文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > Measuring and understanding user comfort with resource borrowing
侵权投诉

Measuring and understanding user comfort with resource borrowing

Resource borrowing is a common underlying approach in grid computing and thin-client computing. In both cases, external processes borrow resources that would otherwise be delivered to the interactive processes of end-users, creating contention that slows t

MeasuringandUnderstandingUserComfortWithResourceBorrowing

AshishGuptaBinLinPeterA.Dinda

{ashish,binlin,pdinda}@cs.northwestern.edu

DepartmentofComputerScience,NorthwesternUniversity

Abstract

Resourceborrowingisacommonunderlyingapproachingridcomputingandthin-clientcomputing.Inbothcases,externalprocessesborrowresourcesthatwouldotherwisebedeliveredtotheinteractiveprocessesofend-users,creat-ingcontentionthatslowstheseprocessesanddecreasesthecomfortoftheend-users.Howresourceborrowingandusercomfortarerelatedisnotwellunderstoodandthusresourceborrowingtendstobeextremelyconservative.Toaddressthislackofunderstanding,wehavedevelopedasophis-ticateddistributedapplicationfordirectlymeasuringusercomfortwiththeborrowingofCPUtime,memoryspace,anddiskbandwidth.Usingthistool,wehaveconductedacontrolleduserstudywithqualitativeandquantitativere-sultsthatareofdirectinteresttothedesignersofgridandthin-clientsystems.Wehavefoundthatresourceborrowingcanbequiteaggressivewithoutcreatinguserdiscomfort,particularlyinthecaseofmemoryanddisk.Wealsode-scribeanon-goingInternet-widestudyusingourtool.

1Introduction

Manywidelyuseddistributedcomputingplatformsandapplicationsuseavailableresourcesonexistinghostcom-puters,exploitingthefactthatmostofthesesystemsaredramaticallyunder-utilized[20,5,1],atechniquewerefertoasresourceborrowing.Examplesinscienti ccomputingincludeCondor[19,11],Entropia[3],SETI@Home[30],ProteinFoldingatHome[18],DESChall[4],andtheGoogleToolbar[12].ThemajorityofsuchsystemsandapplicationsrunonMicrosoftWindowsplatforms,andtheyaredeployedonhundredsofthousands(SETI@Home)tomillions(Google)ofhosts.Examplesinpeer-to-peercon-tentdistributionsystemsincludecommercialtoolssuch

EffortsponsoredbytheNationalScienceFoundationunderGrantsANI-0093221,ACI-0112891,ANI-0301108,EIA-0130869,andEIA-0224449.Anyopinions, ndingsandconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthoranddonotnecessarilyre ecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation(NSF).

asKazaa[28]andGnutella[22],aswellasacademicprojects[29,23,15,14].Someofthesesystemsarede-ployedonmillionsofWindowshosts.

Therehavealsobeennumerousproposalstoconsolidatedesktopcomputersandserversontoclusters[26,10]tosim-plifytheiradministrationandexploittheirdramaticunder-utilizationtomakecomputingmoreeconomical.Interactiveuserswouldthenusethinclients[27]toaccesstheirpro-cesses.Ineffect,eachuserwillseeaslowedmachineduetoresourcesborrowedforotherusers.

Inbothcases,severalfundamentalquestionsariseaboutuser’sinteractionwithresourceborrowing:

1Whatlevelofresourceborrowingleadstouserdiscomfortforasigni cantfractionofusers?

2Howdoestheleveldependonwhichresourceorcombinationofresourcesisborrowed?

3Howdoestheleveldependontheuser’scontext(theforegroundtask)?

4Howdoestheleveldependontheuser,factoringoutcontext?

5Howdoestheleveldependonthetimedynamicsofresourceborrowing?

6Howdoestheleveldependontherawpowerofthehost?

Currentsystemsassumeveryconservativeanswerstothesequestionsbecauseiftheycausetheusertofeelthatthema-chineisslowerthanisdesirable,theuserislikelytodis-ablethem.Forexample,thedefaultbehaviorinCondor,Sprite[7]andSETI@Homeistoexecuteonlywhentheyarequitesuretheuserisaway,whenthescreensaverhasbeenactivated.Othersystemsrunataverylowpriority,ortheysimplyasktheusertospecifyconstraintsonresourceborrowing,somethingthatfewordinaryusersunderstand.Iflessconservativeresourceborrowingdoesnotleadtosigni cantlyincreaseduserdiscomfort,theperformanceofcurrentsystemscouldbeincreasedthroughtechniquessuchaslinger-longerscheduling[24].

Thereisindirectevidencethatresourceborrowingneednotbeespeciallyconservativeinthatmanyusersarewill-ingtoinstallpeer-to-peertools,andrunservicessuchasMicrosoft’sIISandKazaa,Gnutella,etc,ontheirdesktopcomputers.Certainly,theextremelylowutilizationofavail-ableCPUcycles,whichhasheldtrueforover10years,sug-

第1页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • Refereed Publications

    Dinda, Measuring And Understanding User Comfort With Resource Borrowing, In Proceedings of the 13th IEEE International Symposium on High Performance Distributed...

  • UNDERSTANDING THEVALUE OF ACCOUNTING

    UNDERSTANDING THEVALUE OF ACCOUNTINGUNDERSTANDING ... new partners) Firms with external borrowing ...measuring performance, resources are misallocated and...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email