文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 经管营销 > 经济/市场 > Linda T. M. Bui
侵权投诉

Linda T. M. Bui

REGULATIONANDCAPITALIZATIONOFENVIRONMENTALAMENITIES:

EVIDENCEFROMTHETOXICRELEASEINVENTORY

INMASSACHUSETTS

LindaT.M.BuiandChristopherJ.Mayer*

Abstract—EnvironmentalregulationintheUnitedStateshasundergoneaslowevolutionfromcommandandcontrolstrategiestowardsmarket-basedregulations.OnesuchinnovationistheToxicsReleaseInventory(TRI),aregulationthatrequirespolluting rmstopubliclydiscloseinformationabouttheirtoxicemissions.Thebasictenetofthisregulationisthatitcorrectsforinformationalasymmetriesbetweenpollutersandhouseholds,allowingcommunitiestopressurepolluterstodecreasetheiremissions.Policy-makershavejudgedtheTRIatremendoussuccess,asnationalreleasesdeclinedby43%between1988and1999.YetmanyofthefundamentalproblemswhichareknowntoleadtotheclassicfailureoftheCoasetheorem(suchashightransactioncostsanddif cultiesinorganizing)castdoubtontheeffectivenessofdisclosurerules,alone,toleadtoanef cientoutcomeinthecaseofpollution.Weuseaneventstudymethodologywithhigh-qualitydataonhousepricesandotherlocalattributestoassesstheextenttowhichthepublicvalueschangesintoxicreleasesandthusthesuccessofTRI.Ourmajor ndingsinclude:(1)declinesintoxicreleasesappearunrelatedtoanypoliticaleconomyvariablesthatmightleadtopublicactivism;(2)initialinformationreleasedunderTRIhadnosigni canteffectonthedistributionofhouseprices;and(3)housepricesshownosigni cantimpactofdeclinesinreportedtoxicreleasesovertime.Standarderrorsaresmallenoughthatwecanrejectthehypothesisthatlargedeclinesintoxicreleasesleadtomorethana0.5%increaseinhouseprices.TheseresultsalsoholdwhenwecontrolfordifferencesintheavailabilityofinformationonTRIandthepossibleeffectofexpectations.Our ndingscastdoubtontheabilityofthepublictoprocesscomplexinformationonhazardousemissionsandsupporttheCoasetheoreminthatright-to-knowlawssuchasTRImaynotbethemosteffectiveformofenvironmentalregulation.

I.Introduction

E

NVIRONMENTALregulationintheUnitedStateshasundergoneaslowevolutionfromcommandandcontrolstrategiestomoremarket-basedapproaches.Inpart,thistransitionisinresponsetotheoverwhelminggrowthinthedirectcostofregulationandthepriceofmeetingthoseregulations.IntheUnitedStates,pollutionabatementcon-trolexpendituresareontheorderof1.5%–2.5%ofGDPperyear.Asthetrendtowardsstricter,morepervasiveenviron-mentalregulationcontinues,boththecostandtheeffective-nessofregulationhavebecomehottopicsonthepublicagenda.

Onesuchmarket-basedinnovationadoptedbytheU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency(EPA)istorequirepol-luting rmstopubliclydiscloseprivateinformationabouttheiremissions.Thebasictenetofthisregulationisthatit

ReceivedforpublicationOctober27,2000.RevisionacceptedforpublicationDecember4,2002.

*BostonUniversityandTheWhartonSchool,UniversityofPennsyl-vania,respectively.

TheauthorswishtothankseminarparticipantsattheWEAmeetings,theJFKSchool,ColumbiaUniversity,BostonUniversity,UniversityofTo-ronto,andTheWhartonSchool,alongwithKatherineCarmen,LisaGeorge,WayneGray,JoeGyourko,CharlieHimmelberg,BobInman,JoelWaldfogel,MartyWeitzman,andtwoanonymousreferees,forhelpfulcomments.Anyerrorsareourown.

