厦门大学微观经济学课件
CHAPTER 9
THE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITIVE MARKETS

With the exception of Chapter 1, Chapter 9 is the most straightforward and easily understood chapter in the text. The chapter begins with a review of consumer and producer surplus in section 9.1. If you have postponed these topics, you should carefully explain the definition of each. Section 9.2 discusses the basic concept of efficiency in competitive markets by comparing competitive outcomes with those under market failure. A more detailed discussion of efficiency is presented in Chapter 16. Sections 9.3 to 9.6 present examples of government policies that cause the market equilibrium to differ from the competitive, efficient equilibrium. The instructor can pick and choose among sections
9.3 to 9.6 depending on time constraints and personal preference. The presentation in each of these sections follows the same format: there is a general discussion of why market intervention leads to deadweight loss, followed by the presentation of an important policy example. Each section is discussed in one review question and applied in at least one exercise. Exercise (1) focuses on minimum wages presented in Section 9.3. Exercises (4) and (5) reinforce discussion of price supports and production quotas from Section 9.4. The use of tariffs and quotas, presented in Section 9.5, can be found in Exercises (3), (6), (7), (8), (11), and (12). Taxes and subsidies (Section 9.6) are discussed in Exercises (2), (9), and (14). Exercise (10) reviews natural gas price controls in Example 9.1, a continuation of Example 2.7. Exercise (4) may be compared to Example 9.4 and discussed as an extension of Example 2.2.

1. What is meant by deadweight loss? Why does a price ceiling usually result in a deadweight loss?
Deadweight loss refers to the benefits lost to either consumers or producers when
markets do not operate efficiently. The term deadweight denotes that these are
benefits unavailable to any party. A price ceiling will tend to result in a deadweight
loss because at any price below the market equilibrium price, quantity supplied will be
below the market equilibrium quantity supplied, resulting in a loss of surplus to
producers. Consumers will purchase less than the market equilibrium quantity,
resulting in a loss of surplus to consumers. Consumers will also purchase less than the
quantity they demand at the price set by the ceiling. The surplus lost by consumers
and producers is not captured by either group, and surplus not captured by market
participants is deadweight loss.
2. Suppose the supply curve for a good is completely inelastic. If the government imposed a price ceiling below the market-clearing level, would a deadweight loss result? Explain.
When the supply curve is completely inelastic, the imposition of an effective price
ceiling transfers all loss in producer surplus to consumers. Consumer surplus
increases by the difference between the market-clearing price and the price ceiling
times the market-clearing quantity. Consumers capture all decreases in total revenue.
Therefore, no deadweight loss occurs.
3. How can a price ceiling make consumers better off? Under what conditions might it make them worse off?
If the supply curve is perfectly inelastic a price ceiling will increase consumer surplus.
If the demand curve is inelastic, price controls may result in a net loss of consumer
surplus because consumers willing to pay a higher price are unable to purchase the
price-controlled good or service. The loss of consumer surplus is greater than the
transfer of producer surplus to consumers. If demand is elastic (and supply is
relatively inelastic) consumers in the aggregate will enjoy an increase in consumer
surplus.
热门文档