文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 高等教育 > 法学 > unilateral non-colonial secession in international law
侵权投诉

unilateral non-colonial secession in international law

unilateral non-colonial secession in international law

onastic,itwouldseemtoindicatethatpeoplescanalsoexistinanon-colonialcontext,assituationsof“aliensubjug-ation,dominationandexploitation”arenotuniquetocolonisation.

Principle5,paragraph4reiterates,thecontentofPrincipleVIofResolution1541[FN26]regardingthemethodsbywhichapeoplemayexercisetheirrighttoexternalself-determination.[FN27]However,unlikePrincipleVI,theparagraphdoesnotexplicitlyseektolimittheapplicationofitscontenttocolonialpeoples.Thisdifferenceiscrucial,asitarguablyopensthepossibilityforparagraph4toapplytonon-colonialpeoples.Paragraph4wouldthusseemtocomportwiththemeaningof“peoples”asdeducedfromparagraphs1and2.

Principle5,paragraph5dealswiththedutyof“states”torefrainfromactionthatwoulddeprive“peoples”oftheirrighttoself-determination.Theparagraph'sphraseologythereforeimplicitlyreaffirmsthatstatesandpeoplesaretwodistinctconcepts.Furthermore,ifitisacceptedthatparagraphs1,2,and4implythatpeoplesmayexistinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext,itfollowsthatthedirectivecontainedinparagraph5mustalsoapplytopeoplesinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext.

Principle5,paragraph6dealsexclusivelywithpeoplesinacolonialcontext,asindicatedbytheopeningphrase,“[t]heterritoryofacolonyorotherNon-Self-GoverningTerritoryhas,undertheCharter,astatusseparateanddis-tinctfromthe*352territoryoftheStateadministeringit.”[FN28]Thefactthatparagraph6explicitlyconfinesitspurposetocolonialpeoplesissignificantforthefactthattheotherparagraphsprecedingitdonotexplicitlyconfinetheirpurposetocolonialpeoples.Thisisfurtherinferentialevidencethattheprecedingparagraphs--1,2,4,and5--refertopeoplesbeyondthecolonialcontext.

Paragraph6continuesbynoting“suchseparateanddistinctstatusundertheChartershallexistuntilthepeopleofthecolonyorNon-Self-GoverningTerritoryhaveexercisedtheirrightofself-determination....”[FN29]Crucially,paragraph6wouldseemtoindicatethatonlyonepeoplecanexistwithinanon-self-governingterritory,astheplural“peoples”isnotemployed.[FN30]ThisdraftingisinconsistentwithArticles73,73(b),and76(b)oftheU.N.Charter,allofwhichindicatethatmorethanonepeoplemayinhabitanon-self-governingterritory.[FN31]ItisalsoinconsistentwithPrinciples2,7(a),8,and9ofResolution1541,allofwhichsuggestthatmorethanonepeoplecaninhabitanon-self-governingterritory.[FN32]Onbalance,therefore,thefailureofparagraph6tousethepluralterm“peoples”probablyconstitutesadraftingerror.

Principle5,paragraph7ofResolution2625arguablymovesbeyondthecolonialcontextwhenemployingtheterm“peoples”:

Nothingintheforegoingparagraphsshallbeconstruedasauthorizingorencouraginganyactionwhich

woulddismemberorimpair,totallyorinpart,theterritorialintegrityorpoliticalunityofsovereignandinde-pendentStatesconductingthemselvesincompliancewiththeprincipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoplesasdescribedaboveandthuspossessedofagovernmentrepresentingthewholepeoplebelongingtotheterritorywithoutdistinctionastorace,creedorcolour.[FN33]

Paragraph7hencelinksitscontentto“sovereignandindependentStates,”whichwould,onbalance,seemtoreferto“States”--notnon-self-governingterritories.Althoughitmaybearguedthatmetropolitanpowers[FN34]are“States”responsiblefornon-self-governingterritories,thisdoesnotseemtobetheprimaryobjectiveofparagraph7.Thisreasoningisnotnegatedbythesubsequentphrase:“Statesconductingthemselvesincompliancewiththeprin-cipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoplesasdescribedabove,”whichnecessarilyrequiresthatall*353otherparagraphsbeforeparagraph7mustbeconsidered--asparagraphs1,2,4,and5indicate--thatpeoplesmayexistinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext.Onlyparagraph6restrictsitsdiscussionofpeoplestothenon-self-governingorcolonialcontext.Itwouldthusseemhighlyprobablethatparagraph7isaddressingitscommentstosovereignstates,whichbyimplicationconfirmstheapplicabilityoftheterm“peoples”tothenon-colonialcontext.

Paragraph7does,however,containsomedraftingproblems.Thisisbecausealthoughitappliestheterm

上一页第5页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • 第三章+国际法的基本原则

    ? All Members shall refrain in their international...colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

  • 国际法课件2

    colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

  • 国际法课件2

    colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email