水力计算中摩阻计算公式C-W方程的显式近似式的求解和比较
1 )aW[Reaexp(-ba)]
a)
4
(8)
ln(10)
b)0.4Substitutingforaandbineq8gives
1
)1.7372W[0.4573Re](9)
wherethevalueofaisaccuratetofourdecimalplaces.Ifadditionalaccuracyinfestimatesisdesired,suchatruncationshouldnotbemade.
Itisclearfromeq8thatthisrepresentationofeq1istrulyexplicitinthefrictionfactor,f.Severalap-proachesthatallowforthehighlyaccuratecomputationofWineq8exist.17-20Thus,eq8offersasimpleandhighlyaccuratemethodofestimatingthefrictionfactorforturbulentflowinsmoothpipes.Also,unliketheoriginalimplicitform,itdoesnotinvolveiterativeestimationoffthroughroot-solvingtechniquessuchastheNewton-Raphsonmethod.ResultsandDiscussion
VerifyingtheAccuracyoffValuesObtainedfromEq8.Toverifytheaccuracyoffvaluesobtainedfromeq8,1000logarithmicallyspacedRevaluesweregeneratedintherange4000<Re<108,andthecorrespondingfvalueswerecalculatedusingeq8.These1000setsofReandfvaluesweresubstitutedintoarearrangedformofeq1thatresultedinerrorestimatesforfvaluescomputedfromeq8
error)
1
-4.0log10(Re f)+0.4(10)
Allcomputationswereperformedusingdouble-precisionarithmetic,andtheLambertWfunctionwasevaluatedusingtheMapleimplementation(WaterlooMapleInc.)thatisbasedonthemethodpresentedinCorlessetal.(1996).17Figure1showsaplotoftheerrorinthefvaluescomputedusingeq8for1000Revaluesbetween4000and108.Themaximumerrorinfwas5.7×10-15,suggestingthatmachine-precisionfvaluescouldbereadilyobtainedfromeq8.
ComparisonoffValuesfromEq8withotherFrictionFactorCorrelations.Thefvaluesobtainedfromeq8werecomparedwithsomeofthemoreaccurateexplicitapproximationsoftheNPKequa-tion10,12andtheBarenblattformula.14,15Thepercentagedifferenceinfrictionfactorestimateswascomputedas
percentagefdifference)
(
|fPNK-fcorrelation|
f)
×100
PNK
(11)
wherefPNKisthevaluecomputedusingeq8andfcorrelationisthefrictionfactorobtainedfromtheothercorrelations.Figure2showsthepercentagedifferenceinfrictionfactorestimatesasafunctionofReynoldsnumberforthecorrelationsexaminedinthisstudy.TheapproximationspresentedinJain(1976)10andTechoetal.(1965)12wereverygoodrepresentationsofthePNKequation,withmaximumabsolutedifferencesof1.93and0.45%,respectively.Frictionfactorestimates
Ind.Eng.Chem.Res.,Vol.42,No.12,20032879
Figure1.Errorassociatedwithcomputingthefrictionfactorusingeq8.Atotalof1000fvalueswerecomputedfor1000Revaluesthatwerelogarithmicallyspacedintherange4000<Re<108

.
Figure2.Percentagedifferencesinfrictionfactorestimatescomputedusingeq11asafunctionofReynoldsnumberforsomeofthefrictionfactorcorrelationsexaminedinthisstudy.
fromtheBarenblattformula14,15thatisbasedonthepower-lawdistributionofturbulentflowvelocitywerecharacterizedbyamaximumdifferenceof3.88%.Conclusions
Theimplicitnatureofeq1hasrequiredtheuseofgraphicalornumericalsolutiontechniquestocomputethefrictionfactorforturbulentfluidflowinsmoothpipes.Althoughseveralexplicitapproximationsofeq1havebeenproposed,therehasneverbeen,toourknowledge,arepresentationofeq1thatistrulyexplicitinthefrictionfactor.Inthisstudy,wehavepresentedatrulyexplicitformofeq1throughtheuseoftheLambertWfunction.Inadditiontoitsexplicitnature,thisnewexpression(eq8)providesestimatesoffrictionfactorthatareaccuratetomachineprecision.Theconvenienceoftheexplicitsolutioncoupledwithitshighaccuracyshouldmakethisnewexpressionthe

method
turbulent flow in smooth pipe; 1 λ = 2 log ...correlation (which was based on the Prandtl’s ...“An Explicit Equation for Friction factor in ...
heavily on in order to determine the friction factor for turbulent flow. ... A comparison of smooth... 16页 免费 Experimental and Numer... 暂无评价...
For turbulent ?ow in the hydrodynamic entrance S. Barlak et al. / ...ow occurred; smooth and abrupt. The pressure drop and friction factor ...
A classical reference for fully developed turbulent flow in smooth pipes is ... the following nondimensional correlation for the Colburn factor j has been ...
13页 2财富值 Explicit Friction Factor... 3页 10财富值 A survey on the Kahler-R... 暂无评价 28页 免费 TURBULENT FLOW IN A M... 8页 免费...
Rzasa and Katz[5] derived a correlation for ...friction factor in the general equation for fully...turbulent and the tubing wall is nearly smooth. ...
The Fanning friction factor for turbulent flow in the smooth tube, f = 0.046 Re ?0.2 Heat transfer by forced convection for turbulent flow in the ...
friction factors and heat transfer coefficients for turbulent flow in ... tubes with twisted tape inserts; Friction factor; Single-phase turbulent ?...
Correlation of two-phase friction for refrigerants...The single-phase friction factor was predicted ...liquid and vapor phases are laminar or turbulent....
Explicit predictability ... 暂无评价 23页 免费 ...(1:1) where u = = is the \friction" or \...developed turbulent ows in circular smooth pipes. ...
热门文档