Uncertaintiesindilatometricdeterminationofmartensitestarttemperature
Hong-SeokYangandH.K.D.H.Bhadeshia
Methodsforthedilatometricdeterminationofthemartensitestarttemperatureofsteelsarediscussed,withemphasisonnoiseintheexperimentaldata.Themethodsaretestedonanewsetofexperimentsusingaspeciallypreparedsteel.Relyingonthefirstdetectionofexpansionduetotransformationisfraughtwithdifficulties.Instead,anoffsetmethodisproposedwhichshouldenableindependentinvestigatorstoreachthesameconclusionsgivenidenticaldata.Thetechniqueatthesametimepreservesthenotionthattheearlystagesofmartensiteformationcorrespondtothestarttemperature.Theuncertaintyinthestarttemperaturededucedusingthismethodisabout¡12uC,betterthanthereportedvaluesofnoiseinpublisheddata.Theworkunderlinestheneedtostatethesensitivityoftheanalysistechniquewhenquotingtransformationtemperatures.
Keywords:Dilatometry,Martensite,Transformations,Steels
Introduction
Thereisachangeindensitywhenmartensiteformsin
steels,whichcanbemeasuredusingdilatometry.Most
dilatometersareofthepushrodtypeandhenceare
limitedtodetectingthelengthchangeduetothevolume
strainaccompanyingsolidstatereactions.Oneofthe
parametersthatcanbeextractedfromtheplotofthe
changeinlengthasafunctionofthetemperatureis
themartensitestartMStemperature.Adeviationofthe
lengthfromthatexpectedduetothermalcontractionis
takentoimplytransformation.Thisraisesdif cultiesin
thattheextentofdeviationmustbede nedandthe
procedureusedinnotalwaysclear.Insomerecentwork,
theMShasbeenidenti edbeyondthepointwherethe
curvedepartssigni cantlyfromthermalcontractionata
highertemperature.1
Evenforthecasewherethede nitionofMSisthe
pointwhereexpansionisdetected,uncertaintiesexist
becausetheoutputofadilatometerisneverperfect;the
datacontainnoisewhichismostlyignoredwhen
measurementsarereported.Thepurposeofthepresent
workwastoexaminesystematicallytheeffectofthis
noiseonthedeterminationoftheMStemperature.The
workwasinspiredwhenattemptsweremadetoverify
certaintheoreticalpredictionsoftransformationtem-
peratures;thechoiceofthealloyisconsistentwiththe
aimsofthatwiderstudy.2,3Thepresentexperimentsare
concernedwithmartensiteinahighhardenabilitysteel,
butthemethodologypresentedshouldbegenerally
applicableintheinterpretationofdilatometricdata.Theprimaryaimistode neamethodwhichenablesindependentassessmentsofthesamedilatometricdatatoreachidenticalnumericalconclusions.ExperimentalAtechniqueusuallyappliedtomanufacturestandardsforchemicalanalysiswasusedtomakethealloys.Asolidcylindricalsampleofdimensions3.668cmwascentrifugallycastandthenhomogenisedinavacuumfurnacefor2daysat1200uC.Thelengthofthesamplewasthencutinto vepiecesofequalthickness;theirindividualchemicalanalysesareshowninTable1.ThecarbonconcentrationwasanalysedusingaLECOanalysertoareproducibilityof¡0.0013wt-%,andtheremainingelementsusingsparkopticalemissionspec-troscopytoareproducibilityof¡0.003wt-%.Thesechemicalcompositiondatacanbeusedtoestimatetheexpectedvariationinthemartensitestarttemperature.Usingthemethodologydescribedelsewhere,4,5thevaria-tionexpectedonthebasisofthetabulatedcompositionsisestimatedtobejust¡1uC.Cylindricaldilatometricsamplesofdiameter4mmandlength7mmweremachined,someofwhichweremadehollowbydrillinga3mmdiameterlongitudinalhole.ApushrodBAHRDIL805highspeeddilatometerwithradiofrequencyinductionheatingwasused.Thesampletemperatureismeasuredbyathermocoupleweldedtoitssurfaceusingaprecisionwelderandjigsuppliedbythedilatometermanufacturer.Eachsample
wasaustenitisedat950uCfor3min,followedbycooling
ataconstantratetoambienttemperature.Thecooling
ratesusedwereintherange3.2–330uCs21.Itwasnot
possibletomaintainaconstantcoolingratewhen˙>140uCs21,sothestatedvaluesinthosecasesareT
overtherange300–500uC.GraduateInstituteofFerrousTechnologyPOSTECH,Hyoja–dongsan31,Pohang790784,Korea*Correspondingauthor,emailhkdb@postech.ac.kr
556ß2007InstituteofMaterials,MineralsandMiningPublishedbyManeyonbehalfoftheInstituteReceived2September2006;accepted7November2006
DOI10.1179/174328407X176857MaterialsScienceandTechnology2007VOL23NO5
热门文档