
The Impact ofManaged Careon Physicians
MaryGuptillWarren,Rose Weitz,and
StephenKuhs
This article investigates physicians'perceptions of how managed care hasaffected them, using data from a 1995survey of Arizona physicians.
Respondents report that participationin managed care has hadsignificantand largely unpleasant effects on
numerous aspects of medical practice:physician patient relationships,clinical decision making, work
conditions and settings, and overallsatisfaction.
Health Care Manage Rev, 1999, 24(2), 44-56© 1999Aspen Publishers, Inc.
44
The rise of managed care has been met with muchtrepidation by physicians, many of whom fear thatmanaged care will lower quality of care while reduc-ing their income and autonomy. These fears are re-flected in the comments that a surprising number ofphysicians took the time to write on the questionnairedescribed in this article. For example,
Managed care lowers quality of care, increases bu-reaucracy, increases physician and patient frustrations,depersonalizes the physician-patient relationship, andshifts costs but does not save money. (Specialist, 90 per-cent of patients from managed care contracts.)
The quality of patient care has absolutely diminished duetomanaged care. As a radiologist, this becomes moreevident daily in dealing with these organizations.Decisions are made by elementary school dropoutsroutinely. (Specialist, no estimate of percentage ofpatients from managed care.)
Insurance companies are practicing medicine without alicensealbeit "bottom line" medicine which is revenuebased.... [Under managed care] we will see a changefrom a trusting relationship with the family physician tothat of an adversarial relationship as people are forced toKey words:managed care, physicians, physician management,physician participation, physician satisfaction
Mary Guptill Warren,Ph.D., is an independent managed careconsultant, Tempe, Arizona.
Rose Weitz, Ph.D., and Stephen Kulis, Ph.D., are Professors,Department of Sociology, Arizona State University, Tempe, Ari-zona.
The authors thank Jennie Kronenfeld, Deborah Sullivan, and BradfordKirkmann-tiff for their help in conceptualizing this research and article.Thanks also to Joel Cantor, C.J. Hindman, Arthur Pelberg, Thomas Ross,Janine Rournain, Donald Schaller, and Shap Wolf for their suggestions onthe questionnaire, and to Anthony Yeung and Anthony Mitten of theMaricopa County Medical Society for their help in boosting physicianresponse to the questionnaire. In addition, Karen Maish and James
Carvahlo provided invaluable technical assistance with the data analysis.
Health and Medical care_教育学_高等教育_教育专区。英语教育Health and ... and that extending coverage to all would lower costs and improve quality....
Health and Medical Care Background Information 1 Health care in the United... and that extending coverage to all would lower costs and improve quality....
大学英语课件Health and Medical care大学英语课件Health and Medical care隐藏>... and that extending coverage to all would lower costs and improve quality....
Inadequate insurance and risk-pooling coverage ? ...Declining access of medical care and preventive ...Cost + 5% Retail Price Ex-factory Price ...
Drug companies say new medicines cost a lot to develop and market. The ...1. Health care coverage for all is needed to ensure quality of care and...
U.S.health care system_理学_高等教育_教育专区...costs of medical technology and prescription drugs ... such as declining patient choices, the increased...
From pharmaceuticals to medical products to consumer...health-care coverage with rewards for innovation) ...and declining investments in Europe and North ...
Health Care Market: Private Insurance ? Cost-...coverage and have restricted choice of providers ...Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs) – Consumers have...
Population coverage of maternal health care and chronic disease management need...provision of public health care would affect control of medical cost ...
E-Health, Wealth, and Happiness Ian Morrison Key...Pharmaceutical Costs 180 160 7.50% 140 120 100...care bashing Even handed coverage of very uneven ...
热门文档