文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 高等教育 > 经济学 > the power of power in supplier and retalier relationships
侵权投诉

the power of power in supplier and retalier relationships

relationship between supplier and retailer

IndustrialMarketingManagement34(2005)863–

the power of power in supplier  and retalier relationships

the power of power in supplier  and retalier relationships

the power of power in supplier  and retalier relationships

866

Thepowerofpowerinsupplier–retailerrelationships

NirmalyaKumar*

LondonBusinessSchool,CenterforMarketingEdgmond,NewportShropshireTF108NB,UnitedKingdom

Received28February2005;accepted28February2005

Availableonline11May2005

Inhisinterestingpaper,MartinHingleymakesafewkeyobservationsaboutpowerandroleaccordedtoitintherelationshipmarketingliteraturethathasbecomeincreas-inglypopularoverthepastdecade.Fundamentally,thearticlestatesthattherelationshipmarketingviewseespowerasalientoeffectiverelationships,asnegatingcooperation,andastheantithesisoftrust.Inotherwords,powerinarelationshipis‘‘onlyviewedinanegativesense’’.Or,alternatively,powerisviewedasnotimportantenoughtoincludeinrelationshipmarketingmodelsbecausefirmshavemovedfromtransactionalexchangestorelationalexchange.Itiscontendedbytherelationshipmarketingliteraturethatasadversarialandarms-lengthdealingshavebeenreplacedbyclosepartnershipsandlong-termcommitments,power(especiallypowerimbalance)hasnoplaceintheselattertypeofrelationships.Thearticlequotesmyresearchassupportingsomeoftheseconclusions.

InthispaperIwillarguethatmyconclusionsaboutpowerinchannelrelationshipsareabitmorenuancedthantheabovedescription.And,myviewofpowerisactuallysympatheticofHingley’smainthesisthatpoweriscentraltochannelrelationshipsandthateffectivepartnershipshavebothcooperative(positive-sum)andcompetitive(zero-sum)dimensions.Furthermore,despitecentraltendenciesfavour-ingtheriseoftrustandcommitmentunderconditionsofhighmutualdependence,itispossibletoseetrustingrelationshipsassociatedwithasymmetricpowerstructures.Attheoutset,intheinterestoffulldisclosure,Imustnotethatwhiletheopinionsexpressedinthispaperaremine,theyarebasedonresearchthathasresultedfromclosecollabo-rationswithseveraldelightfulco-authors.Myapproachherewillbetoconsiderthisresearchasabodyanddrawintegratedlessonsfromitratherthandoamoresweeping

*Correspondingauthor.

E-mailaddress:nkumar@london.edu.

0019-8501/$-seefrontmatterD2005ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.doi:10.1016/j.indmarman.2005.02.003

literaturerevieworapointbypointrebuttalofMartinHingley’sarticle.Ihopethereaderwillallowthisindulgence.Whiletheuseofthewordpowerisubiquitousineverydaylanguage,asatheoreticalconstructitismessyandcomplexconcept.Itdefieseasydefinition,quickunder-standingofhowitworks,andclearcomprehensionofresultingoutcomes.Aresearchergrapplingwithpowercanthereforeeasilybetrappedintodiscussingpowerasitisappliedineverydayconversation.However,thiswillleadtoerroneousconclusions.Toreallyunderstandpowermaytakemorethantheyearsavailabletoanyofus.Still,basedonmyresearch,herearesomeconclusionsaboutpowerandrelationshipmarketing.

1.Long-termrelationshipsdonotimplytrust

Intheworldofmanufacturer–retailerrelationships,mostrelationshipsbetweenthelargeretailersandmanufacturersarelong-terminthesensethattheyintendtoandwillcontinuetodobusinesswitheachother.It’safaitaccompli.Forexample,ProcterandGambleorSaraLeewillbesupplyingCarrefourandWal-Martfortheforeseeablefuture.And,ifthatiswhatismeantbycommitment,thenonemayconcludethesearecommittedrelationships.Butthenatureoftheunderlyingcommitmentiscalculativecommitmentinthesensethatthefirmshavetocontinuetodobusinesswitheachother.Whetheraffective(affectbased)ormoral(obligationbased)commitmentexistsbetweensuchpartiesisanentirelydifferentstoryanddependsontheleveloftrustandthelackofopportunismbetweentheparties(Geyskens,Steenkamp,Scheer,&Kumar,1996;Kumar,Hibbard,&Stern,1994).

Relationshipsbetweenpowerfulretailersandpowerful,albeitrelativelylesspowerful,manufacturerswhomustcontinuetodobusinesswitheachothermayormaynotbe

第1页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • Building Deep Supplier Relationships

    Building Deep Supplier Relationships_管理学_高等...the long-term benefits of investing in ...Power and Associates study found that suppliers ...

  • Power in Scs2012 [Compatibility Mode]

    and bargaining power in SCs ‘Power’ in Supply...of exchange relationships within an uncertain ... but allows the supplier to develop their own ...

  • 窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the Firm

    窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the ...of vertical relationships ---such relationships may...From competitive contracting to supplier partnerships...

  • Porter's Five Forces

    relationships Determination of how changes in the business environment may ...奇货 可居 Supplier Power and Buyer Power Suppliers can erode industry ...

  • 窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the Firm

    窝-Transactions Costs and the Scope of the ...of vertical relationships ---such relationships may...From competitive contracting to supplier partnerships...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email