124C.Babilonietal./NeuroImage44(2009)123–135
al.,2001).However,the“transition”hypothesisischallengedbyobservationsindicatingthatnotallMCIsubjectsdeteriorateovertime(Bennettetal.,2002;Larrieuetal.,2002),asADcumulativeincidenceratesrangefrom40to60%(Bennettetal.,2002;Larrieuetal.,2002;Fisketal.,2003).
Theimportancetoselectappropriateneuropsychologicaltestsandtode nenormativeperformanceforearlyADdiagnosisandmonitoringpurposeshasbeensuggested(Salmon,2007).ConcerningneuropsychologicalmarkersofearlierstagesofAD,acrucialfunctiontobetestedisepisodicmemory,namelytheabilitytorecalleventsthatarespeci ctoatimeandplace(Welshetal.,1992).AsADspreadsfromentorhinal–hippocampalregionstocorticalassociationareas,othercrucialcognitivefunctionsareattentionand“executive”functions(goalformulation,planning,andexecutionofgoal-directedplans),semanticmemory(word,face,andobjectknowledge),language,praxis,andconstructionalandvisuo-spatialabilities(Nestoretal.,2004;Marianietal.,2007).CAMCOGMemoryandPerceptioncognitivescreeningitemshavebeenfoundtobeoptimumindepen-denttoolstoclassifyMCIsubjectswhowillprogresstoADwitharelativeriskofprogressionof4–10times(Marcosetal.,2006).AlthoughneuropsychologicalmarkersareofextremeimportanceintheassessmentofpreclinicalstagesofAD,thereisaconsensusthatacrucialchallengeofagingresearchisabetterunderstandingoftheneurobiologicalbasisofMCIcondition,inordertore nethediagnosticproceduresandtotargetnewpharmacologicalinterven-tions(BraakandBraak,1991;Rogersetal.,1996;Smalletal.,1995;Nestoretal.,2004).
BasedonhistopathologicalevidencethattheentorhinalcortexandhippocampusareearlysitesaffectedbyAD,moststructuralmagneticresonanceimaging(MRI)studiesinMCIsubjectshavefocusedonthesetwostructureslocatedinthemedialtemporallobe(deLeonetal.,2004).Anatrophy(about30%)ofmedialtemporallobeinmildtomoderatelysevereADpatientshasbeenshown(Romboutsetal.,2000;Baronetal.,2001;Ohnishietal.,2001;Frisonietal.,2002;Wolfetal.,2003;Testaetal.,2004).Furthermore,atrophy(about10%)inthemedialtemporallobe,temporalneocortex,superiorparietallobule,anteriorcingulategyrus,andthalamusinMCIsubjectshasbeendetected(Chetelatetal.,2002;Pennanenetal.,2005).Recently,themeasurementofnormalizedhippocampalatrophyhasbeeninvokedintheinternationalguidelinesfortheassessmentofearlyAD(Duboisetal.,2007).
ToevaluategeneralmechanismsofcorticalneuralsynchronizationthatbecomeabnormalalongMCIandADconditions,restingeyes-closedelectroencephalographic(EEG)recordingshavebeenrepeat-edlyperformed.Whencomparedtohealthyelderly(Nold)subjects,ADpatientshavebeencharacterizedbyhighpowerofdelta(0–4Hz)andtheta(4–7Hz)rhythms,andlowpowerofposterioralpha(8–12Hz)and/orbeta(13–30Hz)rhythms(Dierksetal.,1993,2000;Huangetal.,2000;Ponomarevaetal.,2003;Jeong,2004;Babilonietal.,2004;Prichepetal.,2005).TheseEEGabnormalitieswereassociatedwithalteredregionalcerebralblood ow/metabolismandwithimpairedglobalcognitivefunctionasevaluatedbyminimentalstateexamination(MMSE;Sloanetal.,1995;Rodriguezetal.,1998,1999a,1999b;Jeong,2004).Furthermore,posterioralpharhythmsshowedapowerdecre-mentinMCIcomparedtoNoldsubjects(Zappolietal.,1995;ElmstahlandRosen,1997;Huangetal.,2000;Jelicetal.,2000;Koenigetal.,2005;Babilonietal.,2006b).However,acertainvariabilityofbrainrhythmicityinpathologicalagingmightpreventitsuseforpersonalizeddiagnosisandprognosis,especiallyatearlierstagesofMCIcondition.Forexample,recentmagnetoencephalographicevidencehasshownnostatisticallysigni cantdifferenceofbrainrhythmsinnormalelderlyandMCIsubjects(Osipovaetal.,2006).
