ClinicalChemistry59:71028–1035(2013)
ClinicalChemistry
GuidetoManuscriptReview
WritinganEffectiveManuscriptReview:
The6“Be’s”toSuccess
ThomasM.Annesley1*
Inthepreviousarticleinthisseries(1),Iprovidedpointersonwhatquestionstoconsiderandwhatinfor-mationtogathertoperformafairandthorougheval-uationofallsectionsofamanuscript.Onceyouhavecompletedyourevaluationoftheentiremanuscriptandidentifieditsstrengthsandweaknesses,thetimearrivestoputpentopaper(orkeystrokestocomputerscreen)andactuallycreatethepeerreviewreportthatwillgobacktotheeditorandauthors.
Unfortunately,peerreviewerscannotgive,likeRomansintheColosseum,justathumbs-uporthumbs-downorlimittheirresponsibilityto“yes”or“no.”Asapeerreviewer,youmustprovidethecriteriabywhichyoujudgedthemanuscript(i.e.,documenta-tionofitsstrengthsandlimitations).Whatyoucom-municatetotheauthorsandwhatyoucommunicatetotheeditorwillnotbeexactlythesame,becausethese2stakeholdersneeddifferentinformationanddifferenttypesoffeedback.Therefore,itisimportantasyouwritethemanuscriptreviewtounderstandthatyouarereallywriting2reports,althoughtheremaybeoverlapinwhatyouconveytotheeditorandtheauthor.There-fore,yourreviewmustbeeffectiveingivingeachpartytheinformationtheyneed.So,howdoyouwriteaneffectivepeermanuscriptreview?InthisarticleIhopetogiveyousomepointerstoachievethisgoal.TohelpyourememberwhatIconsiderthecharacteristicsofaneffectivemanuscriptreview,Ihavebrokendowntheimportantpointsintothe6“Be’s”tosuccess.BeCognizantofYourRoles
Asapeerreviewer,youhave2importantroles.Thefirstistoinformtheauthorsaboutthestrengthsandweaknessesofthesubmittedpaperandtosuggestwaysthatthestudycouldbeorcouldhavebeenim-proved(1).Thesecondroleistorecommendtotheeditorwhetherthemanuscriptshouldbeaccepted,re-jected,orsentbackforrevision.Thisrecommendation
1
UniversityofMichiganHealthSystem,AnnArbor,MI.
*Addresscorrespondencetotheauthorat:UniversityofMichiganHealthSystem,Rm.UH2G332,1500EastMedicalCenterDr.,AnnArbor,MI48109-5054.E-mailannesley@umich.edu.
ReceivedApril13,2013;acceptedApril22,2013.DOI:10.1373/clinchem.2013.208280
1028
shouldbebasedonthevalueoftheworkinrelationtowhatisalreadyknownaboutatopic,whethertheques-tionbeingaskedisvalid,whetherthemethodsusedtoanswerthequestionarecompleteandrobust,andwhethertheansweraddstoexistingknowledge.Atnopointdoyoumakethedecisionaboutthedispositionofthemanuscript.Thatistheeditor’sjob.Nordoyouindicatetotheauthorswhetheryouarerecommendingacceptance,rejection,orreconsiderationafterrevision.Yourreviewwillbemosteffectiveifitdoesdonotsayanythingthatwillputtheeditorinadifficultorno-winsituation.BeOrganized
Beforeyoubegintowritethereview,makesureyouareorganizedinwhatyouwanttosayandwhatevidenceyouaregoingtopresenttosupportyourcommentstotheauthorandtheeditor.Ataminimum,youwanttoprovidetheauthorswith(a)asummaryofthepaper,(b)alistingofmajorcomments,and(c)alistingofminorcomments.Trytopresentyourcommentsinanorderthatallowstheauthorstobestfollowyourpoints.Finally,writeupaseparateappraisalofthemanuscriptalongwithanyspecialcomments,andplacethesema-terialsinthesectionoftheevaluationformdesignatedforcommentstotheeditor.Rememberthatrecom-mendationsregardingsuitabilityforpublicationgoonlytotheeditor.
Whenyouorganizethereview,rememberthattheeditorcanseeallofyourcommentstotheauthors,sothereisnoreasontopastethesamecommentsintothesectioncontainingthecommentstotheeditor.Doingsomayseemimpressivebecauseyouhavenowdoubledtheoveralllengthofthepeerreviewreport,butyouhavenotaddedanyvalue.
SUMMARY
Irecommendthatyouwriteasummaryparagraphde-scribingthecontentofthemanuscript,thehypothesisorgoalofthestudy,theexperimentaldesign,themajorresults,andtheconclusionsmadebytheauthors.Butwhyspendtimesummarizingthepaper?Don’ttheau-thorsknowwhattheywroteabout?Thereareseveralreasonswhyaddingaparagraphthatsummarizesthestudydescribedinthesubmittedmanuscriptcanbebeneficialtoeveryone,includingyou.First,asummary
英语科技论文写作与发表 ? Check the “Guide for ...“An example to illustrate details of manuscript ...A review of magnetic refrigerator and heat pump ...
Part 1 Manuscript Form 13页 免费 Part 1 Manuscript Form 24页 20财富值 ...Critic Dorothy Parker was unambiguous in her review of the book: “This ...
3、是否记住了自己的文章编号(The manuscript ... 科学堂有一篇文章出现 required review completed ...Neither the entire paper nor any part of its ...
part of the work, could not have been completed or the manuscript could ... Book Review of Testcra... 暂无评价 3页 1.00 Guide to Scientific ...
论文全过程经典经验(重要的资料)_物理_自然科学_...manuscript into the formal review process in its ...? ? 严格参照所投期刊的Guide for Authors,进 行...
发表SCI论文全过程经验回顾_数学_自然科学_专业资料...manuscript into the formal review process in its ...? ? 严格参照所投期刊的Guide for Authors,进 行...
Part I: Publication & Peer Review When you are embroiled in publishing a ...also to guide the editor to making the right decision about a manuscript....
论文总体质量把关 Manuscript Editor -文字编辑、核对修改细节 - Associate Editor = Reviewers Manuscript Review Process Preliminary Screening Assign to Associate ...
manuscript 怎样写作科技论文 Main complaints of ... include review articles as appropriate 引用主要...Conform strictly to the Guide for Authors严格遵循...
21 9.4 四、如何写好论文讨论部分:科学论文的讨论...manuscript titled “Paper Title” (ID: 文章稿号...A: Please find enclosed for your review an ...
热门文档