relationship between supplier and retailer
IndustrialMarketingManagement34(2005)863–



866
Thepowerofpowerinsupplier–retailerrelationships
NirmalyaKumar*
LondonBusinessSchool,CenterforMarketingEdgmond,NewportShropshireTF108NB,UnitedKingdom
Received28February2005;accepted28February2005
Availableonline11May2005
Inhisinterestingpaper,MartinHingleymakesafewkeyobservationsaboutpowerandroleaccordedtoitintherelationshipmarketingliteraturethathasbecomeincreas-inglypopularoverthepastdecade.Fundamentally,thearticlestatesthattherelationshipmarketingviewseespowerasalientoeffectiverelationships,asnegatingcooperation,andastheantithesisoftrust.Inotherwords,powerinarelationshipis‘‘onlyviewedinanegativesense’’.Or,alternatively,powerisviewedasnotimportantenoughtoincludeinrelationshipmarketingmodelsbecausefirmshavemovedfromtransactionalexchangestorelationalexchange.Itiscontendedbytherelationshipmarketingliteraturethatasadversarialandarms-lengthdealingshavebeenreplacedbyclosepartnershipsandlong-termcommitments,power(especiallypowerimbalance)hasnoplaceintheselattertypeofrelationships.Thearticlequotesmyresearchassupportingsomeoftheseconclusions.
InthispaperIwillarguethatmyconclusionsaboutpowerinchannelrelationshipsareabitmorenuancedthantheabovedescription.And,myviewofpowerisactuallysympatheticofHingley’smainthesisthatpoweriscentraltochannelrelationshipsandthateffectivepartnershipshavebothcooperative(positive-sum)andcompetitive(zero-sum)dimensions.Furthermore,despitecentraltendenciesfavour-ingtheriseoftrustandcommitmentunderconditionsofhighmutualdependence,itispossibletoseetrustingrelationshipsassociatedwithasymmetricpowerstructures.Attheoutset,intheinterestoffulldisclosure,Imustnotethatwhiletheopinionsexpressedinthispaperaremine,theyarebasedonresearchthathasresultedfromclosecollabo-rationswithseveraldelightfulco-authors.Myapproachherewillbetoconsiderthisresearchasabodyanddrawintegratedlessonsfromitratherthandoamoresweeping
*Correspondingauthor.
E-mailaddress:nkumar@london.edu.
0019-8501/$-seefrontmatterD2005ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.doi:10.1016/j.indmarman.2005.02.003
literaturerevieworapointbypointrebuttalofMartinHingley’sarticle.Ihopethereaderwillallowthisindulgence.Whiletheuseofthewordpowerisubiquitousineverydaylanguage,asatheoreticalconstructitismessyandcomplexconcept.Itdefieseasydefinition,quickunder-standingofhowitworks,andclearcomprehensionofresultingoutcomes.Aresearchergrapplingwithpowercanthereforeeasilybetrappedintodiscussingpowerasitisappliedineverydayconversation.However,thiswillleadtoerroneousconclusions.Toreallyunderstandpowermaytakemorethantheyearsavailabletoanyofus.Still,basedonmyresearch,herearesomeconclusionsaboutpowerandrelationshipmarketing.
1.Long-termrelationshipsdonotimplytrust
Intheworldofmanufacturer–retailerrelationships,mostrelationshipsbetweenthelargeretailersandmanufacturersarelong-terminthesensethattheyintendtoandwillcontinuetodobusinesswitheachother.It’safaitaccompli.Forexample,ProcterandGambleorSaraLeewillbesupplyingCarrefourandWal-Martfortheforeseeablefuture.And,ifthatiswhatismeantbycommitment,thenonemayconcludethesearecommittedrelationships.Butthenatureoftheunderlyingcommitmentiscalculativecommitmentinthesensethatthefirmshavetocontinuetodobusinesswitheachother.Whetheraffective(affectbased)ormoral(obligationbased)commitmentexistsbetweensuchpartiesisanentirelydifferentstoryanddependsontheleveloftrustandthelackofopportunismbetweentheparties(Geyskens,Steenkamp,Scheer,&Kumar,1996;Kumar,Hibbard,&Stern,1994).
Relationshipsbetweenpowerfulretailersandpowerful,albeitrelativelylesspowerful,manufacturerswhomustcontinuetodobusinesswitheachothermayormaynotbe
Building Deep Supplier Relationships_管理学_高等...the long-term benefits of investing in ...Power and Associates study found that suppliers ...
and bargaining power in SCs ‘Power’ in Supply...of exchange relationships within an uncertain ... but allows the supplier to develop their own ...
窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the ...of vertical relationships ---such relationships may...From competitive contracting to supplier partnerships...
relationships Determination of how changes in the business environment may ...奇货 可居 Supplier Power and Buyer Power Suppliers can erode industry ...
窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the ...of vertical relationships ---such relationships may...From competitive contracting to supplier partnerships...
热门文档