In contrary to authors of Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 126406 (2004) claiming "the band picture to be a reasonable starting point for the description of the electronic structure of NiO, much better than the ligand-field picture", we argue that the many-electron CE
CommentonPhys.Rev.Lett.’spaper”All-ElectronSelf-ConsistentGW
Approximation:ApplicationtoSi,MnO,andNiO”:
bandvslocalizeddescriptionofNiO
CenterofSolidStatePhysics,SntFilip5,31-150Krakow,Poland,InstituteofPhysics,PedagogicalUniversity,30-084Krakow,Poland
http:doc.guandang.net
R.J.Radwanski
arXiv:cond-mat/0605567v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 23 May 2006
CenterofSolidStatePhysics,SntFilip5,31-150Krakow,Poland
IncontrarytoauthorsofPhys.Rev.Lett.93,126406(2004)claiming”thebandpicturetobeareasonablestartingpointforthedescriptionoftheelectronicstructureofNiO,muchbetterthantheligand- eldpicture”,wearguethatthemany-electronCEFapproachisphysicallyadequatestartingpointfordiscussionoftheelectronicstructureandmagnetismofNiO.
Z.Ropka
BythisCommentwewouldliketoexpressourlargedisagreementaboutaconclusivestatementofapaper[1]inPhys.Rev.Lett.93,126406(2004)thatau-thorsFaleev,vanSchilfgaarde,andKotani”believethatthebandpicture[23,here[2]]forNiOisareasonablestartingpointforthedescriptionoftheelectronicstruc-tureofNiO,muchbetterthanpreviouslythought,andinmanyrespectsmoreappropriatethantheligand- eldpicture.”Faleevetal.haveperformedelectronic-structurecalculationswith”anewkindofself-consistentGW(SCGW)approximationbasedontheall-electron,fullpotentiallinearmu n-tinorbitalmethod.”gettingcontinuousenergyspectrum,abandofdelectronswideby5-6eVwithaspin-polarizationofeg-egstatesby2-3eVsimilartothatgotbyTerakuraetal.[2,3].IncontrarytoauthorsofRef.[1]wearguethatthemany-electroncrystal- eldapproach,knownfromworksofBetheandVanVleckfrom1929withpredominantlyNi2+andO2 ions,isphysicallyadequatestartingpointfordiscussionoftheelectronicstructureandmagnetismofNiO[4,5,6].Beingmoreexact,weclaimthatthecon-tinuouselectronicstructurefordelectronspresentedinFigs2and3ofRef.isnotrealizedinthereality-weclaimthatinNiOexiststhediscreteelectronicstructure.InourpreviousComment[7]tothispaperweputat-tentionthatthe”excellentagreementintheSCGWap-proach”ofthecalculatedmagneticmomentof1.72µBisbasedoncomparisontotoolowvaluederivedin1983butnottoavalueof2.2±0.3µBat300Kderivedin1998[8,9].Thedisagreementbecomeslargerifonecomparesamorerelevantzero-temperaturevalueof2.6µB.
Thedescriptionoftheelectronicstructureandmag-netismof3doxides,includingfamousNiO,isasubjectofextensivetheoreticalandexperimentalinvestigationsbylast70years.Inrecentyearsthetheoreticalun-derstandingbecomesasubjectofenormouscontroversywhenthelocalized-basedviewisopenlydiscriminatedinPhys.Rev.Lett.andPhys.Rev.BItisadirectreasonforwritingofthisCommentbyusasthepub-licationofCommentisthescienti cobligationofeachjournalconsidereditselftobescienti c.ItisobviousthatPhysicscandeveloponlyintheopenintegralscien-ti cdiscussionandinthefriendlyatmosphere,butitisalsoobviousthatinthisdiscriminationtakespartgreatmodernphysicistsactingasreferees.Thisdiscriminationisthebestproofthatthemostnaturalandthemostel-egantapproachastheCEFtheoryisisnotappreciatedinthetheoryofthesolid-statephysicsatthebeginningoftheXXIcentury.Despiteitweconsequentlydevelopanunderstandingoftransition-metalsolidswiththedis-creteelectronicstructureleavingitssolutiontothefuturegenerationofphysicists.
Althoughtheionicpictureisknownalmostfromthebeginningofthemodernmagnetism,inparticularfromtheseminalworksofBetheandVanVleckonthecrystal- eldtheoryandofTanabeandSuganoonthee ectoftheoctahedralcrystal eldon3delectronictermswehaveex-tendedthesingle-siteCEFtheorytotheQuantumAtom-isticSolidStateTheory(QUASST)for3dcompounds[11,13]bythecorrecttreatmentofthespin-orbitcouplingandtherecognitionthatthemany-electronCEFapproachitselfincorporatesstrongelectroncorrelationsamongdelectronsalreadyfromthebeginning.WestartanalysisofNiOfromthedetailedanalysisofthesingle-ione ectsandtheevaluationofthediscretelow-energyelectronicstructureoftheNi2+ion.Afterthecompletionwithinter-sitespin-dependentinteractionswehavecal-culatedthemagnetically-orderedstatewiththeNimag-neticmomentatT=0Kas2.54µB.QUASSTallowscalculationsoftheorbitalandspinmomentaswellasphysicallyadequatethermodynamics[4].Theinsulatingstateoccursbothintheantiferromagneticandparamag-neticstate.Wedescribeintheconsistentwayboththeparamagneticandthemagneticstatewiththedescrip-tionof,forinstance,theλ-peakatTNinthetemperaturedependenceoftheheatcapacity[13,14].
QUASSTcanbepracticallyunderstoodasademandtostartfromtheverystrongelectroncorrelationlimit
Self-consistent approxim... 暂无评价 9页 免费 All-electron self-consis......Kotani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 126406 (2004). [17] D. Pines and P....
arXiv:cond-mat/0209335v2 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 16 Sep 2002 Self-consistent solution of the Kohn-Sham equations for systems with inhomogeneous electron gas...
arXiv:cond-mat/0209335v2 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 16 Sep 2002 Self-consistent solution of the Kohn-Sham equations for systems with inhomogeneous electron gas...
热门文档