英语论文审稿指南
Guidelines for Paper Review
I. Paper description:
o
o describe the summary and list key (most essential) ideas what were the main contributions ?
II.
III. What are the most important reasons to accept the paper [when you review for a conference/ journal] or why you like this work ? What are the most important reasons to reject the paper [when you
review for a conference/ journal] or why you dislike this work ? Possible reasons:
o
o
o
o has serious technical mistakes (describe them) isn't novel (provide/suggest related work/papers) doesn't demonstrate (all) its point by proofs, simulations, experiments (be specific) makes unreasonalbe assumptions (describe them)|
what did you learn reading the paper ?
what are the technical things that you appreciated ?
how does the paper relate with other works/projects/papers ?
which of them have been cited and which you know that are
related by they have not been referenced by the authors
does the paper describe clearly its goals ?
did the paper deliver what originally promised ?
what were the motivations (what issues/problems inspired
this research), assumptions (of the setting, requirements),
contributions ?
is the bibliography format/list of keywords complete ?
Are the figures readable ? Can you see the trend ? Do they
explain the trend or "strange behaviour" ? Do the results in
the figures make sense ? If
not, mention it in the review. Raise questions... IV. Detailed comments on the paper o o V. Comments on their references & related work: o o VI. Comment its presentation style: o o o o o o
Performance Review Guidelines for ManagersPerformance Review Guidelines for Managers隐藏>> Performance Review Guidelines for Managers The Performance Review Form ...
A P E R S O N A L V I E W HOW TO REVIEW A PAPER Dale J. ...provide a comprehensive set of guidelines for all aspects of the review ...
review paper工作标准_专业资料。一个reviewer给准备学习写paper的同学一些建议: 最近又有review paper的工作,突然想到把这个工作的标准贴出来应该最能体现怎么写算...
Review paper for M1-10_英语_初中教育_教育专区。八年级下册,英语,2014新版,复习资料,练习,单词Review paper for 一、重点短语 M1-2 1. 好闻的味道___ ...
Paper Review_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。Paper Review Image fusion can be defined as the process of combining two or more source images into Paper ...
How to review a technic paper_教学研究_教育专区。教如何有效阅读一篇技术文档paper.review Technical Note How to Review a Technical Paper Alan Meier ...
“Integrating Classification and Association Rule Mining” [Bing Lui, Wynne Hsu, and Yiming Ma] Paper Review Daniel Mallett CMPUT 695 March 4, 2003 The...
High Risk Materials Guidelines for ECDS Review ? Control and Declaration Part...Paper Al foil Ethylene Glycol Rubber Cu wire SnBi plating Weight Ratio ...
1 5 REVIEW PAPER Methods of embryo scoring in in vitro fertilization Tomasz B?czkowski2, Rafa? Kurzawa1,2, Wojciech G??bowski3 2 Clinic for ...
Paper Review Customer Experience Management in Retailing: An Organizing Framework 文章主要内容: 文章主要内容 “Survival in today’s economic climate and ...
热门文档