Good morning, my distinguished judge and audience. My speech today includes two parts. First, the rebuttal to the government. And then, I’ll summarize the main clashes and prove to you by comparison of both teams’ major arguments, that it is our team that should win the case, that is to say, capital punishment should not be abolished.
First of all, the government tried to prove that as poor education is the root cause of most crimes, capital punishment is not justifiable. However, this counter-plan of education is neither reasonable nor practical. The DPM mentioned that most murderers are poorly educated. Following this logic, in order to solve the problem from the root, the government must start from the everyday quality education for all citizens. However, this is impossible, with China’s large population and lack of resources. What’s more, considering after-crime education brought up by the PM, just as our team has mentioned, there’s no proof of its effectiveness. But as capital punishment can reduce potential murderers by deterrence and doesn’t have the burden of costs the counter-plans will bring about, it should by no means be abolished.
Next, I’ll summarize the 3 major clashes in this debate and prove to you that our arguments are more convincing. The clashes are: 1. Whether the government’s act of sentencing people to death can be justified or not. 2. Human rights of criminals vs. an eye for an eye. 3. In weighing the pros and cons of capital punishment and its counter- plans, which is more effective?
First, considering whether the government has the right to sentence people to death, the proposition team argues that it doesn’t, as using killing to punish killing is also a crime. However, this is faulty as they failed to realize the true role of the government. As our OL pointed out, according to the Social Contract, the government is formed by the general will to protect the people’s rights and thus has the right to enforce penalties to maintain social order. Ensured by law, death penalty is different from murder and are by no means comparable. They also mentioned that it can lead to irreversible harm, so the government shouldn’t be granted this right. However, as our team stated, all punishments are irreversible. You justify life-long imprisonment, then why abolish death penalty? One can surely not say that a great idle of time and mental disorder are less harmful. What’s more, one of our arguments says that as the government’s use of punishment is mainly for deterrence, and as death penalty most effectively achieves this goal, this right can surely be justified.
The second clash is on the criminals’ rights. The proposition believes that men have the right to live on all conditions. However, they fail to see that in extreme cases, individual rights must give way to public rights. They also fail to see that the life-long imprisonment they promote also deprives one of men’s basic rights – liberty. As our side pointed out, the law should protect the right of the majority. And as proved before, when innocent citizens’ rights are violated, the government is justified by law to punish the criminal. For those who choose to violate the law and jump out of the system, their rights are no longer preserved. What’s more, our team believes that from the concept “an eye
capital punishment_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。比较中美死刑Capital Punishment About Capital Punishment ? ? ? ? practised by most societies in the past ...
Capital Punishment ---Damon_法律资料_人文社科_专业资料。Yellow damon 134612205 Contents 1 Capital punishment in the world 10 Horrifying Methods Of Capita...
sth. Which stops people doing sth.制 止物,威慑因素,威慑力量 They seriously believe that capital punishment is a deterrent.他们真的相信死刑具有威慑作用。 ...
Capital Punishment_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。与同名的PPT内容配合串词。。。 Four parts 1.Introduction 2.Compared with legal punishment 3.Capital punishment...
capital punishment 18页 5财富值 capital punishment 4页 2财富值 Capital Punishment 6页 2财富值 Capital Punishment Or No... 2页 10财富值 On Capital ...
Capital Punishment The death penalty, or be called the capital punishment, is born from the criminal law from the very beginning, the death penalty is...
Capital Punishment As a kind of punishment,capital punishment may be the most brutal because it takes everything of a person.The most precious thing of...
Capital punishment死刑_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。死刑该不该被废除?Capital punishment, the only way to deter criminals? On May 7th,177 students from ...
In modern society Capital Punishment is a highly controversial and hotly contested issue. Improve lawful consciousness ---Adrina ...
Capital punishment should not be abolished As the society develops, various crimes appeared. Like other countries, we also have some severe crimes in our ...
热门文档