a simple biomass-based length-cohort analysis for estimating biomass and fishing mortality
TransactionsoftheAmericanFisheriesSociety139:911–924,2010ÓCopyrightbytheAmericanFisheriesSociety2010DOI:10.1577/T09-041.1
[Article]
ASimpleBiomass-BasedLength-CohortAnalysisfor
EstimatingBiomassandFishingMortality
CHANGIKZHANG
PukyongNationalUniversity,599-1,Daeyeon3-Dong,Nam-Gu,Busan608-737,Korea
BERNARDA.MEGREY*
NationalMarineFisheriesService,AlaskaFisheriesScienceCenter,7600SandPointWayNortheast,Seattle,Washington98115,USA
Abstract.—Abiomass-basedlength-cohortanalysis(LCA)wasexaminedforitsperformanceinestimatingtotalstockbiomassandfishingmortality(F)forapopulationinequilibrium.WecomparedtwoLCAmethods—(1)anumbers-basedLCAthatreliesoncatchnumbersatlengthasinputdataand(2)anewbiomass-basedLCAthatreliesoncatchbiomassatlength—byapplyingbothtosimulateddatathatgenerallyfollowedcharacteristicsofPacificchubmackerelScomberjaponicusinKoreanwaters.Weinvestigatedtheeffectsofusingtwolengthaggregationmethods,twodatasimulationmethods,andthreeexpressionsofweightgrowth(i.e.,exponentialgrowthoverthelengthincrementoftheanalysis,arithmeticmeangrowth,andgeometricmeangrowth).BiomassandFwereestimatedfromthenewmodelandcomparedwiththoseestimatedfromthenumbers-basedLCAmodel.Asensitivityanalysiswasperformedtounderstandwhichaspectofthemodelparameterscontrolledtheresults.SensitivitytoestimatesofterminalFwasalsoexamined.Resultsoftheanalysisshowedthattheallometricpowercoefficientbwasthemostimportantmodelparameterandthatsensitivityofbiomass-basedLCAtoterminalFwassimilartothatofnumbers-basedLCA.MonteCarlosimulationwasusedtoevaluatetheequilibriumassumptionandtocalculateconfidenceintervalsforbiomassestimates.Weappliedthebiomass-basedLCAmodeltodatafornorthernrocksoleLepidopsettapolyxystraintheeasternBeringSea.Acomparisonofbiomass-basedLCApopulationbiomassestimateswithnorthernrocksoleresearchsurveybiomassestimatesshowedgoodagreementbetweenthetwotypesofestimates.Thebiomass-basedLCAdescribedinthisstudyisuniqueinthatitincorporatesgrowthexplicitlyintotheestimationprocedure,whichcanbeusefulunderdata-deficientsituationswhensimplelengthcompositiondataandestimatesoftotalcatchbiomassfromjustonesamplingyeararetheonlyavailabledata.
Cohortanalysisanditsstatisticalvariantsarethemostwidelyusedmethodsforestimatingthesizeoffishstocks.Theserelyoncatchinnumbersatage(Pope1972)orcatchinbiomassatage(ZhangandSullivan1988).Thesedatarequiretheuseofanage–lengthkeytoestimateage.However,sometimesagedeterminationforthestockofinterestisdifficultorimpossibletocarryout,anditisoftenacostlyprocedure.
EstimatesfromtheFoodandAgricultureOrganiza-tionoftheUnitedNations(2005)indicatethat20%ofworldwideexploitedfishpopulationseitherhavenoassessmentinformationortheavailableinformationisnotsufficientlyreliabletoallowanestimateofthestateofexploitation.Indata-deficientsituations,traditionalage-structuredstockassessmentmodelscannotbeapplied.Simplemethodsthatrelyonminimaldatarequirementsareneeded.Analternativeistouse
*Correspondingauthor:bern.megrey@noaa.govReceivedMarch5,2009;acceptedDecember13,2009PublishedonlineMay6,2010methodsthatrelyonlengthcompositionandcatchdata(Jones1979,1984;SchnuteandFournier1980;PaulyandDavid1980;Pauly1987;LaiandGallucci1988;Fournieretal.1990;Methot2000;Bulletal.2005).Somemethodstakeadvantageofbothdatasources(Kirkwood1983).Oneofthefundamentalassumptionsoflength-cohortmethodsthatuselengthcompositiondataisthatthestockisatequilibrium,withnovariationinexploitationovertimeandnovariationinyear-classstrength.Underequilibriumconditions,lengthcompo-sitiondatawillbestableovertime.Werefertothisaslength-cohortanalysis(LCA).Allofthesemethodsproducepopulationestimatesintermsofnumbers.Thecatchbiomasshastobeconvertedintonumericabundance,andLCAabundanceestimateshavetobeconvertedbackintobiomass,whichisoftenmoremeaningfulformanagementpurposes(i.e.,totalallowablecatch[TAC],orcatchquotas).Forexample,fisheriesmanagerssetTACsbyweightinmostmarinefisheries.Fishermenthemselvesareusuallyinterestedinthetotalweightofthecatchforeconomicreasonsandoftenrecord,report,andprocesscatchinunitsof
911
Estimating canopy closure density and above-ground tree biomass using partial least square metho_专业资料。Junlfoet eerh(022()1116oraoFrsysac21)32:9—9 ...
Estimating canopy closure density and above-ground tree biomass using partial least square metho_专业资料。Junlfoet eerh(022()1116oraoFrsysac21)32:9—9 ...
热门文档