文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 人文社科 > 法律资料 > Breach of contract in UK
侵权投诉

Breach of contract in UK

Cehave N. V. v. Bremer Handelgesellschaft m. b. H.

(The "Hansa Nord")

[1976] Q. B. 44.

[The sellers agreed to sell to the buyers 12, 000 tons of citrus pulp pellets c. i. f. Rotterdam for use as animal feed. Clause 7 of the contract provided for "shipment to be made in good condition". One shipment arrived in the "Hansa Nord" with 1, 260 tons of pellets in No. 1 hold and 2,053 tons in No. 2 hold. Much of the cargo in No.1 hold was found to be damaged while that in No. 2 hold was in substantially good condition. The buyers rejected the whole cargo. Mocatta J., on a case stated from arbitration, upheld the board's award in favour of the buyers and held that the term "shipment in good condition" was a condition of the contract, breach of which justified rejection of the goods. The sellers appealed to the Court of Appeal.]

Lord Denning M. R. [57]

"SHIPPED IN GOOD CONDITION"

The judge held that, in contracts for the sale of goods, a stipulation must either be a "condition" or a "warranty" and that there could be no tertium quid. Accepting that distinction, he held that this stipulation "shipped in good condition" was a "condition" and not a "warranty" . . . so that, for any breach of it by the seller, the buyer was entitled to treat the contract as repudiated...

THE GENERAL LAW APART FROM

THE SALE OF GOODS

For the last 300 or 400 years the courts have had to grapple with this problem: in what circumstances can a party, who is in breach himself of a stipulation of the contract, call upon the other side to perform his part or sue him for non - performance? At onetime the solution was thought to depend on the nature of the stipulation itself, and not on the extent of the breach of its consequences. Under the old forms of pleading, a plaintiff had to aver and prove that he had performed all conditions precedent or that he was ready and willing to perform them. The question, therefore, was whether the stipulation (which he had broken) was a condition precedent or not; or, in the terminology of the 18th [58] century, whether it was an independent covenant (the breach of which did debar the plaintiff because the performance by the other was dependent on the plaintiff performing his)...

Although that division was treated as exhaustive, nevertheless, when the courts came to apply it, they had regard to the extent of the breach. This was done by Lord Mansfield in 1777 in the great case of Boone v . Eyre (Note) (1779) 1 Hy. Bl. 273; 126 E. R.160. . . In the language of those times, if the breach went to the whole consideration, the covenant was considered to be a condition precedent and the defendant could plead the breach in bar of the action; but if the breach went

"only to a part, where a breach may be paid for in damages, there the defendant has a remedy on his covenant, and shall not plead it as a condition precedent" .

In short, if the breach went to the root of the matter, the stipulation was to be considered a condition precedent; but if the breach did not go to the root, the stipulation was considered to be an independent covenant which could be compensated for in damages.

[59] Apart from those cases of "breach going to the root", the courts at the same time were developing the doctrine of "anticipatory breach'. When one party, before the day when he is obliged to perform his part, declares in advance that he will not perform it when the day comes, or by his conduct evinces an intention not to perform it, the other may elect to treat his declaration or conduct as a breach going to the root of the matter and to treat himself as discharged from further performance: see Hochster v. LIZ la Tour I (1853) 2 E. & B. 678; 118 E. R. 922. By his prior declaration or conduct the guilty party is said to repudiate the contract. The word "repudiation" should be confined to those cases of an anticipatory breach, but it is also used in connection with cases of an actual breach going to the root of the contract (see Heynwn v. Dar-wins Ltd [1942) A. C. 356, 378-379, per Lord Wright). All of them

第1页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • Chapter 18 Contracts — Breach of Contract and Reme...

    breach of contract 15页 2财富值 Disgorgement for Breach,... 34页 20财富值 Unit 5 Breach of Contra... 28页 1财富值 Breach of contract in UK 3...

  • ...repudiatory-breach-of-sale-contract

    breach of contract 15页 2财富值 Breach of contract in UK 3页 1财富值 Expectation Damages and ... 56页 免费 Unit 5 Breach of Contra... 暂无评价...

  • Unit 5 Breach of Contract

    Right to avoidance Avoidance of installment contract elements of contract breach (China) the two elements that constitute a contract breach: breach: (1)...

  • group 8Remedies for breach the contract

    breach of contract 15页 2财富值 Breach of contract in UK 3页 1财富值 Lecture #8 - Breach of S... 35页 免费 Unit 5 Breach of Contra... 暂无...

  • In memory of Derek Breach

    Breach of contract in UK 3页 1财富值 Do Promises Matter An Ex... 18页 1财富值 In memory of 21页 免费 0 1992 Gordon and Breach... 暂无评价 ...

  • Unit 3 Enforceability of Contract

    In UK The general rule is that a minor is not bound by a contract ...breach of contract; whether the person allegedly exerting the pressure has ...

  • breach of contract

    breach of contract_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。精读 breach of contract...of important informationThree elements in the defense of fraud: ...

  • 商法 英文版 课件contract law6(breach)

    商法 英文版 课件contract law6(breach)_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。Contract law 1 6.1Breach of Contract 6.1.1The patterns of breach ? Anticipatory ...

  • 国际贸易法Chapter 2.5 Remedies for Breach of Contract

    国际贸易法Chapter 2.5 Remedies for Breach of Contract_销售/营销_经管营销_专业资料。Chapter 2 ITL Contract Laws Unit 5 Remedies for Breach of Contract ...

  • 英国合同法相关问题

    Remedies for breach of contract(违约救济) Types of remedies: (1) Damages; (损害赔偿) (2)specific performance;(依约实际履行合同) (3)injunction;(不得...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email