Routines may help groups to effectively reduce coordination requirements when solving interdependent tasks. However, routine problem solving always involves the risk of a negative transfer, which appears if a routine is applied to novel problems even thoug
Routine Problem Solving in Groups
Torsten Reimer (t.reimer@unibas.ch)
Klaus Opwis
(klaus.opwis@unibas.ch)
Anne-Louise Bornstein
(anne-louise.bornstein@unibas.ch)
Department of Psychology, University of Basel,Bernoullistr. 16, 4056 Basel, Switzerland
Abstract
Routines may help groups to effectively reducecoordination requirements when solving interdependenttasks. However, routine problem solving always involvesthe risk of a negative transfer, which appears if a routineis applied to novel problems even though it isinappropriate. In this experiment, negative transfer wasproduced by first teaching individuals a procedure forsolving the Tower of Hanoi problem. Next, participantswere asked to solve several transfer tasks eitherindividually or in pairs. However, the routine could notbe applied directly to the transfer tasks but led to a longdetour. As expected, the individuals surpassed the dyads,who insisted more strongly on their routine. This resultfits with studies that corroborate the claim that groupsare prone to a “principle of inertia” when solvingproblems or making decisions.
Introduction
A routine may be defined as a well practiced problemsolving procedure, which has been applied repeatedlyand, therefore, does not need much planning but may beexecuted rather automatically (for an overview onvarious definitions, see Betsch, Haberstroh, & Hoehle,in press). Typically, in the problem-solving domain,routines consist of several single action steps that haveto be executed in a particular order. Even though thesingle steps may require some planning, the sequenceof the steps itself is usually highly internalized. Fromthis automation follows that procedures or schematathat have become a routine may easily be transferred tonovel tasks. However, routines are not only transferredto structurally equivalent tasks (positive transfer), butare sometimes also applied to tasks that share onlysurface features with the learning task. Accordingly,there is ample evidence showing that the successful useof a scheme enhances the likelihood of a negativetransfer effect, i.e., worse performance compared to acondition in which the scheme has not been repeatedlyapplied before (cf. VanLehn, 1996).
In the present study, we sought to extend theliterature on learning transfer to group problem solving.In particular, the study aimed at testing whethernegative transfer effects are more pronounced in dyads
than in individuals. On the one hand, it may be morelikely that a dyad recognizes a change in task demands.On the other hand, adapting a routine in a group usuallyrequires coordination processes, which may causeprocess losses (cf. Gersick & Hackman, 1990).Moreover, there are several studies showing that groupsoften tend to accentuate preferences or decisions thatare held by a majority (cf. Hinsz, Tindale, & Vollrath,1997). In general, if individuals are predisposed toprocess information in a biased way, then, groupsusually tend to enhance this bias. However, if groupsuse strategies more reliably and consistently thanindividuals, then, transfer effects should also beenhanced in groups, irrespective of whether this transferis positive or negative.
In this study, the hypothesis that negative transfer ismore pronounced in groups than in individuals wastested by asking participants to solve Tower of Hanoiproblems either individually or in pairs. There areseveral procedures that guarantee an optimal solution ofthe Tower of Hanoi problem (cf. Simon, 1975). In orderto produce transfer effects, participants were first taughteither the goal-recursion (R) or the move-patternprocedure (M). These two procedures differ in twoaspects, which make them suitable for studying transfereffects within the Tower of Hanoi problem:
(1) Only the R-procedure but not the M-proceduremay be directly applied to a transfer task in which thestart peg is the middle peg. (2) The two procedures leadto different patterns of move latencies. Hence,differences in move latencies may be used as anindicator of the respective procedure applied and towhat extent a problem solver insisted on his/her routine.Whereas the first study tested for process losses inpairs, the second study compared homogeneous withheterogeneous pairs and additionally consideredindividual learning.
The Tower of Hanoi Problem
The Tower of Hanoi problem consists of three pegsand a fixed number of disks of different sizes (Simon,1975). The original task is to move all the disks fromthe left to the right peg under the following constraints
Problem Solving in Group... 13页 免费 Difficulty in Problem-so... 31页 免费 Creative problem-solving... 18页 2财富值 Routine Problem Solving ... ...
Dynamic leaders use problem-solving skills to turn those lemons into sweet success; like lemonade! All individuals and groups come across problems. Some ...
Routine Problems – Nonroutine Problems – Flowcharts Defining the problem Fact...in Groups Disadvantages of Making Decisions in Groups – More Time Investment...
How to support groups in... 暂无评价 14页 免费 Solving period problems ... 暂无评价 26页 免费 When is Inquiry Problem ... 暂无评价 28页 免费 A...
Learn and use problem solving and decision-making technique ? Use creative thinking ? Begin the problem solving process in groups ? Reinforce and build ...
problem solving & project method_教育学_高等教育_教育专区。提出一个问题,...? It can be accomplished individually or in small groups. It involves ...
Problem solving skill_机械/仪表_工程科技_专业资料。Additional Materials on ...4)Matrix diagram:Shows relationship between two,three or four Groups of ...
7-Steps Problem Solving ... 56页 5财富值 2 Problem Solving Tools 19页...2007 Charts & Graphs To show the difference between related groups of ...
Problem Solving问题处理方... 84页 5财富值 problem solving--学员版本......university, students in other groups, books in the library, and the ...
宝洁解难能力测试 (Problem Solving Test, PST)样题_理学_高等教育_教育专区。...In which one of the following groups did all three types of industry ...
热门文档