写作
Chapter 4
RESPONDING TO EDITORS AND REFEREES
You have sent a polished version of your manuscript to a journal, and after a few months, you will receive a packet with an editor’s letter and anonymous reviews by 2–4 referees. Each review will be a critique that includes an overall evaluation and a list of items that need improving. Based on the reviews, the editor’s letter will put your paper into one of three categories:
The manuscript is accepted, pending specified changes.
The manuscript requires revision and re-review.
The manuscript is rejected.
You should have started the road to publication by submitting your manu-script to a demanding journal, one with a high rejection rate. If your manuscript is rejected, use the referees’ comments to make improvements, and submit the paper to another journal.
1. HOMEWORK
After all your work, stay confident. You are going to publish your paper in this journal or in some other. Regardless of the editor’s letter, use this as an opportunity to make improvements. Even good papers can use more work.
Therefore, before you face the details of the referees’ comments, assign your-self some homework, beginning with reading. Find a new review article on the subject of your research, a review that you have not yet studied. Read the article and jot down each point that differs from what you have written, that agrees with what you have written, that expands on what you have written, or that fills a gap in what you have written. For every one of these points, make a change in your manuscript:
Differences. If the article says something different from your manuscript, either change your manuscript or add a note such as “Smith et al. (2008) present an alternative view.”
Agreements. If the article cites a new supportive reference, consider adding it to your manuscript.
Further detail. If the article includes relevant information beyond what you have written, add a summary statement to your manuscript with full references.
Gap-fillers. If the article presents relevant information that you did not know, add the information to your manuscript, with references.
M.J. Katz, From Research to Manuscript, 179© Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
Editors and referees will provide plenty of help and advice. ? This includes rewriting suggestions when necessary. Writing for non-native English speakers ?...
Generally accepted by editors and referees IMRAD成为通用的科技文章结构 ? ? ? ? ? 最简单最逻辑化最经济的结构 I: 研究的问题是什么? M: 怎样研究这个...
Often several editors. ? Papers sent out to review will be seen by 2-4...Responding to referees ? Persuasion and diplomacy are key. ? Put yourself ...
How to deal with editors and referees ? How to write a proposal ? How to attend a conference and give a presentation ? How to prepare an interview ...
Editors and referees cannot be expected to act as linguistic consultants Papers can be rejected because they are difficult to understand Try to think and ...
editors and referees 132 25 Correcting proofs 26 Authors’ responsibilities Further reading Index 164 152 Literature needed on your desk 150 Literature cited ...
? Responding to referees’ comments ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Read referees‘ report and put away for a day! Read them again! Respond to each and every...
Generally accepted by editors and referees IMRAD成为通用的科技文章结构 ? ? ? ? ? 最简单最逻辑化最经济的结构 I: 研究的问题是什么? 研究的问题是什么? ...
Responding to referees’ comments ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Read referees’ report and put away for a day! Read them again! Respond to each and every ...
What can be done to speed up the publication process and make it less agonizing and more efficient? Both editors and referees could help. Referees need...
热门文档