H. Akbar-Zadeh has recently proposed (J Geom Phys 17 (1995) 342) a new geometric formulation of Einstein--Maxwell system with source in terms of what are called "Generalized Einstein manifolds". We show that, contrary to the claim, Maxwell equati
Comments on the Uni cation of Electromagnetism and Gravitation through\Generalized Einstein manifolds" Atomic Energy Organisation of Iran, Tehran, Iran MPanahi@vax.ipm.ac.ir and z Department of Physics, Amir Kabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran Mehrafar@cic.aku.ac.ir
y Centre for Theoretical Physics and Mathematics
M. Panahiy,
M. Mehrafarinyz
H. Akbar-Zadeh has recently proposed (J Geom Phys 17 (1995) 342) a new geometric formulation of Einstein{Maxwell system with source in terms of what are called\Generalized Einstein manifolds". We show that, contrary to the claim, Maxwell equations have not been derived in this formulation and that, the assumed equations can be identi ed only as sourcefree Maxwell equations in the proposed geometric set up. A genuine derivation of source-free Maxwell equations is presented within the same framework. We draw a conclusion that the proposed uni cation scheme can pertain only to source-free situations.
Abstract
Keywords: Generalized Einstein manifolds; Finsler Geometry; Einstein{Maxwell system 1991 MSC: 83Exx, 83C22 PACS: 04.40.Nr, 04.50.+h
In a recent article 1], using the tangent bundle approach to Finsler Geometry, H. Akbar-Zadeh has introduced a class of Finslerian manifolds called\Generalized Einstein manifolds'. These manifolds are obtained through some constrained metric variations on an action functional depending on the curvature tensors. The author has then proposed a new scheme for the uni cation of electromagnetism and gravitation, in which the spacetime manifold, M, with its usual pseudoRiemannian metric, gij (x), is endowed with a Finslerian connection containing the Maxwell tensor, F ij (x). Following this sheme, the author arrives at a class of Generalized Einstein manifolds containing the solutions of Einstein{Maxwell equations. As for Maxwell equatins, they are decrared 1, pp 343 and 378] to have been obtained by means of Bianchi identities. We wish to point out the following aws in the treatment of Einstein{Maxwell system. First consider the treatment of Maxwell equations. Through some constrained metric variarions, and the use of Bianchi identities, the author arrives at 1, eq (5.55)]:
riF ij= 1
1u
j
;
(1)
Unification of Electroma... 暂无评价 10页 免费 Bursts of Radiation and ....1 Equation (2) provides a link between electromagnetism and gravitation, and...
A complete geometric unification of gravity and electromagnetism is proposed ...PACS number: 0450 Uni?ed Field Theories and Other Theories of Gravitation ...
is discovered and a new unification of geometry and electromagnetism is found...cation of mechanics and geometry that explained gravitation. It was just a ...
electromagnetism and gravitation, which he believed ...the unification of the basic concepts of physics,...leading scientific academies throughout the world. ...
The unification of electromagnetism, by James Clerk Maxwell 5. The discovery...One academic year—from September through June ? Different divisions of ...
The unification of electromagnetism, by James Clerk Maxwell 5. The discovery...One academic year—from September through June ? Different divisions of ...
热门文档