文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 高等教育 > 法学 > unilateral non-colonial secession in international law
侵权投诉

unilateral non-colonial secession in international law

unilateral non-colonial secession in international law

ThepresentarticleexamineswhetherarighttoUNCsecessioniscontainedinUnitedNations(“U.N.”)declarat-oryGeneralAssemblyresolutions,andifso,whatmightbethelegaleffectofsucharight.Examinationofdeclarat-oryGeneralAssemblyresolutionsiscriticaltoestablishingarighttoUNCsecessionininternationallaw.[FN5]Thisisbecausescant--ifany--supportforsucharightcanbefoundintreatylaw.[FN6]YetUNCsecessionisawell-recognisedmethodofstatecreation,[FN7]whichbyitsverynatureleadstoasovereigntyconflictbetweentheexist-ingstateandthe(putative)secessioniststate.Theprimaryrulesinvokedfortheresolutionofthisconflictarethoserelatingtotheinternationallawofself-determination.Itisthisbodyoflaw,asdevelopedandappliedprimarilybytheU.N.,whichprovidesjustificationforthecreationofanewstatebywayofUNCsecession.

TwodeclaratoryGeneralAssemblyresolutionsarguablyprovideaqualified[FN8]righttoUNCsecessionforpeoples:TheDeclarationonPrinciplesofInternationalLawConcerningFriendlyRelationsandCo-operationAmongStatesinAccordanceWiththeCharteroftheUnitedNations[FN9](“FriendlyRelationsDeclaration”)andtheDe-clarationontheOccasionoftheFiftiethAnniversaryoftheUnitedNations[FN10](“FiftiethAnniversaryDeclara-tion”).Thearticle'sfirsthalfexaminesthetextualcontentoftheseinstrumentsaskingtwointerrelatedquestions:first,“whatdoestheterm‘peoples'mean?”;andsecond,“doesthelawofself-determinationprovidepeoples--howeverdefined--witharighttoUNCsecession?”[FN11]Bothquestionsarecontroversial,withvariousscholarsarguing*348for[FN12]andagainst[FN13]theextensionof“peoples”tothenon-colonialcontextandarightofpeoplestoUNCsecessionrespectively.

Thearticle'ssecondhalfinvestigatesthelegaleffectofdeclaratoryGeneralAssemblyresolutionsfromavarietyofperspectives,includingwhetherthey(1)constituteauthenticinterpretationsoftheU.N.Charter,(2)createbindingcustomarylaw,(3)servetocreategeneralprinciplesofinternationallaw,and(4)cancreatenewlawbywayofcon-sensus.Thisinvestigationisvitaltopreciselyunderstandingthelegaleffectsoftextuallyarticulatedrightsindeclar-atoryGeneralAssemblyresolutions.ThisisespeciallythecasegiventheimplicationsofUNCsecession:candeclar-atoryGeneralAssemblyresolutionscreatearightthatevenpartlyunderminesthewell-establishedprinciplesofstatesovereigntyandterritorialintegrity?

ThearticleconcludesthattheFriendlyRelationsDeclarationandFiftiethAnniversaryDeclarationarticulateaqualifiedrighttoUNCsecession,butthatthisrightwillonlygainlegaleffectbywayofcustomarylaw.Further-more,itisdeterminedthatacustomarylawrighttoUNCsecessionwillonlybelegallyperfectedbystatepracticeintermsofphysicalactsandomissions.InotherwordsstatepracticeinrelationtoUNCsecessionistdisputes,particu-larlygrantsofrecognitiontoUNCsecessionistgroups,mustbeconcomitantwiththequalifiedrighttoUNCseces-sionarticulatedindeclaratoryGeneralAssemblyresolutions.

II.TheDeclarationonPrinciplesofInternationalLawConcerningFriendlyRelationsandCo-operationAmong

StatesinAccordancewiththeCharteroftheUnitedNations(“FriendlyRelationsDeclaration”)

TheFriendlyRelationsDeclaration[FN14]wasadoptedbytheU.N.GeneralAssemblyinOctober1970,andasthenamesuggests,enumeratesprinciplesofinternationallawconcerningfriendlyrelationsandcooperationamongstates.[FN15]*349Principle5dealswiththe“equalrightsandself-determinationofpeoples”andgivenitscentral-itytothepresentarticleisreproducedinextensobelow:

[1]Byvirtueoftheprincipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoplesenshrinedintheCharteroftheUnitedNations,allpeopleshavetherightsfreelytodetermine,withoutexternalinterference,theirpoliticalstatusandtopursuetheireconomicsocialandculturaldevelopment,andeveryStatehasthedutytorespectthisrightinaccordancewiththeprovisionsoftheCharter.

[2]EveryStatehasthedutytopromote,throughjointandseparateaction,realizationoftheprincipleofequalrightsandself-determinationofpeoples,inaccordancewiththeprovisionsoftheCharter,andtorenderassistancetotheUnitedNationsincarryingouttheresponsibilitiesentrustedtoitbytheCharterregardingthe

上一页第3页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • 第三章+国际法的基本原则

    ? All Members shall refrain in their international...colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

  • 国际法课件2

    colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

  • 国际法课件2

    colonial people or an oppressed people, nor can ...In the circumstances, the National Assembly, the ...international law, to unilateral secession, that ...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email