257
Reliabilityofdemographic,smokingandoccupationaldataprovidedbymothersvs.fathersinachildhoodcancerstudy
RobertaMcKean-Cowdina,SusanPreston-Martina,JaniceM.Pogodab,BethA.MuellercandElizabethA.Hollyd
a
DepartmentofPreventiveMedicine,UniversityofSouthern,California,NorrisComprehensiveCancerCenter,LosAngeles,CA,bStatology,Truckee,
CA,cFredHutchinsonCancerResearchCenter,Seattle,WA,andDepartmentofEpidemiology,UniversityofWashington,Seattle,WA,dDepartmentofEpidemiologyandBiostatistics,UniversityofCalifornia,SanFrancisco,CA,USA
Summary
Correspondence:
RobertaMcKean-Cowdin,DepartmentofPreventiveMedicine,UniversityofSouthernCalifornia,NorrisComprehensiveCancer
Center,1441EastlakeAve.,POBox33800,MS44,Los
Angeles,CA90033-0800,USA.E-mail:mckeanco@hsc.usc.edu
Alargecase±controlstudyofchildrenwasusedtotestmothers'reportingofinformationonfathers'background,lifestyleandoccupationalfactors.Forasubset(104)of1341enrolledfamilies,bothparentswereinterviewedaboutfathers'characteristics.Reliabilityofreportingwasdeterminedforfathers'race,education,smokingstatus,non-recentjobhistoryanduseofoccupationalagents.Theabilityofmotherstoreportfathers'race,educationandsmokingstatuswashigh(kappa40.70).Mothersweregenerallyabletoreportjobsheldbythefathersinthe5yearsprecedingthebirthofthechild,butreliabilitywashigherforjobsheldforlonger(kappatypicallyabove0.70),ratherthanshorterperiods(kappaabove0.40).Thefindingthatmothers'reportingonfathers'background,lifestyleandnon-recentjobhistorywasreliableisencouraging,becausemanystudiesonchildhoodhealthrelyexclusivelyoninformationfrominterviewswithmothers.However,motherswerenotreliablyabletodescribeexposuretospecificoccupationalagents.
Introduction
Exposurehistoriesoffamiliesinretrospectivestudiesareoftenobtainedthroughinterview.Instudiesofpaediatricdisease,exposurehistoriesofbothbiologi-calparentsmaybeofimportance,butarenotnecessarilyavailablethroughrecordsorpersonalinterviewswitheachparent.Inthissituation,mothers'responsesmaybetheonlyavailablesourceofinformation.Previousstudieshaveshownthatproxies(typicallyaspouse/partnerorotherrelative)canreliablyreportdemographicdata1±3andsmokingstatus,1±6butthereliabilityofoccupationalhistoriesobtainedthroughproxyhasbeenlessconsistent.1±10Whileseveralreportsindicatethatrespondentscandescribethemostrecentorcurrentjobofaspouse/partnerwithgoodtoexcellentagreement,1,2,5othersshowthattheydonotaccuratelyreportlifetimeemploymenthistories,3,4nordotheyaccuratelyreportoccupationalexposurestospecificagents,suchas
solvents,arsenicandasbestos.3,8±10Whetheraspouse/partnercanreliablyreportnon-recentjobhistoriesremainsunclear.Thisstudyinvestigatesthereliabilityofmothers'reportingoffathers'demographicdetails,smokingstatus,jobhistoryandexposuretooccupa-tionalagentsinastudyofchildhoodcancer.
Usingdatafromacase±controlstudyofchildhoodbraintumours,weexaminedtheabilityofbiologicalmotherstodescribetherace,educationandsmokingstatusofthechild'sbiologicalfather.Wealsoexaminedthemother'sabilitytoreportjobsheldbythefatherduringthe5yearsprecedingthebirthofthechildenrolledinthestudyandherabilitytoreportonhisexposuretoninegeneraltypesofoccupationalagents.Weexaminedhowreliabilityofproxyjobhistoryvariedbycharacteristicsofthemother±fatherpairandbylevelofdetailaboutjobhistory.Wealsolookedforevidenceofreportingbiasamongcasesandcontrols.
#BlackwellScienceLtd.PaediatricandPerinatalEpidemiology2000,14,257±262
occupational groups with a relatively small sample ...Data on demographic characteristics, medical history... vital information was provided by family members ...
??&?Reliability? ? Cost?? ??Effectiveness? ? ...and Occupational Group Average Monthly Resignation ...“Singapore Demographic Bulletin” produced by RBD....
Relationships of demographic factors, job risk ... the estimated fatalities and occupational injuries ...Reliability measures for individual factors range ...
occupational groups with a relatively small sample ...Data on demographic characteristics, medical history... vital information was provided by family members ...
Return to Work After Occupational Injury Yonghua ...Information including demographic characteristics (e.... and medical history provided by the Division of...
demographic factors, reproductive and medical history... occupational and residential history, physical ... passive smoking and preterm birth provided con?...
randomly from general and occupational populations. ...data were obtained on demographic and other ...Reliability of BP and vegetable intakes (mean of...
environmental exposure levels, demographic ... such as smoking, occupational exposures, and ...We tested the reliability of the automatic coding...
occupational groups with a relatively small sample ...Data on demographic characteristics, medical history... vital information was provided by family members ...
reliability and validity (Wang et al. 2001; Xu et al. 2008; Yang et ...Conclusions Our ?ndings revealed that occupational roles, demographic ...
热门文档