doc.guandang.net The UN in Haiti Damned if you do
Nov 10th 2011, 18:09 by P.B. | NEW YORK
THERE are few chinks in the legal armour of Minustah, the UN peacekeeping force in Haiti. Its Status of Forces Agreement grants troops immunity from civil and criminal courts. Although the deal provides for an outside commission to hear Haitians’ complaints and demands for redress, such a body has never been set up. The
internal claims office at its base in Port-au-Prince dwells in obscurity. For the most part, Minustah is subject only to the regulation of its own good intentions.
This week marked the first serious challenge to Minustah’s immunity. On November 8th the Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti (IJDH), a Boston-based
advocacy group, submitted 5,000 claims to the organisation for damages totalling at least $250m on behalf of Haitian cholera victims, on the grounds that Minustah imported the disease into the country. The UN’s response to the petition could affect peacekeeping missions around the world, which generally enjoy immunity from legal action.
Since arriving in Haiti in October 2010, cholera has sickened nearly 500,000 people and killed more than 6,600, according to local health officials. The death rate has tapered off, but the disease remains a lethal threat because of Haitians’ poor access to clean water, sanitation and health care.
When the disease first appeared on Haitian soil, the UN denied any link. Three
months later Ban Ki-moon, the UN’s secretary-general, appointed a panel of experts to investigate. In May the commission officially determined that the outbreak was “not the fault of, or deliberate action of, a group or individual.” The experts “found that it was not possible to determine conclusively how cholera was introduced,” said Kieran Dwyer, a spokesperson for the UN’s peacekeeping operations. “On the scientific evidence, we don’t know if it was the UN troops or not.”
A close read of the panel’s , however, suggests otherwise. The experts pinpointed the origin of the outbreak to the Meille River, a tributary of the region’s main water source, near a peacekeeping base where sanitation conditions “were not sufficient to prevent faecal contamination” of the river. They noted that the battalion was deployed from Nepal shortly after endemic cholera had flared up in the Kathmandu Valley, and that asymptomatic soldiers, who can still carry cholera, were not tested. They cited epidemiological studies showing genetic similarities between Haiti’s strain of cholera and the South Asian strain endemic in Nepal. And they dismissed every other alternate theory on the origins of cholera in Haiti. Despite the report’s cautious conclusions, the evidence it contains is so persuasive that the IJDH’s lawyers relied on it almost exclusively to make their case. “Though [the authors] don't go as far as saying Minustah is responsible, it’s really difficult logically to see what other options are available,” says Beatrice Lindstrom, a lawyer for an
商学精要作业 10页 2下载券 商学精要-chapter 1 43页 1下载券 商槪(商学精要)期末重点... 16页 7下载券 商学精要期中资料 暂无评价 35页 2下载券 Chapter...
publishing as Prentice Hall PowerPoint Presentation prepared by Carol Vollmer Pope Alverno College LEARNING OBJECTIVES After reading this chapter, you should be...
商学精要期中资料_理化生_初中教育_教育专区。6 chapter Organizing the Business Business Essentials, 8th Edition Ebert/Griffin Instructor Lectu...
商学精要作业 隐藏>> Beauty美丽公司 部门经理:xxx 什么是服务?服务是一种概念 服务是一种行为 服务是一种态度 部门职责: 1.负责部门扎实有效地开展基础管理...
2 chapter Business Ethics and Social Responsibility Business Essentials, 8th Edition Ebert/Griffin Instructor Lecture PowerPoints Copyright ? 2011 Pearson ...
商学精要-chapter 1_经济学_高等教育_教育专区。商学精要英文版第八版,作者是罗纳德·埃伯特Chapter 1 The Business Environment ? 1. The external environments ...
11044117 胡凡 商学精要期末作业 隐藏>> China Resources Enterprise, Limited 1 / 15 BRAVING CHALLENGES China Resources Enterprise, Limited 11044117 Hu Fan ...
商学精要_管理学_高等教育_教育专区。全面分析商学精要Human Resource Management And Labor Relation 工商管理类 128 班 曲冲冲 1206010823 一.人力资源管理的意义...
商学精要_管理学_高等教育_教育专区 暂无评价0人阅读0次下载举报文档 商学精要_管理学_高等教育_教育专区。Catching up is so very hard to do (The world...
热门文档