错误记忆
Memory& Cognition 1999,27 (6),937-947
Can Bartlett's repeated reproduction experiments be replicated? ERIK T. BERGMAN and HENRY L. ROEDIGER III Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri Surprisingly, Bartlett's (1932) famous repeated reproduction experiments, in which he found systematically increasing errors in recall from the same people tested over time, have never been successfully replicated. Several studies have attempted partial replications, which were unsuccessful, and their authors concluded that the original observations might not be replicable. We conducted a study modeled closely after Bartlett's procedures: Subjects studied"The War of the Ghosts," took an initial test 15 min later, and then took a delayed test after 1 week. A follow-up test was conducted 6 months later on as many subjects as could be obtained. We did replicate Bartlett's results, in that (1) subjects forgot the story over delays but (2) introduced rationalization and distortion into their accounts of the story, with increases in the proportion of material distorted as retention interval increased. Subjects also imported new propositions at long delays, further confirming Bartlett's empirical observations and conclusions. Bartlett's repeated reproduction results can be replicated. Bartlett (1932) published Remembering: A study in Experimental and Social Psychology, a book that has deservedly received its place among the classic works in all of psychology (Roediger, 1997; Thompson, 1997). The book reported research dating from 1913 on perceiving, remembering, thinking, and social and cultural influences on these processes. The book is famous for Bartlett's theoretical ideas on the constructive nature of remembering and the notion that schemata (organized mental structures) were critical to the comprehension, assimilation, and remembering of information. Bartlett (1932) used several different techniques to study the phenomena in which he was interested. With regard to memory, the two best known methods were the serial reproduction technique and the repeated reproduction technique. In serial reproduction, a subject is exposed to some material, such as a story, and then tries to recall it. A second subject reads the first subject's account of the original event and tries to recall that. The third subject reads the second subject's account, and so on. (The technique is like that in the party game of rumor or telephone.) Serial reproduction can often lead to dramatic distortions in recall over repeated reconstructions of the event (see Bartlett, 1932, pp. 118-153, for examples). Although rarely used now, this experimental technique was used in later studies with results generally confirming those of Bartlett (e.g., Paul, 1959). Psychologists interested in transmission of rumors used the technique, among others (e.g., Allport& Postman, 1947). The other primary technique that Bartlett (1932) used to study remembering is repeated reproduction. In the most famous use of t
his method, Bartlett read his subjects the native American folktale,"The War of the Ghosts." After hearing the story read twice, subjects were given a 15-min delay and then tried to recall the story. After this first recall, subjects were tested again at some later point in time, and often they were tested on more than one occasion."The War of the Ghosts" is an unusual story for the English college students who seem to have been Bartlett's subjects (although this detail is unclear). The story is rather disjointed and contains supernatural elements. Bartlett was interested in how his subjects would alter the story when remembering it across repeated occasions. One of his primary findings was what he called rationalization, by which he meant that"whenever anything appeared incomprehensible ... it was either omitted or explained" by the addition of material (Bartlett, 1932, p. 68). Rationalization occurred"in practically every reproduction or series of reproductions" (Bartlett, 1932, p. 71). In addition, intrusions would occur in recall, when subjects remembered events that were not in the story (sometimes in the process of rationalization). The distortions in recall of the story tended to grow over repeated reproductions, as in the case of the serial reproduction results. However, the distortions tended to be somewhat less dramatic in repeated reproduction than in serial reproduction. The basic idea that Bartlett proposed was that remembering was a constructive (or reconstructive) process, one rife with error. People remember the schema or gist of an event but forget the details; later, when they recall the event, they may get the gist correct but create details (and even
This research was supported by N[H Grant MH[[56-02 to the first author. The authors thank Kate Pfeifer for her help in conducting and scoring this research and Walter Kintsch, Ulric Neisser, and David Rubin for helpful comments. These data were first reported at the 38th Annua[ Meeting of the Psychonomic Society, Philadelphia, November 1997. Correspondence should be addressed to H. L. Roediger III, Department of Psychology, Box 1125, Washington University, One Brookings Drive, St. Louis, MO 63130-4899 (e-mail: roediger@artsci. wustl.edu).
937
Copyright 1999 Psychonomic Society, Inc.

Understanding Repeated-Measures ANOVA_教育学/心理学_人文社科_专业资料。重复...However, we can make an appropriate correction by changing the degrees of ...
毕业设计 外文翻译 CAN总... 10页 1下载券 IEEE期刊论文翻译 16页 7下载...Bartlett 和 Downs 提出了一个基于梯度下降途径的概率分布,这个途径假设单元的...
Eating_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。Children's Eating Raising children can be...Children need repeated experiences with new food before they learn to like ...
We ensure the finiteness of the repeated-game payoffs by introducing discounting of future payoffs relative to earlier payoffs. Such discounting can be an ...
多个方差的齐性检验可用 Bartlett 法,它 用卡方值...如果几个因变 量之间彼此不独立,应该用 Repeated ...本例选择“LSD”和“Duncan”比较,检验的显著性...
Real life is a bigger game in which what a player does early on can affect what others choose to do later on. Repeated games can incorporate ...
repeated , the better the worker will retain it...Bartlett (1932) pioneered what became the ... then how can we as a society communicate and/...
em rule can be used to replace the authors’ name(s) that are repeated... M & Groenwald, SL 2000, Cancer nursing, 5th edn, Jones and Bartlett, ...
Randomized Complete Block and Repeated Measures (Each_其它考试_资格考试/认证...Can have more than one replicate per block, but prefer to have equal ...
repeated , the better the worker will retain it...Bartlett (1932) pioneered what became the ... then how can we as a society communicate and/...
热门文档