公允价值:金融危机的“元凶”、“帮凶”还是“替罪羊”?
——兼论美国金融危机的应对措施
兰凤云 张军
( 北京物资学院商学院 北京 101149 中国社会科学院经济研究所博士后流动站) 摘要:金融危机和公允价值的关系主要有“元凶说”、“帮凶说”、“替罪羊说”。 金融危机微观层面的根本原因是美国金融机构治理结构不完善,导致高管层激励机制异化,管理层薪酬高且没有与风险挂钩。这导致金融机构积极从事高风险业务,采用高杠杆持有,故意模糊证券化过程,欺骗消费者,造成房地产泡沫,泡沫破灭酿成金融危机。金融业高管层为逃避责任,利用其话语权,将公允价值指为“元凶”,公允价值成为替罪羊。本文认为预防金融危机应标本兼治,治本之策是完善金融机构公司治理,优化激励机制。 关键词:公允价值;金融危机;元凶;帮凶;替罪羊
Fair value: culprit,Accomplice or scapegoat of financial crisis?
Abstract: The main view of relationship between financial crisis and fair value are culprit, accomplice and scapegoat. The root causes of the financial crisis in U.S. financial industry is flawed management structure, this result to alienation of senior management incentives, management compensation and access to the high risk business. This has led to the financial industry actively involved in high-risk business, and hold with high leverage, deliberately blurred process of securitization in order to deceive consumers,and even to manipulate the use of fair value gains, resulting in a real estate bubble,bubble burst led to the financial crisis. Top management of financial sector in order to avoid the responsibility, so use its voice right refer fair value as “culprits”, therefore fair value is a scapegoat. This article holds that the prevention of financial crisis, we should take both radical and stopgap measures to solve the problem, so we should improve financial sector governance, optimize the incentive mechanism. Keywords: Fair value; financial crisis; culprit; accomplices; scapegoat
引言
2007年4月2日,从美国第二大次级抵押贷款公司——新世纪金融公司申请破产开始,次贷危机(本文对次贷危机和金融危机不作区分)爆发,随后两房被接管,雷曼、美林倒下,AIG被国有化,华盛顿互惠银行破产,次贷危机随即演变成全球性金融危机,从金融领域扩散到实体经济,从发达国家传导到发展中国家。国际主要金融市场动荡加剧,欧洲主要金融机构相继发生风险,被迫由政府救助或被其他金融机构兼并。欧洲、日本和新兴市场股市大幅下挫,不少市场跌幅超过50%。在金融危机的严重冲击下,发达经济体陷入全面衰退,新兴经济体也面临着严重冲击,引起全世界关注。关于次贷危机的原因众说纷纭,目前认为主要有房地产泡沫、货币政策失误、低利率、信用评级机构渎职、过度证券化等(Katalina M. Bianco,2008)。令人意外的是,部分金融机构,如AIG,UBS,IMF等认为金融业采用公允价值计量是“元凶”之一。因为公允价值导致金融机构确认巨额的未实现、没有现金流的账面损失,这些损失引起投资者恐慌,导致他们抛售次贷产品金融机构的股票。另外有部分人士作者简介:兰凤云,女,北京物资学院商学院会计系主任,副教授;张军,男,北京物资学院商学院讲师,会计学博士,经济学博士后。
热门文档