or leaves the region of interest. The...and Creating Input Files Evaluating the Output File...
热门文档