
JournalofBusinessResearch67(2014)1154–1161
ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
JournalofBusinessResearch
Advancingtheaestheticmiddleprinciple:Trade-offsindesignattractivenessandstrength
JoanL.Giesea, ,1,2,KevenMalkewitzb,1,UlrichR.Orthc,1,PamelaW.Hendersond
a
UniversityofMontana,Missoula,MT59812-6808,USAWesternOregonUniversity,Monmouth,OR97361,USAc
A&FMarketing,Christian-Albrechts-UniversitätKiel,Wilhelm-Seelig-Platz6/7,24098Kiel,Germanyd
NewEdge,Inc.,1350SpauldingAvenue,Richland,WA99352,USA
b
articleinfoabstract
Keydesignpropertiesofmarketingartifactsthatin uenceconsumerresponseincludeperceivedattractiveness(thevalencedevaluativeresponsetotheartifact)andperceivedstrength(theartifact’sabilitytocaptureatten-tion).Theaestheticmiddleprinciplecontendsthatthedesignsmosteffectiveingeneratingpurchaseintentionsarecounterintuitivelynotthemostattractiveandstrongest,butratherdesignstemperedtobemoderatelyattractiveandverystrongorveryattractiveandmoderatelystrong.Suchdesignsarevisualrepresentationsclosertotheaestheticmiddle,therebypromptingmorefavorableconsumerresponses.Thisresearchempiricallyteststheaestheticmiddleprincipleintwoconsumer eldstudies,usingbothsimple(typeface)andcomplex(winepackage)designs.Inasubsequentcontrolledexperiment,thestrongestaestheticmiddleeffectsemergeforhedonic(ratherthanutilitarian)productsandwhenlessproduct-relatedinformationisavailable.Theeffectsoftheaestheticmiddleoccurregardlessofavailablecognitiveresourcesorindividualdifferencesindesignacumen.
PublishedbyElsevierInc.
Articlehistory:
Received16May2012
Receivedinrevisedform6May2013Accepted7May2013
Availableonline16June2013Keywords:
Designstrength
DesignattractivenessAestheticmiddleTypefacePackage
1.Introduction
Marketersfrequentlyusestimulitoelicitfavorablecustomerbehaviors,suchassendingacarefullydesigneddirectmailpiecetosolicitcontributionsordevelopinganattractivewinebottletotriggerpurchase.Inthesecases,multipledesignpropertiescombinetostim-ulatepurchaseintentions(Bloch,1995).Visualdesignsofmarketingstimuliarewell-establishedconsumerbehaviordrivers(e.g.,Bloch,1995;Doyle&Bottomley,2004;Henderson&Cote,1998;Lee,Ha,&Widdows,2011;Muller,Kocher,&Crettaz,2013;Orth&Malkewitz,2008),especiallywhenconsumerslackproduct-relatedknowledgeorexpertise(Alba&Hutchinson,1987;Dhar&Novemsky,2008).Inaddi-tion,twokeypropertiesofvisualstimuli—perceivedattractivenessandstrength—promptconsumerresponses(Page&Herr,2002).Potentialbuyersuseperceptionsofattractivenesstoformbehavioralintentions(Bloch,Brunel,&Arnold,2003;Reber,Schwarz,&Winkielman,2004)andrespondconsistentlytotheperceivedstrengthofadesign(Bafna,2008;Karlsson,Aronsson,&Svensson,2003;Page&Herr,2002).Yetknowledgeabouttheeffectsofcombinationsofdifferentlevelsof
Correspondingauthor.Tel.:+14062432273.
E-mailaddresses:joan.giese@business.umt.edu(J.L.Giese),malkewik@wou.edu(K.Malkewitz),uorth@ae.uni-kiel.de(U.R.Orth),pam.henderson@new-edge.com(P.W.Henderson).1
Authorscontributedequallyandarelistedalphabetically.2
ThispaperwasdevelopedwhiletheauthorwasattheUniversityofOregonandKansasState

University.
0148-2963/$–seefrontmatter.PublishedbyElsevierInc.

doc.guandang.net
multipledesignpropertiesremainslacking(Orth&Malkewitz,2008;Park,Eisingerich,Pol,&Park,2013).
Seminalresponsetheorysuggeststhatperceivedattractivenesscorre-spondswiththepleasuredimension,whereasstrengthcorrespondswiththepotency/dominancedimension(Mehrabian&Russell,1974;Osgood,Suci,&Tannenbaum,1957).Inpractice,speci cdesignelements,factors,orholisticdesignsconveyperceivedattractivenessandstrength(Henderson,Giese,&Cote,2004;Orth&Malkewitz,2008).Perceptionsofattractiveness(VandenBergh&Vrana,1998;Veryzer&Hutchinson,1998)andstrength(Janiszewski&Meyvis,2001)in uencecustomerre-sponses,somarketersroutinelyemployattractive,strongdesignstodif-ferentiatetheirpropositions(Keller,1993).Accordingtoresearchintotherelativerolesofhedonicandutilitarianvalueseeking,thevisualoraestheticappealassociatedwithadesignconstitutesahedonicbene t,elicitingemotionandleadingtotheful llmentofpromotion-orientedgoals(Chernev,2004;Chitturi,Raghunathan,&Mahajan,2007).
Integratingdesignresearchwithvisualperceptiontheories(Arnheim,1974;Page&Herr,2002;Veryzer,1999),affectiveresponseframeworks(Mehrabian&Russell,1974),andhedonic–utilitarianbene tsresearch(Chitturi,Raghunathan,&Mahajan,2008),thepresentresearchexaminesthecounterintuitivedesignprincipleofthe“aestheticmiddle”(Arnheim,1974),accordingtowhichmaximizingbothattractivenessandstrengthmaynotbeoptimalforstimulatingpurchaseintentions.Instead,temper-ingeitherattractivenessorstrengthmayyieldavisualrepresentationclosertotheaestheticmiddle,promptingmorefavorableresponses.Inac-cordancewithresearchthatindicatesthatvariationinmotivationalgoalsleadsconsumerstoattachdifferentrelativeimportancetohedonicand
读书笔记 Psychical distance as a factor in art and an aesthetic principle_设计/艺术_人文社科_专业资料。Psychical distance’ as a factor in art and an ...
Seura?s Aesthetic Opinion, 1890 Art is harmony....the middle of a river Half an hour from the ...Advancing art is easy- Financing it is not. A...
4) advancing any suggestions for the course ...rule or principle on which a judgment is based....Not spoil the aesthetic effect of the original ?...
the application of rhetoric Lvxu’s Aesthetic ...? I see advancing upon all this in hideous ...principle except appetite and racial domination. ...
the developments of affection advancing the harmonious developments of their ...cognition and affect is one of the basical requirements in aesthetic ...
the developments of affection advancing the harmonious developments of their ...cognition and affect is one of the basical requirements in aesthetic ...
热门文档