Our comments to Thomson Reuters decision and to JCR and
SCI indexing
Przeglad Elektrotechniczny is one of the oldest and largest European journal devoted to electrical engineering – we exist since 1919 and last year we published more than 2000 scientific papers a year. Our journal was established as official representation of Association of Polish Electricians. But later we obtained more and more foreign papers mainly from other countries of our part of the Europa - Russia, Ukraine, Belorussia, Czech republic, Slovakia and Slovenia, Montenegro, Serbia and Croatia, Bulgaria, Romania or Hungary. We expanded to representation of the large part of Europa – Central and Ost Europa. Probably this importance for European scientific community was the main reason that we have been accepted to JCR database.
After acceptation to JCR in 2008 the pressure of the authors increased spectacularly. We published about 50% papers of Polish authors andt number of foreign papers increased every years. After acceptation to JCR started avalanche of papers also from Asian countries - Iran, Pakistan, Malaysia, Thailand and especially China. We received 10 -20 China papers every day (!). The reason was obvious. These countries have not sufficient representation on JCR (related to number of author and scientific potential of the country). And although we received papers with author’s notes as “we are proud to send paper to so prestigious and excellent journal” the truth was more banal – for authors from these countries Przegl d Elektrotechniczny was an only gate to publish in journal that is indexed by SCI.
Thomson Reuters dropped Przegl d Elektrotechniczny from JCR with the end of 2012. This decision arrived suddenly without any earlier warnings. It was surprise for us because our parameters slowly increased and were better than at the date of acceptation to JCR. In contrary to many other journals we never press the authors to improve the citations. Applying to our journal such very strong requirements results that our part of world again will not have any representation on JCR list – the blank page on world map will enlarge.
Moreover decision of Thomson Reuters was introduced in deeply illegible way. Although we were rejected from the list at the end of December 2012 the first official announcement was published at the end of March 2013 (!!!). Thus many authors publishing papers in January, February, March believed that they are indexed by SCI and basing on this conviction they obtained grants or other supports. Now they are requested to return these supports, often from private account. We have sent special request to T&R to include exceptionally these papers into indexing because T&R was responsible for such situation. But we have met refusal. In our opinion authors of these papers have right to demand compensation from T&R.
As official reason of dropping us was too high self-citation index, close to 77%. Neglecting fact that similar value of this index we had at the date of acceptation we would like to underline that practically it is not possible to have similar self-citation parameters as American journals (without special manipulations) because:
- We estimate that for about 90% of our authors Przeglad Elektrotechniczny was only one possibility to publish in journals from JCR. Thus these authors and their colleagues were not able to cited papers from PE in other JCR journals.
- After years of isolation for most of these authors it is often the first possibility to publish papers in international journal. They are not so fluent in English language, they have very limited number of foreign colleagues, they have limited contact with other countries due to financial limitations. To tell truth distance between our countries and USA is still very large and difficult to overcome.
2014被踢出ssci的杂志_院校资料_高等教育_教育专区。2014年被踢出ssci的杂志,帮助...JCR Title ANAT SCI EDUC ANN AGR ENV MED APPL INTELL ASIAN J CONTROL ...
(二) SCI 期刊投稿各种状态详解及实例综合(学习各种投稿状态+投稿经 历总结) ...fromRecommend (四)如何处理审稿意见(补实验、语言润色、重整数据、申辩及其他) ...
(回复意见、补实验、润色、重整数据、作图及调整、申辩及其他) (五)Reject ...http://article.dxy.cn/bbs/topic/16969597 【求助】我想撤稿,杂志是 SCI ...
(回复意见、补实验、润色、重整数据、作图及调整、申辩及其他) (五)Reject ...http://article.dxy.cn/bbs/topic/16969597 【求助】我想撤稿,杂志是 SCI ...
热门文档