AnEgalitarianRegimeBreedsGenerosity:TheE¤ectofEndowmentAllocationProceduresonSocialPreferences
YohanesE.Riyantoy
January2010
JianlinZhangz
Abstract
Weexperimentallyinvestigatethee¤ectofendowmentallocationproceduresonsocialpreferencesusingatwo-stagedictatorgame.Inthe…rststage,participantswhowererandomlyselectedasallocatorshadtoperformataskinordertoearnmoney.Betterperformanceonthetaskresultedinhigherearnings.Inourbaselinemerito-cratictreatment,theallocators’initialendowmentwassetequaltotheirindividualearnings.Wecomparedthiswithanegalitariantreatmentwherebytheallocators’initialendowmentwassetequaltotheaverageearningsofallallocators.Essentially,highperformersweretaxedandunderperformersweresubsidizedbythehighper-formers.Inthesecondstage,theallocatorshadtodividetheirendowmentwiththerecipients.Weshowthattheallocatorsweremoregenerousintheegalitariantreat-mentthaninthemeritocratictreatment.Interestingly,beingtaxeddidnotreducethehighperformers’generositybutbeingsubsidizeddidsigni…cantlyincreasetheun-derperformers’generosity.Thus,beingtreatedkindlyinducedtheunderperformerstoreciprocateforwardtootherpeople.
Keywords:Other-regardingBehavior,DictatorGame,EndowmentAllocationPro-cedures,Meritocratic,Egalitarian,ForwardReciprocityJELClassi…cation:C91,D63,D64
WearegratefultoJingpingLiforhersuperbresearchassistance.WealsothankParimalBag,YounghwanIn,JingfengLu,WongWeiKang,andseminarparticipantsatNationalUniversityofSingaporefortheirusefulcomments.Thisresearchbene…ttedfromtheresearchgrantsupportR-122-000-107-112awardedbytheFacultyofArtsandSocialSciences-NationalUniversityofSingapore.y
DivisionofEconomics,SchoolofHumanitiesandSocialSciences,NanyangTechnologicalUniversity,14NanyangDrive,HSS04-83,Singapore637332,e-mail:yeriyanto@ntu.edu.sg.z
DepartmentofEconomics,FASS,NationalUniversityofSingapore,AS21ArtsLink,Singapore117570,e-mail:g0402740@nus.edu.sg.
paper themselves off major describe agree n v v n adv adv v a v n n...21727 21712 21596 21585 21575 21504 21488 21470 21454 21339 21260 21205 ...
paper calculated and analyzed the operation effect of the check valve1 ...Δ— ΔP = hf qv 对于 流体是温度为 176 ℃的空气 , 密度为 21727 kg/...
this paper argues that the most important factor is the enlarging ... X Y= - 21727+ 01138* X1 - 01119* X2 - 01988* X3 + 01635* X4...
In the context of Chinese industrialization and urbanization, this paper ...21727 9 2.94 12 24 0.727 16 0.397 31 0.173 3 0.224 山 西 14 ...
paper n 424 23673 themselves pron 425 23629 off prep 426 23629 major a ...21727 plan n 476 21712 product n 477 21596 city n 478 21585 early adv ...
paper n 424 23673 themselves pron 425 23629 off prep 426 23629 major a ...21727 plan n 476 21712 product n 477 21596 city n 478 21585 early adv ...
paper n 424 23673 themselves pron 425 23629 off prep 426 23629 major a ...21727 plan n 476 21712 product n 477 21596 city n 478 21585 early adv ...
通过 理论载畜量与实际载畜量对比, 实际超载 21727 个羊单位, 25. 9% 。 ... This paper describes the basic situation and work status of grassIand ...
通过 理论载畜量与实际载畜量对比, 实际超载 21727 个羊单位, 25. 9% 。 ... This paper describes the basic situation and work status of grassIand ...
热门文档