Perspectives
REPRINT
N°
379
Failure to Compete —Revisited
See your lawyer before gaining market share if you are a leader. What is best for the customer and the country is not necessarilylegal.
—Bruce Henderson, 1973
The Virtues of Benign Monopoly
“Failure to Compete” was a commentary on afundamental implication of the experiencecurve, or the insight that in many industries“cost and market share are inversely related.”Henderson argued that since greater marketshare leads to lower costs, the failure of amarket leader to extend its share and lower itscosts still further leaves the company needlesslyvulnerable to attack by aggressive competitors.Hence a leader’s refusal to accumulate moremarket share is “prima facie evidence of failureto compete.”
According to Henderson, failure to compete
The natural tendency of some layers in adeconstructed value chain to produce winner-take-all profits has brought monopoly andantitrust back to the center of public attention.Witness the recent legal challenges to the“Wintel” (Windows plus Intel) franchise inpersonal computing.
Twenty-six years ago, BCG founder Bruce
is not only bad for the market leader. It also has
Henderson made a strong economic case for
negative effects on the public. Consumers share
the public bene ts of “benign monopoly” in a
in the bene ts of having a dominant producer
now classic Perspective titled “Failure to
because, in any price-sensitive market, it is in
Compete.”Revisiting Henderson’s argument in
that producer’s interest to pass along a portion
the light of today’s events illustrates how
of the cost savings in the form of lower prices to
competition is changing in an era of
keep competitors at bay. Because failure to
deconstruction—and how it is not.
compete keeps prices unnecessarily high, it
1.For the complete text of Henderson’s Perspective,
1
see the accompanying insert.
amounts to a “self-evident restraint of trade.”
Boston Scientific Programme Update Keith Dawkins MD FRCP FACC FSCAI Chief ...(1) Target Lesion Failure* Stent Thrombosis *Ischemia-driven (ARC Def/...
经过近40多年 的发展,波士顿咨询已发展为一家提供全方位企业策略的 顾问机构,四大业务职能是企业策略、信息技术、企业组 织、营运效益。公司在全球34个国家和地区、...
亚洲销售汤料的合资企 业 ST——策略思路 开发新的微波炉加热电视食品 WT——策略思路 1.停止在欧洲不盈利业务 2.多元化经营,进入非汤料 食品市场 5、波士顿经典...
亚洲销售汤料的合资企 业 ST——策略思路 开发新的微波炉加热电视食品 WT——策略思路 1.停止在欧洲不盈利业务 2.多元化经营,进入非汤料 食品市场 5、波士顿经典...
热门文档