ThementionedstudiesindicatethatEEGrhythmsandMRIparameters(i.e.hippocampalatrophy)re ectcognitivedeclineinthespectrumrangingfromMCItoADcondition.AnotherbulkofpreviousevidencehasshownthatEEGandMRIdatacomplement
eachotherinthemodelingofpsychomotorspeed,globalcognition,memory,andlanguageability(reviewedinStrijersetal.,1997).Brainatrophyhasbeentheprimaryfactorassociatedwithpsychomotorspeedonthetrailmakingtest,whereasevent-relatedchangesofalpharhythmshavebeenassociatedtoawiderrangeofcognitivefunctions(vanderHieleetal.,2007).Moreover,abilateralreductionofhippocampalandentorhinalvolumesofADsubjectshasbeenrecentlycorrelatedwithanincrementofcorticalmagnetoencephalo-graphicdeltarhythms(Fernandezetal.,2003).Finally,ithasbeenshownthatMCIsubjectswithdifferentdegreesofhippocampalatrophywerecharacterizedbyadiversepowerofrestingEEGrhythms,especiallyatdominantalphafrequencies(Morettietal.,2007).Keepinginmindthesedata,areasonablehypothesisisthathippocampalatrophyandrestingEEGrhythmsareinter-relatednotonlywithinMCIsub-groupsbutalsointhecontinuumalongMCIandADconditions.Totestthishypothesis,hereweevaluatedthehippocampalatrophyandrestingEEGrhythmsintheMCIsubjectsofamentionedstudy(Morettietal.,2007)withrespecttothoseofagroupofADsubjectshavingsimilarpersonalfeatures.Speci cally,weprobedandcomparedlinearandnon-linearrelationshipsbetweenhippocampalatrophyandcorticalsourcesofrestingEEGrhythmsacrossMCIandADsubjects.Ofnote,theuseofhippocampalatrophyasindependentvariableisbasedontherecentinternationalguide-linesemphasizingtheroleofthisvariableintheinstrumentalassessmentofAD(Pattersonetal.,2008).Methods
Subjectsanddiagnosticcriteria
Inthisstudy,88MCIsubjectsand35ADpatientswereevaluated.Furthermore,60cognitivelynormalelderly(Nold)subjectswererecruitedasacontrolgroup.Noteworthy,these88MCIsubjectswerethoseofapreviousreferencestudy(Morettietal.,2007),whereastheremaining95subjectswererecruitedtogloballymatchthepersonalvariablesoftheMCIsubjects.
Localinstitutionalethicscommitteesapprovedthestudy.Allexperimentswereperformedwiththeinformedandovertconsentofeachparticipantorcaregiver,inlinewiththeCodeofEthicsoftheWorldMedicalAssociation(DeclarationofHelsinki)andthestandardsestablishedbytheAuthor'sInstitutionalReviewBoard.
ThepresentinclusionandexclusioncriteriaforMCIwerebasedonpreviousseminalreports(Albertetal.,1991;Devanandetal.,1997;Flickeretal.,1991;Petersenetal.,1995,1997,2001;Rubinetal.,1989;Zaudig,1992;Portetetal.,2006),andweredescribedindetailinthepreviousreferencestudy(Morettietal.,2007).Summarizing,theinclusioncriteriawereasfollows:(i)objectivememoryimpairmentonneuropsychologicalevaluation,asde nedbyperformances≥1.5standarddeviationbelowthemeanvalueofageandeducation-matchedcontrolsforaneuropsychologicaltestbatteryofneuropsy-chologicaltests,toassesscognitiveperformanceinthedomainsofmemory(i.e.Busckhe-FuldandMemoryReytests),language,execu-tivefunction/attention,andvisuo-construction;(ii)normalactivitiesofdailylivingasdocumentedbythehistoryandevidenceofindependentliving;and(iii)clinicaldementiaratingscoreof0.5.Theexclusioncriteriaincluded:(i)mildAD,asdiagnosedbystandardprotocolsincludingNINCDS-ADRDA(McKhannetal.,1984);(ii)evidence(includingdiagnosticMRIprocedures)ofconcomitantdementiasuchasfrontotemporal,vasculardementia,reversibledementias(includingpseudo-depressivedementia),marked uctua-tionsincognitiveperformancecompatiblewithLewybodydementiaand/orfeaturesofmixeddementias;(iii)evidenceofconcomitantextra-pyramidalsymptoms;(iv)clinicalandindirectevidenceofdepressionasrevealedbyGeriatricDepressionScalescoreshigherthan13;(v)otherpsychiatricdiseases,epilepsy,drugaddiction,alcoholdependence(asrevealedbyapsychiatricinterview)anduseof
single hippocampal generator or that cortical theta...sources of the observed changes in EEG theta and...(1999). Frontal midline theta rhythms re?ect ...
single hippocampal generator or that cortical theta...sources of the observed changes in EEG theta and...(1999). Frontal midline theta rhythms re?ect ...
热门文档