Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas
Historians of ideas focus on two types of meaning – literal and intended meaning. Quentin Skinner makes two key distinctions: between literal and intended meaning, and between text and contexts. These distinctions should be considere considered separately. A statement‘s intended meaning may differ from its literal meaning – the sense and reference of the terms used to express it. Skinner‘s first example is irony. Taken literally, Defoe‘s The Shortest-Way With the Dissenters argues that dissenters should be executed. Taken ironically, as Defoe actually intended, the argument is for toleration, not persecution. To conclude that Defoe meant to defend persecution would be to confuse literal and intended meanings, to confuse what the words say and what Defoe meant by them. Irony is the textbook case‘ of a divergence between what a person says and what she means‘.
Skinner‘s second example is ambiguity. We should look to intended meanings when literal meanings are unclear – when the speaker fails to make clear how exactly the utterance is to be taken or understood‘. Ambiguity is rampant‘ in natural
languages, and perhaps no statement is ever entirely unambiguous. Much more could be said about speech-act theory. The basic point is that intended and literal meanings diverge, and we usually prioritise intended meanings. This
view is standard for philosophers of language, although they differ from each other in many details. Of course, my brief account cannot fully justify this position. But three points are briefly worth emphasising.
The value of textual analysis should be briefly highlighted. We do not need contextual analysis to reject obvious misreadings, like Geoffrey Hill‘s bizarre claim that Hobbes believed in intrinsic value. Indeed, the Cambridge school‘s huge contribution to intellectual history partly reflects high-quality textual analysis.
Reading a text carefully is necessary – but not sufficient. Ultimately, the combination of textual and contextual analysis is crucial, as in Skinner‘s superlative analysis of Hobbes‘s changing account of liberty.
In summary, for many intellectual historians the aim is to uncover intended meanings, and the means to that end are textual and/or contextual analysis, both of which may involve analysing literal meaning.
斯金纳
斯金纳是行为主义学派最负盛名的代表人物——被称为―彻底的行为主义者‖。也是世界心理学史上最为著名的心理学家之一.
在哈佛大学攻读心理学硕士的时候,他受到了行为主义心理学的吸引,成为了一名彻头彻尾的行为主义者,从此开始了他一生的心理学家生涯。他在华生等人的基础上向前迈进了一大步,提出了有别于巴甫洛夫的条件反射的另一种条件反射行为,并将二者做了区分,在此基础上提出了自己的行为主义理论——操作性条件反射理论。他长期致力于研究鸽子和老鼠的操作性条件反射行为,提出了―及时强化‖的概念以及强化的时间规律,形成了自己的一套理论。 斯金纳还将操作性条件反射理论应用于对人的研究,他认为,人是没有尊严和自由的,人们作出某种行为,不做出某种行为,只取决于一个影响因素,那就是行为的后果。人并不能自由选择自己的行为,而是根据奖惩来决定自己以何种方式行动,因此,
西方历史学经典名著选读读书笔记1_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。The History 1...4、感悟 有文章可以看出希罗多德对历史的描述更多是建立在主观的认识之上,史 料...
《西方管理学名著导读》读书笔记_管理学_高等教育_...协调更有效率和更有利可图时, 才首次在历史上出现...(四)大量生产与大量分配的结合 美国工业界最早的...
西方哲学经典名著选读_哲学/历史_人文社科_专业资料。西方哲学经典名著选读目录(...《形而上学》《政治学》 、 3、奥古斯丁: 《上帝之城》《忏悔录》 、 4、...
西方管理学名著选读读后感_金融/投资_经管营销_专业... 管理学名著读后感 4页 2下载券 管理学著作读后感 ... 管理名著读书心得 18页 2下载券 管理学名著阅读...
西方史学史 《编年史》读书笔记_历史学_高等教育_...、、 《编年史》是塔西陀的最后一部著作,十六卷本...四:宗教迷信色彩塔西陀的思想中夹杂着宗教迷信色彩,...
马原名著选读 经典篇目读书笔记_哲学_高等教育_...模式是在50年代初中期的历史条件下进行的,当时对...既影响了流通又影响了生产 4、在分配上存在着重积累...
马克思主义经典著作读书笔记_哲学/历史_人文社科_...4 《<政治经济学批判>序言》 ......并没有因为西方国家经济、科 技的发展而有本质的改变。 资本主义...
4《活着》读书笔记 只要活着 我喜欢看书,喜欢看各种各样的书,看的很杂,文学... 西方历史学经典名著选读... 3页 免费 10篇名著读书笔记 8页 免费...
·人类学名著选读期末读书笔记· 1 读《社会人类学...的历史和功能的文化解释;第三章/人类学研究的现状;第四章/社会人类学 的意义与范围;第五章/社会人类...
世界名著读书笔记或读后感15·18篇_建筑/土木_工程...4《活着》读书笔记只要活着 我喜欢看书,喜欢看各种...读这本书我仿佛读了一遍《圣经》,西方人对宗教笃深...
热门文档