Peer Editing Checklist (use this as a master to either photocopy or transcribe, and give your responses to each writer in your group. Then each writer should hand in their peer editors’ filled-in copies with rough drafts.)
Editor’s Name________________________
Writer’s Name________________________
Assignment Name_____________________
1. Write out the question, problem, or issue that this draft addresses.
2. Write out the writer’s complete thesis statement. (Note: If you have trouble with 1 & 2, concentrate on helping the writer clarify the problem and
thesis.) Clarify whether the thesis sentence a) narrows the topic; b) makes an assertion about the topic; and c) previews the main points of the thesis as they outline the paragraphs.
3. Note with a wavy line in the margins any places where you get confused as a reader.
4. Write out your assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of the writer’s ideas. Assuming that the teacher is interested primarily in the quality of thinking in a paper, how will the teacher respond to the ideas in this draft? Where do you disagree with the writer?
5. Reread the draft, looking for quality of support for the assertion. Does the writer offer sufficient details to support the argument (reasons, examples, quotations, textual references, personal examples)? Does the writer need to research the text(s) more?
6. Write out at least two things that you think are particularly strong about this draft.
7. Make three or four directive statements recommending specific changes that the writer should make in the next draft.
developed from several sources: John C. Bean, Engaging Ideas: The Professor’s Guide to Integrating Writing, Critical Thinking, and Active Learning in the Classroom. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2001; The Little, Brown Handbook; and others.
But first, you have to learn what it means to “peer edit” and how to do it! What is Peer Editing? ? A peer is someone your own age. ? ...
effective_peer_editing_workshop_for_web_教育学/...either by putting a transparency on an overhead ...this; can you be more specific in your use of...
Java_Programming_Peer_Review_Checklist_V_2.0_...use the .java extension All Bytecode files use ... either the preferred “Allman” style or the ...
2. What writing approach does "peer-editing ...should use in order to produce accurate utterances...C. The teacher uses either inductive or deductive...
and as a result, they either ignore or ...use the comments they receive during peer review.... three steps: drafting, revising, and editing. ...
Editing Checklist for Self- and Peer Editing Class: ___ Author’s Name:___ Peer’s Name ___ Directions: Edit your written work using the Self-E...
editing a rough draft ? compiling a bibliography ...have arisen as a result of this new technology....Then do the Self-Evaluation Checklist either on ...
Either I Too I Neither Forms of Use Countable ...Editing Checklist Final Exam Answer Key Grammar ... but if you master this form, you will always...
master the format of a Job Application Letter. ...showing off your writing and editing skills; ? ...use good sales strategy, such as you-viewpoint ...
热门文档