为什么六西格玛不是全面质量管理
Why Six Sigma is not TQM
By
Thomas Pyzdek*
February 2001
My colleagues often tell me that there is no real difference between Six Sigma and TQM. "Show me where Six Sigma involves anything new." Six Sigma employs some of the same
tried-and-true tools and techniques of TQM. Both Six Sigma and TQM emphasize the importance of top-down support and leadership. Both approaches make it clear that continuous improvement of quality is critical to long-term business success. The PDSA cycle used in TQM is not fundamentally different than the Six Sigma DMAIC cycle.
But there are differences. Critical differences. And these differences explain why the popularity of TQM has waned, while Six Sigma's popularity continues to grow.
The difference, in a word, is management. TQM provided only very broad guidelines for management to follow. Guidelines so abstract and general that only the most gifted leaders were able to knit together a successful deployment strategy for TQM. Business magazines and newspapers reported widespread failure of TQM efforts. True, solid research showed that organizations which succeeded in successfully implementing TQM reaped substantial rewards. But the low probability of success deterred many organizations from trying TQM. Instead, many organizations opted for ISO 9000. ISO 9000 promises not world-class performance levels, but "standard" performance. But it provides clear criteria and a guarantee that meeting these criteria will result in recognition. In contrast, TQM offered a mushy set of philosophical guidelines and no way to prove that one had accomplished their quality goals.
Unlike TQM, Six Sigma was not developed by techies who only dabbled in management. Six Sigma was created by some of America's most gifted CEOs. People like Motorola's Bob Galvin, AlliedSignal's Larry Bossidy, and GE's Jack Welch. These people had a single goal in mind: to make their businesses as successful as possible. Once they were convinced that the tools and techniques of the quality profession could help them do this, they developed a framework to make it happen. Six Sigma.
Speaking as a member of the quality profession, we knew that we had a winning set of tools that could solve quality problems in manufacturing. Total quality control, invented in 1950, showed that product quality could be improved by expanding quality efforts into upstream areas such as engineering and purchasing. We even had limited success in using our tools to improve quality in administrative areas by reducing errors in service transactions. But despite these successes we suffered from a number of shortcomings. For example:
We focused on quality and ignored other critical business issues. Quality
trumped everything else. Of course, this made no business sense and often lead to
质量全面管理与六西格玛的关系。6sigma.GE的管理核心,与质量管理结合,相信会很有用。TQM & 6s 1 全面质量管理和 6s概论摘要:介绍现代企业管理方法中与企业生存...
六西格玛质量管理法介绍及案例分析一、六西格玛管理的起源与发展 近几年来,一股六西格玛管理的风暴正席卷全球,六西格玛这种新的管理方法在世界许多 顶级组织内开始...
应如何实施6-Sigma方法? ISO9000,TQM和6-Sigma之间的区别是什么? 什么是六西格玛?六西格玛是一项以数据为基础,追求几乎完美的质量管理方法。 西格玛是一个希腊字母...
是定位于一个关 于六西格玛、品质工具、品质体系、品质管理、企业管理的综合行业...Why Six Sigma at Starwood为什么喜达屋实行 六西格玛 ? What Is Six Sigma什么...
六西格玛与服务质量管理(2010.7.2)_经管营销_专业资料。六西格玛与服务质量管理Six Sigma 与服务质量管理 Six Sigma 介绍和客 服质量管理研讨 质量监控处 1 ...
最近,六西格玛管理创新活动已演变为全面综合 创新活动...综合管理创新定义 is NOT : 以提升质量为目的的六...Six Sigma “Endless Improvement” DMAIC QSS (Lean...
Six Sigma六西格玛常见问题解答Six Sigma六西格玛...方法 ISO9000,TQM和6-Sigma之间的区别是什么? 之间...六西格玛是一项以数据为基础,追求几乎完美的质量管理...
is Way of Quality ! 六个西格玛是质量之路! ...为什么做 ? Why SIX SIGMA ? “Quality . . . ...注重文件记录 ?重预防而非检验 全面质量管理(TQM) ...
*从管理理论的发展看6 Sigma管理模式 * 6 Sigma管理模式与全面质量管理(TQM) ...Six Sigma 六西格玛在GE 领先一步,追求卓越---6 Sigma管理模式 高 六个西格玛...
sixsigma六西格玛_DAY6-3_企业管理_经管营销_专业资料 暂无评价0人阅读0次下载举报文档 sixsigma六西格玛_DAY6-3_企业管理_经管营销_专业资料。 ...
热门文档