Clostridium difficile has been recognized as a cause of nosocomial diarrhoea and pseudomembranous colitis. Its enteropathogenicity is associated with the production of enterotoxin A (308 kDa) and cytotoxin B (270 kDa) (Barroso
JournalofMedicalMicrobiology(2005),54,173–179DOI10.1099/jmm.0.45825-0
CoexistenceofmultiplePCR-ribotypestrainsofClostridiumdif cileinfaecalsampleslimitsepidemiologicalstudies
RenateJ.vandenBerg,1HadiA.A.Ameen,1TakahiroFurusawa,1EricC.J.Claas,1EricR.vanderVorm2andEdJ.Kuijper1
CorrespondenceEdJ.Kuijpere.j.kuijper@lumc.nl
21
DepartmentofMedicalMicrobiology,CentreforInfectiousDiseases,LeidenUniversityMedicalCentre,Leiden,TheNetherlands
DepartmentofMedicalMicrobiology,VUUniversityMedicalCentre,Amsterdam,TheNetherlands
Received16July2004Accepted21October2004
Clostridiumdif cileisanimportantcauseofantibiotic-associateddiarrhoea.Thesimultaneouspresenceofdifferentstrainsinindividualfaecalsampleshasnotyetbeenestablished,butisimportantforepidemiologicalstudies.RecurrencesofClostridiumdif cile-associateddiarrhoea(CDAD)areobservedin15–20%ofpatientsandhavebeenreportedasrelapsesorreinfectionswithanewstrain.Inaperiodof1year,28faecalsamplesfrom23patientswitha rstepisodeofCDADwerecollectedattheLeidenUniversityMedicalCentre.Inaddition,52faecalsamplesfrom23patients,fromthreedifferenthospitals,withone(n¼19),two(n¼2)orthree(n¼2)recurrenceswerestudied.PCR-ribotypingwasappliedasthestandardtypingmethodfortheisolates.Thetoxinogenicandclindamycin-resistancepro lesoftheisolateswasdeterminedbyPCR.Of23patientswitha rstepisodeofCDAD,two(8.7%)harbouredtwodifferenttypes,withnodifferencesintoxinogenicityorclindamycinresistance,withinonefaecalsample.Oneofthese23patientsshowedtwotypesinthreefaecalsamplesfromthesameepisode.Ofthe23patientswithrecurrences,six(26%)showedadifferentstraintypeisolatedinarecurrentepisode.ThenumberofcasesofmultipleC.dif cilestrainsinfaecalsamplesfrompatientswitha rstepisodeofCDADdidnotdiffersigni cantlyfromthenumberofdifferentstrainspresentinrecurrentepisodes(chi-squaretest,P<0.2).ThisobservationlimitstheapplicationoftypingmethodsforstudyingtheepidemiologyofCDAD.
INTRODUCTION
Clostridiumdif cilehasbeenrecognizedasacauseofnosocomialdiarrhoeaandpseudomembranouscolitis.ItsenteropathogenicityisassociatedwiththeproductionofenterotoxinA(308kDa)andcytotoxinB(270kDa)(Barrosoetal.,1990;Doveetal.,1990).ClinicalisolatesfrompatientswithnosocomialdiarrhoeaorpseudomembranouscolitisusuallyproducebothTcdAandTcdB,butanincreasingnumberofreportsmentionsevereinfectionsandoutbreaksduetoTcdA-negative,TcdB-positivestrains(al-Barraketal.,1999;Alfaetal.,2000;Kuijperetal.,2001).Ithasbeenreportedpreviouslythatclindamycinresistanceishighamongthesestrains,incontrasttostrainsthatareTcdA-andTcdB-positive(vandenBergetal.,2004).
PatientsoftendeveloparecurrentC.dif cileinfection(15–20%)afterdiscontinuationofantibiotictherapy(Wilcox&Spencer,1992).RecurrencescanbeexplainedbyendogenouspersistenceofC.dif cilespores(relapse)orbytheacquisitionofanewstrainfromanexogenoussource(reinfection).DeterminingifarecurrenceisduetoarelapseorareinfectionisimportantforepidemiologicalstudiesofC.dif cile.Therearecon ictingdatafromstudiesintothesimultaneouspresenceofdifferentstrainsinindividualfaecalsamplesusingmoleculartypingmethodsandimmunochemicalassays(Wilcoxetal.,1998;O’Neilletal.,1991;Devlinetal.,1987;Borriello&Honour,1983;Sharp&Poxton,1985).PCR-ribotypinghasbeendescribedasarobustmethodforthegenotypingofC.dif cilestrains,althoughrestrictionenzymeanalysis(REA)isalsofrequentlyapplied.REAisabletosubgroupPCR-ribotypes(Johnsonetal.,2003),butisadif cultmethodtointerpretandlacksobjectiveinterpreta-tion(Cohenetal.,2001).Stubbsetal.(1999)appliedthePCR-ribotypingmethodto2030strainsanddifferentiated116genotypes.Allknownserogroupscouldbedifferentiated
173
ThispaperwaspresentedattheFirstInternationalClostridiumdif cileSymposium,KranjskaGora,Slovenia,5–7May2004.
Abbreviations:CDAD,Clostridiumdif cile-associateddiarrhoea;REA,restrictionenzymeanalysis.
45825&2005SGMPrintedinGreatBritain
热门文档