Several, possibly associated, dimensions of smoking behavior may be distinguished, e.g., smoking initiation, number of cigarettes smoked per day and nicotine dependence (Mayhew et al., 2000) and each
398
itisimportanttoinvestigatewhethersmokinginiti-ationandnicotinedependencearepartofthesamecontinuumorwhethertheyrepresenttwoindepen-dentdimensions.
Asfarastheauthorsknow,onlyonestudyhasaddressedtheheritabilityofnicotinedependenceusingtheFagerstromscoreinatwo-stagemodel(Kendleretal.,1999;thisstudywasalsoincludedinthemeta-analysesdescribedabove).Kendleretal.(1999)investigatedtherelationshipbetweensmokinginitiationandnicotinedependencebyusingamodelthatestimatesapathbetweentheliabilitytosmokinginitiationandtheliabilitytonicotinedependence,givensmokinginitiation.Whilethemajorityofge-neticriskfactorsfornicotinedependenceweresharedwithsmokinginitiation,adistinctsetoffamilialfactorssolelyin uencedtheriskfornicotinedepen-dence.Geneticfactorscontributedtoatotalof72%ofthevarianceinliabilitytonicotinedependenceandtheremainingvariancewasexplainedbyuniqueenvironmentalfactors.Thisstudywasperformedinwomenonly,andalthoughthesexdi erencesinthegeneticarchitectureofsmokingseemsmall(Maddenetal.,1999;Vinketal.,2003),itisunknowniftheresultsgeneralizetomen.
Instudiesoftheheritabilityofsmokinginitia-tionandquantitysmokedinadolescenttwinsoftheNetherlandsTwinRegister,acomparablebutdif-ferentapproachtoanalyzethesekindsofdatawasused(Koopmansetal.,1999;Vinketal.,2004a).Threedi erentmodelsfortherelationshipbetweenthegeneticandenvironmentalcausesofinitiationandquantitywereevaluated.Thesingleliabilitymodelassumesthatthesamegeneticandenviron-mentalriskfactorsin uenceinitiationandquantity,whiletheindependentliabilitymodelassumesinde-pendentinitiationandquantitydimensionseachdeterminedbyseparategeneticandenvironmentalriskfactors.Thecombinedmodelincludesassump-tionsofbothsingleandindependentliabilitymodels.Itpostulatesseparateinitiationandquantitydimen-sions,buttherearetworoutestobeinganon-smo-ker:anindividualcanbeanon-smokerduetogeneticand/orenvironmentalfactorsthatin uencesmokinginitiationorbecausetheindividualislowonnicotinedependence.Forsmokinginitiationandquantitysmoked,thecombinedmodelwasthebest ttingmodel.Koopmansetal.,(1999)reportedthat39%ofthetotalvarianceinsmokinginitiationwasexplainedbygeneticin uencesand86%ofthetotalvarianceinquantity(numberofcigarettesperday)wasexplainedbygeneticfactors.
Vink,Willemsen,andBoomsma
Inthepresentpaper,thethreedifferentmodelsdescribedbyKoopmansetal.,(1999)areappliedtodataonsmokinginitiationandnicotinedependenceasassessedbytheFagerstromtestfornicotinedependence(FTND)inaDutchtwinsampleaged30.5years(SD=11.9).Afteridenti cationofthecorrectliabilitymodel,therelativecontributionofgeneticandenvironmentalfactorstoinitiationandnicotinedependenceisestimated.
METHODSMeasures
Thisstudyispartofanongoingtwin/familystudyonhealth-relatedbehavioroftheNetherlandsTwinRegister(NTR)thatassessesfamilieswithadolescentandyoungadulttwinseverytwotothreeyearssince1991(Boomsmaetal.,2002).Smokinginitiation
Dataonsmokingbehaviorwerecollectedlon-gitudinally(1991,1993,1995,1997,2000)and61%ofthetwinsparticipatedmorethanonce.Subjectswereclassi edasnon-smokerswhentheyreportedtheyneversmokedorwhentheytriedsmokingafewtimes.Theanswerstoallsurveysweretakenintoaccountsothatanindividualwhoreportedtohavesmokedregularlyinoneofthesurveys,wasclassi edaseversmoker.Ifanswersofdifferentsurveyswerecontradictory,thevariablewassettomissing.Thegroupofnon-smokersincludestheneversmokersandtheindividualswhotriedsmok-ingafewtimesbutneverreportedregularsmoking.Inthe2000survey,onlythesubjectswhoclassi edthemselvesassmokersandex-smokersproceededtocompletetheFTND.Subjectswhoclassi edthem-selvesasnon-smokers(includingsubjectswhore-portedtheytriedsmokingafewtimes)didnot llouttheFTND.
Weexaminedthelongitudinaldataofsubjectswhoreportedtheytriedsmokingafewtimesinoneofthesurveys(n=3317subjects).For2023ofthe3317subjects,datawereavailableforthenextsurvey;23%reportedtobeasmokertwoyearslaterandwerethereforeclassi edassmokers.Therestofthesubjectsreportedagaintohavetriedsmokingafewtimes(41%)orreportedtobenon-smokers(31%)2yearslater;bothgroupswereclassi edasnon-smokers.
doi10.1017S0033291705005374 Printed in the United Kingdom Heritability of ... regular exercise, alcohol consumption and smoking behaviour (Boomsma et al....
doi10.1017S0033291705005374 Printed in the United Kingdom Heritability of ... regular exercise, alcohol consumption and smoking behaviour (Boomsma et al....
热门文档