correctsforinformationalasymmetriesthatmayexist.1OneofthemostpervasiveexamplesofthisistheEmergencyPlanning,CommunityRighttoKnowAct(EPCRA).Theappealofthistypeofregulationisevidencedbytheprolif-erationofcommunityright-to-knowlawsatthestatelevel.Theselawstakevariousforms—fromrequiringstateagen-ciestoprovideenvironmentaldatathroughtheInternet,toincreasingthereportingrequirementsforpollutingplants.Usingdisclosureofprivateinformationasaninformalregulatorytoolisattractivebecauseitisrelativelylow-cost.Theoretically,boththecash-starvedregulatoryagencyandtheregulatedplantcouldfacelowerpollutionabatementcontrolexpenditures.Insteadofdirectlyregulatingplantsandensuringcompliance,theenforcementagencyonlywouldberesponsibleforcollectingandmaintainingapub-licdatabase,increasingcommunityawareness,andpenal-izing rmsforinaccuratereporting.Apolluting rmwouldbefreetochoosehowmuchtochangeitsemissionsandtousewhateverabatementtechnologyitwanted.Communitypolicingwouldpressure rmstoreduceactualemissions.Inthispaper,wefocusononeexampleofthistypeofregulation,calledtheToxicsReleaseInventory(TRI).In-troducedbytheEPAundertheEPCRAin1986,TRIrequiresmanufacturingplantsthatemitmorethanagiventhresholdlevelofanylistedtoxicsubstancetoprovideemissionsdatatotheEPAforuseinapubliclyavailabledatabase.PriortotheTRI,norecordoftoxicemissionsexisted.

Between1988and1999,TRIreportedemissionsfellbyapproximately40%.Supportforcommunityright-to-knowlegislationandtheTRIisverystrong.InapresidentialmemodatedAugust8,1995,theadministrationwrotethattheEPCRAof1986“...providesaninnovativeapproachtoprotectingpublichealthandtheenvironmentbyensuringthatcommunitiesareinformedaboutthetoxicchemicalsbeingreleased...”andthat“...Right-to-Knowprotectionsprovideabasicinformationaltooltoencourageinformedcommunity-basedenvironmentaldecisionmakingandpro-videastrongincentiveforbusinessesto ndtheirownwaysofpreventingpollution.”TheapparentsuccessoftheTRIinreducingreportedtoxicemissionshasmadetheTRIand

Thedisclosureofprivateinformationhasbeenusedasaregulatorymechanisminseveralinstances.Oneexampleistherequiredlabelingofnutritionalcontentsonfoodpackages,andanotheristheOccupationalSafetyandHealthAct,whichrequiresemployerstoinformemployeesaboutworkplacehazards.Theeffectivenessofsuchregulation,toourknowledge,hasnotbeenveri edempirically.

1

TheReviewofEconomicsandStatistics,August2003,85(3):693–708

©2003bythePresidentandFellowsofHarvardCollegeandtheMassachusettsInstituteofTechnology

第1页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • 新概念青少版2A Unit 1 Linda comes to London!

    comes to Londo... Unit 1 Linda comes to London! 1,Where is Karen? 2,Who is she ...

  • 青少版新概念2A-unit 1-Linda comes to London

    comes to Londo...Linda:Ah, I can see it! It’s ___ now! There it is! Linda: Oh...

  • Linda My first year in university 3

    Linda My...first yea...My first year in university Linda My course and...

  • 知名经济评论家

    现为德州 A&M 大学 经济系教授、上海财经大学经济 学院院长、长江学者讲座...Bui·Linda T. M. Caves· Richard E. Cooper· Russell W. Donald· ...

  • ...Microsoft...

    T: OK. I?m happy too. Let?s play a guessing game. Are you ready? ...教师让学生再听一遍课文录音,听听 Linda 在转接电话时 的常用语。 Is Helen in...

  • 2012-2013 ...

    I’m Cindy. Are you Gina? Is he Bob? Bob Linda Yes, he is. Is she Jenny? No, she isn’t. She’s Linda. Jim Tom Tony Bob Cindy Mary ...

  • ...unit5what...

    _the_rainstorm_...Mary: What ___ were you doing last night, Linda? I called at seven...

  • 2012-2013 ...

    ___ name is Linda. isn’t Her 5、根据图示完成对话 1. A: Hello. What’s ___ your name? B: My ___ Jenny. name’s A: I’m Tony. ___ ...

  • 2012-2013 ...

    name’s Are A: ___, I’m not. ___ Bob. No I’m B: Hi, ___...___ name is Linda. isn’t Her Game 3c 分小组练习介绍自己和他人,你能...

  • ...It must b...

    might 4. The hair band ___ belong to Linda. must 5. It ___ be Linda...It ___ a can’t be must be UFO. ?M: A UFO? What’s going on?...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email