How to Learn Any Language Quickly, Easily, Inexpensively, Enjoyably and On Your Own
44
ontological structure that reflects our commonsense view of the world and the way we talk about in ordinary language. Specifically, we argue that very little progress within logical semantics have been made in the past several years due to the fact that these systems are, for the most part, mere sym-bol manipulation systems that are devoid of any content. In particular, in such systems where there is hardly any link between semantics and our commonsense view of the world, it is quite difficult to envision how one can “un-cover” the considerable amount of content that is clearly implicit, but almost never explicitly stated in our everyday discourse. For example, consider the following:
(2)
a. Simon is a rock.
b. The ham sandwich wants a beer. c. Sheba is articulate.
d. Jon bought a brick house. e. Carlos likes to play bridge. f. Jon enjoyed the book.
g. Jon visited a house on every street.
Although they tend to use the least number of words to con-vey a particular thought (perhaps for computational effec-tiveness, as Givon (1984) once suggested), speakers of ordi-nary language clearly understand the sentences in (2) as follows:
(3) a. Simon is [as solid as] a rock.
b. The [person eating the] ham sandwich wants a beer. c. Sheba is [an] articulate [person]. d. Jon bought a brick [-made] house. e. Carlos likes to play [the game] bridge. f. Jon enjoyed [reading/writing] the book.
g. Jon visited a [different] house on every street. Clearly, any compositional semantics must somehow ac-count for this [missing text], as such sentences are quite common and are not at all exotic, farfetched, or contrived. Linguists and semanticists have usually dealt with such sen-tences by investigating various phenomena such as meta-phor (3a); metonymy (3b); textual entailment (3c); nominal compounds (3d); lexical ambiguity (3e), co-predication (3f); and quantifier scope ambiguity (3g), to name a few. How-ever, and although they seem to have a common denomina-tor, it is somewhat surprising that in looking at the literature one finds that these phenomena have been studied quite independently; to the point where there is very little, if any, that seems to be common between the various proposals that are often suggested. In our opinion this state of affairs is very problematic, as the prospect of a distinct paradigm for every single phenomenon in natural language cannot be realistically contemplated. Moreover, and as we hope to demonstrate in this paper, we believe that there is indeed a common symptom underlying these (and other) challenging problems in the semantics of natural language.
Before we make our case, let us at this very early junc-ture suggest this informal explanation for the missing text in (2): SOLID is (one of) the most salient features of a Rock (2a); people, and not a sandwich, have ‘wants’ and EAT is
W. S. SABA
the most salient relation that holds between a Human and a Sandwich (2b)1; Human is the type of object of which AR-TICULATE is the most salient property (2c); made-of is the most salient relation between an Artifact (and conse-quently a House) and a substance (Brick) (2d); PLAY is the most salient relation that holds between a Human and a Game, and not some structure (and, bridge is a game); and, finally, in the (possible) world that we live in, a House can-not be located on more than one Street. The point of this informal explanation is to suggest that the problem underly-ing most challenges in the semantics of natural language seems to lie in semantic formalisms that employ logics that are mere abstract symbol manipulation systems; systems that are devoid of any ontological content. What we suggest, instead, is a compositional semantics that is grounded in commonsense metaphysics, a semantics that views “logic as a language”; that is, a logic that has content, and ontological content, in particular, as has been recently and quite con-vincingly advocated by Cocchiarella (2001).
In the rest of the paper we will first propose a semantics that is grounded in a strongly-typed ontology that reflects our commonsense view of reality and the way we talk about it in ordinary language; subsequently, we will formalize the notion of ‘salient property’ and ‘salient relation’ and suggest how a strongly-typed compositional system can possibly utilize such information to explain some complex phenom-ena in natural language.
2
A TYPE SYSTEM FOR ORDINARY LANGUAGE
The utility of enriching the ontology of logic by introducing variables and quantification is well-known. For example, (p∧q) r is not even a valid statement in propositional logic, when p = all humans are mortal, q = Socrates is a human and r = Socrates is mortal. In first-order logic, however, this inference is easily produced, by exploiting one important aspect of variables, namely, their scope. However, and as will shortly be demonstrated, copredica-tion, metonymy and various other problems that are rele-gated to intensionality in natural language are due the fact that another important aspect of a variable, namely its type, has not been exploited. In particular, much like scope con-nects various predicates within a formula, when a variable has more than one type in a single scope, type unification is the process by which one can discover implicit relationships that are not explicitly stated, but are in fact implicit in the type hierarchy. To begin with, therefore, we shall first intro-duce a type system that is assumed in the rest of the paper.
2.1 The Tree of Language
In Types and Ontology Fred Sommers (1963) suggested several years ago that there is a strongly typed ontology that seems to be implicit in all that we say in ordinary spoken
1
In addition to , EAT, a Human can of course also BUY, SELL, MAKE, PRE-PAREWATCH, or HOLD, etc. a Sandwich. Why EATrelation between a might be a more salient Person and a Sandwichsiderable attention to below.
is a question we shall pay con-
how to learn a foreign language well It is ...read fast and you can get the meaning quickly....This means spending time enjoyably connected to ...
enjoyably connected to the language you are ...learn from the teacher in class will be easily ...potential activity: Do you know any other ...
to be enjoyably ___2___ in the language. ... meet more people and get __5__more easily. ...You?ll have to learn how to handle different ...
How to Learn a Foreign Language 5 Keys to Success ? Language Foreign ...This means spending time enjoyably connected to the language you are learning...
Unit one foreign language learning单词_高二英语_...2. Games help students to learn English enjoyably...12.Fluently:easily,well and quickly 13. relax ...
enjoyably, and the learning effect would be ...learn more effectively and that we can quickly ... no matter what our language or our culture is...
it is essential for students to learn and ...language acquisition, there are two different ...“dog” easily and enjoyably; also to arouse ...
it is essential for students to learn and ...language acquisition, there are two different ...“dog” easily and enjoyably; also to arouse ...
热门文档