Geoforum33(2002)


153–164
doc.guandang.net
Ontheunitsofgeographicaleconomics
JoshuaOlsen
*
SchoolofGeographicalSciences,UniversityofBristol,UniversityRoad,BristolBS81SS,UK
Received2October2000;inrevisedform4September2001
Abstract
Thenew‘geographicaleconomics’introducedbyPaulKrugmanandothershasbeendismissedbygeographersforanumberofreasons,rangingfrom(mis)treatmentofexternalitiestorelianceonformalmodelling.Thesecriticismsmaybeappropriate,buttheymisssomeunderlyingunitassumptionsthatcausegeographicaleconomicstodealpoorlywithissuesofscaleandspace.ThetheoriesproducedbyKrugmanandothersrelyontheeconomicunitsofthe rm,industryandeconomyforanalysis.Incontrast,geog-raphersoftenusespatialunitswhichnotonlyrevealdi erentprocesses,butcanalsodelimittheeconomicunits.Acknowledgementofthedi erenceintheassumedunitsofanalysisbetweengeographicaleconomicsandeconomicgeographyisnecessarybeforeanyusefuldiscoursebetweenthetwo eldscanoccur.Ó2002ElsevierScienceLtd.Allrightsreserved.
Keywords:Geographicaleconomics;Neweconomicgeography;PaulKrugman;Units;Agglomeration
1.Introduction
In1991,PaulKrugmanpublishedashorttextandseriesofarticlesonwhathetermed‘geographicaleco-nomics’.1Inhisownwords,thepointoftheseincur-sionswastoprove rstthat‘spacematters’tothestudyofeconomicactivity(Krugman,1991a,p.8),andsecondthat,‘itisnowtimetoattempttoincorporatethein-sightsofthelongbutinformaltraditioninthisareaintoformalmodels’(Krugman,1991b,p.484).Since1991,Krugmanandhisfollowershaveelaborateduponhisoriginalmodelandthereasonsthatthisnewgeo-graphicaleconomicsissuperiortootherexplanationsofthespatialpatternofeconomicactivity.ThelatestsummaryofKrugman’sapproachappearsinTheSpa-tialEconomy:Cities,Regions,andInternationalTrade,whichheco-authoredwithMasahisaFujitaandAn-
Correspondenceaddress:14223GreenviewDrive,Laurel,MD20708,USA.
E-mailaddress:joshua.olsen@aya.yale.edu(J.Olsen).1
Therehasbeensomeconfusionoverthetermforthisbodyofwork,becauseKrugmanalsoreferstohisworkasthe‘neweconomicgeography’.However,inthispaperIwillrefertotheworkofKrugmanandhisfollowersas‘geographicaleconomics’or‘thenewgeographicaleconomics’or‘thegeographicalturnineconomics’inordertodistinguishitfromthegeneralworkofacademicgeographersconcernedwitheconomicactivity.Inusingthisconvention,IagreewithPinch(2000).
*
thonyVenables(Fujitaetal.,1999).Thistextnotonlylinksthecurrentworkconcerningthelocationofeco-nomicactivitytoKrugman’searlierworkon‘newtradetheory’(seealsoVenables,1998),butitalsorepresentsare nementofthe eld’sbasicformalmodels(cf.Krug-man,1979,1980,1981,1986,1990).
Nevertheless,thegeneralapproachadoptedinthismostrecentworkisbroadlysimilartothatofthelastdecade.First,geographicaleconomicsemphasisestheimportanceofhistoricalaccidentindeterminingthelo-cationofeconomicactivity.Thisconceptisrepresentedinthemodelsbyarandomlyunevendistributionofre-sources.Second,Krugmanandhiscolleaguespositthatcumulativecausationandpathdependencecanresultinanunevendistributionofactivityamongregionswithapproximatelysimilarinitialendowments.Essentially,successive rmsenteringalocationmakeitamoreat-tractivelocationforother rms.Third,thenewgeo-graphicaleconomicsseekstodemonstratehowincreasingreturns,linkagesandtradecostsworktobothmaintainspatialorderandcreatecatastrophicchangesoncebifurcationpointsarereached.Fourth,thesesamefactors,andespeciallyresultantscaleeconomies,areusedtoexplaintheevolutionofamulti-citystructureandregionalspecialisation.Lastly,throughoutthede-velopmentofalltheseideas,thenewgeographicaleco-nomicshasremainedinseparablyweddedtotheuseofformalmathematicalmodelstoexplainspatialandeconomicphenomena.Thecombinationofthisstrict
0016-7185/02/$-seefrontmatterÓ2002ElsevierScienceLtd.Allrightsreserved.PII:S0016-7185(01)00034-3
of geographical economics to illustrate some suggestions that these are ways ...assistance and policy coordination and so on, also conducts the strategic ...
The most frequent application in economics is the use of GIS to visualise ...geographical units of observation when faced with data from different sources....
Economics Short Run Long Run Law of Diminishing ...units Monopolist charges different prices for the ...Geographical Immobility Value the consumer places on...
of the core model of Geographical Economics Consumers in 1 Farm workers in...(goods) Spending on food Income N1 manufacturing firms N1 varieties (...
Economics Applicable to students admitted in 2009-10 1. Major Programme S6/S7 students Students are required to complete a minimum of 62 units of ...
Econometrics, the result of a certain outlook on the role of economics, ...units that are large relative to the population, particularly geographical ...
Furthermore, the dependence on geographical factors in China can be classi?...units, the reference values of ESR of 20,028 women tested in 291 units....
Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data Yan Zhang School of Economics, ... R-squareds, should not depend on the units of measurement of our ...
The core journals of economics_专业资料。This study uses citation analysis ...of thought (that have also tended to be associated with geographical schools...
the influence of geographical locations on the choice of FDI recipient ...at Economic Research Center, Graduate School of Economics, Nagoya University....
热门文档