Human Resource Management
26AcademyofManagementPerspectivesAugust
DecencyMeansMorethan“AlwaysLowPrices”:AComparisonofCostcotoWal-Mart’sSam’sClub
WayneF.Cascio*
ExecutiveOverviewWal-Mart’semphasison“Alwayslowprices.hasmadeitthelargestretailoperationinhistory.
However,thisunrelentingmissionhasalsocreatedawayofdoingbusinessthatdrawssubstantialcriticism
regardingthecompany’semploymentpractices,relationshipswithsuppliers,andthecompany’simpacton
localeconomies.Thispaperfocusesonacompanythatdeliverslowpricestoconsumers,butina
fundamentallydifferentwaythanitscompetitor,Wal-Mart.Thatcompanyiswarehouse-retailerCostco.In
thefollowingsectionswewillbeginbyprovidingsomebackgroundonthecompany,includingitshistory,
itsbusinessmodel,itsethicalprinciples,corebeliefs,andvalues.ThenwewillconsidersometypicalWall
Streetanalysts’assessmentsofthisapproach,followedbyasystematiccomparisonofthefinancial
performanceofCostcowiththatofSam’sClub,awarehouseretailerthatispartofWal-Mart.
Tobesure,Wal-Martwieldsitsawesomepower
forjustonepurpose:tobringthelowestpossi-
blepricestoitscustomers.SamWalton,affec-
tionatelyknownas“Mr.Sam”byWal-Martasso-
ciates,embodiedanumberofadmirablevalues
thatheinstilledinthecompanyhefounded:hard
work,discipline,modesty,unpretentiousness,and
frugality.Byallaccountshealsowantedhisem-
ployeestobemotivated,inspired,andhappyto
workforWal-Mart.Atthesametime,however,
hewasdriven,tireless,anddeterminedtodrivea
hardbargain(Walton,1992).Hisbrilliancelayin
hisabilitytoexecuteasingularlypowerfulidea:
Sellstuffthatpeopleneedeveryday,justalittle
cheaperthaneveryoneelse,sellitatthatlow
priceallthetime,andcustomerswillflocktoyou.
Wal-Mart’smissionisfoundasasloganprintedon
everyWal-Martbag:“Alwayslowprices.Wal-Mart’sobsessivefocusonthatsinglecore
valuecreatedwhathasbecomethelargestand
mostpowerfulcompanyinhistory.
Thecompanyespousesthosesamecorevalues
today,butironically,theirapplicationisquite
differentfromthatinthe1960s,the1970s,even
the1980s.Today,theverycharacteristicsthat
allowedWal-Marttoprosperandgrowarethesourceofunrelentingcriticism.AsFishman(2006)notes,thecompany’scorevaluesseemtohavebecomeinverted,fortheynowsometimesdrivebehaviorthatisnotonlyexploitive,butinsomecases,illegalaswell.Considerthepressureonstoremanagerstocontrollaborcosts.Asnotedinits2005annualreport(pp.45,46),Wal-Martisadefendantinnumerousclass-actionlawsuitsin-volvingemployment-relatedissuesasvariedasfailuretopayrequiredovertimetohourlyemploy-ees,challengestoexempt(fromovertime)statusbyassistantstoremanagers,andallegationsofgender-baseddiscriminationinpay,promotions,jobtransfers,training,jobassignments,andhealth-carecoverage.ThereisanotheraspectoftheWal-Marteffectthatismoretroubling,anditconcernshowWal-Martgetsthoselowprices:lowwagesforitsem-ployees,unrelentingpressureonsuppliers,prod-uctscheapinqualityaswellasprice,offshoringjobs(Fishmanthisissue).“Wal-Marthasthepowertosqueezeprofit-killingconcessionsfromsuppliers,manyofwhomarewillingtodoalmostanythingtokeeptheretailerhappy,inpartbe-causeWal-Martnowdominatesconsumermar-ketssothoroughlythattheyhaveno*WayneF.Cascio(Wayne.Cascio@cudenver.edu)isU.S.BankTermProfessorofManagementattheUniversityofColoradoatDenverandHealthSciencesCenter.
热门文档