The puzzle of the persistent question marks (a phrase coined by Harvey in 1993) refers to the occurrence of residual learnable alleles in simulations of the Baldwin effect, which concerns interactions between learning and evolution. Explanations of the puz
Probing the Persistent Question Marks
Janet Wiles Ruth Schulz School of CS&EE and School of CS&EE School of Psychology The Univ of Queensland The Univ of Queensland Brisbane, QLD 4072 Brisbane QLD 4072
Abstract
The puzzle of the persistent question marks (a phrase coined by Harvey in 1993) refers to the occurrence of residual learnable alleles in simulations of the Baldwin effect, which concerns interactions between learning and evolution. Explanations of the puzzle have focused on the role of fitness proportional selection pressures and of drift. We replicated the original 1987 model by Hinton and Nolan, extending the number of generations simulated until populations converged on stable genotypes, thus quantifying the number of residual question marks and the time to homogeneity (only one allele remaining in the population for each gene in a chromosome). Previous explanations of the residual question marks imply that algorithms that maintain strong selection pressure should not result in residual question marks. We tested this implication by simulating Hinton and Nolan’s Baldwin model replacing frequency proportional selection by tournament selection. Fewer residual question marks remained, but they were still present in many populations. We analyzed the relative factors that contribute to these effects in both fitness proportional and tournament selection runs. We conclude that homogeneous question marks are a significant factor in populations exhibiting the Baldwin effect in all the types of selection strategies tested in this study.
1 INTRODUCTION
Learning is ubiquitous in nature. It may be argued that the ability to learn is the single most valuable trait in Homo sapiens, but even single-celled microbes learn to follow chemical gradients. The nature of the interaction between
Jennifer Hallinan Scott Bolland Institute for Molecular
Bradley Tonkes Biosciences
School of CS&EE The Univ of Queensland The Univ of Queensland Brisbane QLD 4072 Brisbane QLD 4072
evolution and learning has been a subject of research and debate for decades. The suggestion that learning by individuals may guide the evolution of a population was proposed by Baldwin towards the end of the nineteenth century (Baldwin, 1896), and has been dubbed the “Baldwin Effect”.
1.1 THE BALDWIN EFFECT
The assumption underlying the Baldwin effect is that behaviour may be either innate (genetically determined) or learned. Innate behaviour has the advantages of being available to the individual throughout its life, and being quick to carry out, requiring no decision-making on the part of the individual. Innate behaviour is, however, inflexible; if a novel situation arises it may not be dealt with appropriately. Learned behaviour is exactly the opposite: slower to acquire and apply, but flexible. Baldwin suggested that some individuals may contain genes which predispose them to learn a particular behaviour. If this behaviour is advantageous to the individuals, they will produce a higher than average number of offspring, and the advantageous genes will spread through the population. Further mutations to these genes are then possible, making the behavior more innate and hence easier to learn. Eventually a behavior that was learned may become encoded into the genome as an instinct. Learning on the part of individual organisms has then shaped the evolution of the entire population. 1.2 MODELLING THE BALDWIN EFFECT Baldwin’s hypothesis, like those of Darwin, Lamarck and other evolutionary theorists was not testable with the science of the nineteenth century. It remained an intriguing possibility until the advent of sufficiently powerful computers and evolutionary computation algorithms made empirical investigations into evolution-ary processes a real possibility, almost a century later. The most widely studied model of the Baldwin Effect was developed by Hinton and Nowlan (1987). In this model, each individual consists of a simple neural network with twenty connections, which must be set correctly via either
Concurrent Probing –Pros: Question is very fresh on the mind –Cons: Potential bias; switching of tasks can be distracting. Early probes can affect ...
Choose the best answer below. A:c Yes, because it is a general probing question that will get the customer to broadly talk about their issues Yes, ...
Lesson 68 Persistent 纠缠不休_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。新概念英语2 ...Lesson 68 Persistent 纠缠不休 First listen and then answer the question. ...
Probing clumpy stellar winds with a neutron star Clumping in Hot Star ...sources for what concerns their persistent or transient nature. In the frame...
c sources for what concerns their persistent or transient nature. In the ...& Zurita, J.; Probing Clumpy Stellar Wind in SFXTs 2. Hard X-ray ...
2005 195 COMPLETE NUCLEOTIDE SEQUENCE AND MOLECULAR PROBING OF POTATO VIRUS ...non-persistent manner to plant species of the Solanaceae and Chenopodiaceae ...
1:Have you read a newspaper report probing ___ the activities of drug ...1.grate 2.grateful 3.great 4.graceful 5:The question then ___ what are...
c sources for what concerns their persistent or transient nature. In the ...& Zurita, J.; Probing Clumpy Stellar Wind in SFXTs 2. Hard X-ray ...
but was keen on probing into the definition of some ethical and ... which supports its unsubmissive and persistent advance by putting up its ...
[B]probing into [B]tangled [B]transcends [B]...Her main tool is a 74-question diagnostic method...persistent weakness of those paid to predict the ...
热门文档