unilateral non-colonial secession in international law
onastic,itwouldseemtoindicatethatpeoplescanalsoexistinanon-colonialcontext,assituationsof“aliensubjug-ation,dominationandexploitation”arenotuniquetocolonisation.
Principle5,paragraph4reiterates,thecontentofPrincipleVIofResolution1541[FN26]regardingthemethodsbywhichapeoplemayexercisetheirrighttoexternalself-determination.[FN27]However,unlikePrincipleVI,theparagraphdoesnotexplicitlyseektolimittheapplicationofitscontenttocolonialpeoples.Thisdifferenceiscrucial,asitarguablyopensthepossibilityforparagraph4toapplytonon-colonialpeoples.Paragraph4wouldthusseemtocomportwiththemeaningof“peoples”asdeducedfromparagraphs1and2.
Principle5,paragraph5dealswiththedutyof“states”torefrainfromactionthatwoulddeprive“peoples”oftheirrighttoself-determination.Theparagraph'sphraseologythereforeimplicitlyreaffirmsthatstatesandpeoplesaretwodistinctconcepts.Furthermore,ifitisacceptedthatparagraphs1,2,and4implythatpeoplesmayexistinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext,itfollowsthatthedirectivecontainedinparagraph5mustalsoapplytopeoplesinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext.
Principle5,paragraph6dealsexclusivelywithpeoplesinacolonialcontext,asindicatedbytheopeningphrase,“[t]heterritoryofacolonyorotherNon-Self-GoverningTerritoryhas,undertheCharter,astatusseparateanddis-tinctfromthe*352territoryoftheStateadministeringit.”[FN28]Thefactthatparagraph6explicitlyconfinesitspurposetocolonialpeoplesissignificantforthefactthattheotherparagraphsprecedingitdonotexplicitlyconfinetheirpurposetocolonialpeoples.Thisisfurtherinferentialevidencethattheprecedingparagraphs--1,2,4,and5--refertopeoplesbeyondthecolonialcontext.
Paragraph6continuesbynoting“suchseparateanddistinctstatusundertheChartershallexistuntilthepeopleofthecolonyorNon-Self-GoverningTerritoryhaveexercisedtheirrightofself-determination....”[FN29]Crucially,paragraph6wouldseemtoindicatethatonlyonepeoplecanexistwithinanon-self-governingterritory,astheplural“peoples”isnotemployed.[FN30]ThisdraftingisinconsistentwithArticles73,73(b),and76(b)oftheU.N.Charter,allofwhichindicatethatmorethanonepeoplemayinhabitanon-self-governingterritory.[FN31]ItisalsoinconsistentwithPrinciples2,7(a),8,and9ofResolution1541,allofwhichsuggestthatmorethanonepeoplecaninhabitanon-self-governingterritory.[FN32]Onbalance,therefore,thefailureofparagraph6tousethepluralterm“peoples”probablyconstitutesadraftingerror.
Principle5,paragraph7ofResolution2625arguablymovesbeyondthecolonialcontextwhenemployingtheterm“peoples”:
Nothingintheforegoingparagraphsshallbeconstruedasauthorizingorencouraginganyactionwhich
woulddismemberorimpair,totallyorinpart,theterritorialintegrityorpoliticalunityofsovereignandinde-pendentStatesconductingthemselvesincompliancewiththeprincipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoplesasdescribedaboveandthuspossessedofagovernmentrepresentingthewholepeoplebelongingtotheterritorywithoutdistinctionastorace,creedorcolour.[FN33]
Paragraph7hencelinksitscontentto“sovereignandindependentStates,”whichwould,onbalance,seemtoreferto“States”--notnon-self-governingterritories.Althoughitmaybearguedthatmetropolitanpowers[FN34]are“States”responsiblefornon-self-governingterritories,thisdoesnotseemtobetheprimaryobjectiveofparagraph7.Thisreasoningisnotnegatedbythesubsequentphrase:“Statesconductingthemselvesincompliancewiththeprin-cipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoplesasdescribedabove,”whichnecessarilyrequiresthatall*353otherparagraphsbeforeparagraph7mustbeconsidered--asparagraphs1,2,4,and5indicate--thatpeoplesmayexistinacolonialandnon-colonialcontext.Onlyparagraph6restrictsitsdiscussionofpeoplestothenon-self-governingorcolonialcontext.Itwouldthusseemhighlyprobablethatparagraph7isaddressingitscommentstosovereignstates,whichbyimplicationconfirmstheapplicabilityoftheterm“peoples”tothenon-colonialcontext.
Paragraph7does,however,containsomedraftingproblems.Thisisbecausealthoughitappliestheterm
? All Members shall refrain in their international...colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...
colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...
colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...
热门文档