拭子技术与组织活检比较
Diagnostic validity of three swab techniques for identifying chronic wound infection
三种拭子技术鉴定慢性伤口感染诊断的有效性
1. Sue E. Gardner PhD, RN1,2,
2. Rita A. Frantz PhD, RN2,
3. Charles L. Saltzman MD3,
4. Stephen L. Hillis PhD1,
5. Heeok Park MSN, RN2 and
6. Melody Scherubel BSN4
ABSTRACT
This study examined the diagnostic validity of three different swab techniques in identifying chronic wound infection. Concurrent swab specimens of chronic wounds were obtained using wound exudate, the Z-technique, and the Levine technique, along with a specimen of viable wound tissue. Swab and tissue specimens were cultured using quantitative and qualitative laboratory procedures. Infected wounds were defined as those containing 1 × 10 or more organisms per gram of tissue. Accuracy was determined by associating the quantitative cultures of swab specimens with the cultures from tissue specimens using receiver operating characteristic curves. Of the 83 study wounds, 30 (36%) were infected. Accuracy was the highest for swab specimens obtained using Levine's technique at 0.80. Based on Levine's technique, a critical threshold of 37,000 organisms per swab provided a sensitivity of 90% and a specificity of 57%. The mean concordance between swab specimens obtained using Levine's technique and tissue specimens was 78%. The findings suggest that swab specimens collected using Levine's technique provide a reasonably accurate measure of wound bioburden, given that they are more widely applicable than tissue cultures. The diagnostic validity of Levine's technique needs further study using an alternative reference standard, such as the development of infection-related complications.
这项研究考察了三种不同的拭子技术诊断识别慢性伤口感染的有效性。慢性伤口同时用伤口渗液,Z技术和Levine技术获得拭子样品,并同时进行伤口组织活检的取样。拭子和组织标本,采用定量及定性的实验室程序培养。伤口感染被定义为那些含有每克组织的1×10个或更多个微生物。精度是通过利用受试者工作特征曲线的组织标本中培养相关联66
热门文档