JournalofCorporateFinance17(2011)167–188
ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
JournalofCorporateFinance
journalhomepage:doc.guandang.net
Theroleofshareholderproposalsincorporategovernance
LucRennebooga,1,PeterG.Szilagyib,
ab
CentER,TilburgUniversity,POBox90153,5000LETilburg,TheNetherlands
JudgeBusinessSchool,UniversityofCambridge,TrumpingtonStreet,CambridgeCB2-1AG,UnitedKingdom
articleinfoabstract
Thispaperexaminesthecorporategovernanceroleofshareholder-initiatedproxyproposals.Wefindthattargetfirmstendtounderperformandhavegenerallypoorgovernancestructures,withlittleindicationofsystematicagenda-seekingbytheproposalsponsors.Governancequalityalsoaffectsthevotingoutcomesandtheannouncementperiodstockpriceeffects,withthelatterstrongestforfirst-timesubmissionsandduringstockmarketpeaks.Proposalimplementationislargelyafunctionofvotingsuccessbutisaffectedbymanagerialentrenchmentandrent-seeking.Theresultsimplythatshareholderproposalsareausefuldeviceofexternalcontrol,counteringargumentsthattheyshouldberestrictedratherthanfacilitatedundertheSEC'scurrentregulatoryagenda.
CrownCopyright©2010PublishedbyElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.
Articlehistory:
Received30July2009
Receivedinrevisedform12October2010Accepted12October2010
Availableonline18October2010JELclassi cation:G34
Keywords:
ShareholderactivismShareholderproposalsCorporategovernanceSampleselection
1.Introduction
Shareholder-initiatedproxyproposalshavebeensubjecttointenseacademicdebateinrecentyears.Bebchuk(2005)advocatesshareholderparticipationincorporategovernance,andarguesthatshareholderproposalsareausefulandrelevantmeansofcounteringmanagerialagencyproblems.ThisassertionissupportedbyHarrisandRaviv's(2010)theoreticalmodel,whichshowsthatin rmswithexacerbatedagencyconcerns,itisalwaysoptimalthatshareholdersseekcontrolovercorporatedecisions.Otherstudiesareconverselyveryvocalinquestioningthecontrolbene tsofshareholderproposals.PrevostandRao(2000)pointoutthattheyoftensignalfailedprivatenegotiationswithmanagement,andmayexertnodisciplineanyhowduetotheirnonbindingnature.Legalscholarsaddthattheproposalsponsorsarelikelytopursueself-servingagendasorbesimplytoouninformedtomakeeffectivegovernancedecisions,withBainbridge(2006)goingasfarasinferringthatproposalsubmissionsshouldberestrictedbytheSEC.
Therecentempiricalliteraturedemonstratesthatshareholderproposalshaveanontrivialimpactoncorporategovernance.Ertimuretal.(2010)andThomasandCotter(2007) ndthatduetoreputationalpenalties,proposalsthatwinamajorityvotearenowlikelytobeimplemented.Ertimuretal.(2010)alsoshowthatthevotingshareholdersobservethetarget rm'sgovernancequalityandaremorelikelytosupportproposalsagainstentrenchedmanagers.Morerecently,Buchananetal.(2010)reportthat rmstargetedbyshareholderproposalsaremorelikelytoreplacetheirCEOsandelectindependentboardchairmen.
Nonetheless,itremainsunclearwhethertheproposalsponsorsthemselveshavethe“correct”objectiveofdiscipliningmanagement,orotherwiseusetheproxyprocesseffectively.Ononehand,whiletarget rmshavebeenshowntobepoorlyperforming,thereisnoevidencethattheyhavepoorgovernancestructuressuchasheavilyentrenchedmanagers(Akyoland
Correspondingauthor.Tel.:+441223764026;fax:+441223339701.
E-mailaddresses:luc.renneboog@uvt.nl(L.Renneboog),p.szilagyi@jbs.cam.ac.uk(P.G.Szilagyi).1
Tel.:+31134668210;fax:+3113466

2875.
0929-1199/$–seefrontmatter.CrownCopyright©2010PublishedbyElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.doi:10.1016/j.jcorp

n.2010.10.002
305 Corporate governance proposals and shareholder activism: the role of ...2000 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved. JEL classixcation: G34 ...
The Role of Corporate Governance_节日庆典_PPT...More foreign investors interested in a company ...Shareholder Value – Conflict of Interest between ...
1 the role of institutional investors in corporate governance, the motivation... in communicating with each other and submitting shareholder proposals. ...
also prevented them from having an active role in corporate governance. ... a number of innovations in the use of shareholder proposals can be ...
Corporate governance deals with the ways in which...Governance Mechanisms Board of Directors Role of ...Evaluate & Influence – examine proposals(提议), ...
shareholder, the principal–agent issue arises ...interest in the regulation of corporate governance....Role and responsibilities of the board: The board...
the internal audit plays an important role in ...The basic problems of the corporate governance ...shareholder,they will also play the function well...
role of shareholder proposals as a lobbying mechanism for influencing ...Hedge funds in corporate governance and corporate control. University of ...
improve the culture of corporate governance in ... voting on shareholders' election proposals prior ...Substantial shareholder: is a person whose shares ...
Current Issues in European Corporate Governance目前...(greenmail) and the proper role of member ...proposals did not introduce full reciprocity, the ...
热门文档